Share from 0:00
0:00
/

When a Carbon Removal Marketplace Buys a Biochar Project Developer

How Wren’s acquisition of Pacific Biochar signals a new era for carbon removal, alternative exits, and the struggle to keep talent alive through the industry’s coming shakeout

Episode 376 of the Reversing Climate Change podcast. You can listen on Spotify (subscribe there for ad-free), Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or wherever else you listen. Paid subscribers get the ad-free version right here on the page.

Wren recently purchased a majority stake in Pacific Biochar, one of carbon removal's most prolific credit deliverers. What led to this deal, and will this model be emulated in a 2026 that might find carbon removal companies interested in (or maybe desperate for) deals that prolong runway and keep their companies alive?

Wren is one of the oldest marketplaces (and so much more) in carbon removal with a record of doing things differently. Sophie Westover is their Head of Climate and is on the show representing their thinking on this deal.

Josiah Hunt is the Founder and CEO of Pacific Biochar. He's been making biochar since before most of us knew it was a thing. He shares a lot of realness about the difficulties of being a project developer—even a successful one—in carbon removal.

This episode's sponsors

Absolute Climate: the only standard that’s developed independent of registries

Philip Lee LLP: legal resources for carbon removal buyers and suppliers

Listen to the RCC episode with Peter Minor from Absolute Climate

Listen to the RCC episode with Ryan Covington from Philip Lee LLP

Become a sponsor by emailing carbon.removal.strategies[at]gmail.com

Sign up for the 9Zero climate coworking space with my referral code

Resources

Wren

Pacific Biochar

"Wren proudly invests in Pacific Biochar to scale carbon removal"

In case you want to see Pacific Biochar on the cdr.fyi supplier leaderboard.

Benefit corporation

Kita

"313: Can carbon removal be insured?—w/ Racheal Notto & James Kench, Kita"

More from the show

Ad-free episodes and other benefits come with a paid subscription.

Carbon Removal Newsroom, the news show that ran alongside this one, is over. Its episodes are still up, on the feed Climate Workers Anonymous now uses.

Carbon Removal Memes is still goofing around.

The books that come up on this show are collected on my Bookshop shelf.

🎧 Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube

Paid subscribers get this episode ad-free. The ads in the free feed are inserted by Spotify when you press play. They are not in the file I make.


Reversing Climate Change is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


Full Transcript

Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening. This is Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of Reversing Climate Change, the podcast you are listening to right at this very moment. Before we get into the bulk of today's show, I'd love to tell you about our sponsors, Absolute Climate and Philip Lee LLP. I've made great radio with both of them. They should be familiar to you if you listen to this show, but I want to tell you about why you should learn a little bit more. The first sponsor is Absolute Climate. I did a show with their founder, Peter Minor, a few months back. And a lot of people love that show. I was asking a question of, can registries design their own methodologies for carbon markets without it being a conflict of interest? And Absolute Climate's thesis is no. They shouldn't be in the business of doing that. We actually need to disintegrate functionality within carbon markets even further.

Ross Kenyon: They are literally the only independent standards body for carbon removal that exists. Their name is very well chosen. I think they are some of the most aggressively idealistic people within carbon removal. It's come up on Reversing Climate Change so many times about how and why there's tension between commercial teams and science teams within carbon markets. There's some fundamental tension between the rules of running a business, or I should say the rules of running a profitable business is maybe a better way to put that, and climate impact. And I think Absolute is one of those companies that, at least from my experience of what I know of them over there, I think they're going to be some of the staunchest holdouts, just trying to make sure that there can be a justified true belief that a tonne purchased is a tonne truly removed. They're betting big on not compromising.

Ross Kenyon: It's an old strategy. I respect the absolute hell out of that. Absolute is very much doing things their own way and they stand out to me and I will never mistake them in a lineup. Go check them out. I'm seriously fascinated by what they're doing. And that's also true of our other sponsor, Philip Lee LLP. In fact, I told them to pitch me on some weirder legal shows. I really like doing shows about the law. I think the law is such a fascinating part of our shared social life. It structures so much of it. It's badly understood by most people. And just structuring deals within carbon removal is hard. I'm talking grown up deals here. Like when you're trying to put together an enormous package, complicated structuring. A lot of money changing hands. The stakes are high. You really do need a good lawyer. I'm sorry to tell you that if you are a startup out there in carbon removal, you're going to probably pay a fair amount of money to lawyers.

Ross Kenyon: There's just no way around it. Your choice is basically, do you get a bad lawyer or a good lawyer? One really cool thing I can say on Philip Lee LLP's behalf: Ryan Covington and I did a very fun show about how basically no one except for an elite few really know what bankability and project finance even mean. And he lays it out very clearly. If you'd like to go listen to that show, it's awesome. And it's linked in the show notes. And also we ended up talking about Ernest Hemingway. So it keeps with the tradition of Reversing Climate Change. One also really cool thing is that they just won environmental finances VCM law firm of the year. They've run it three years in a row, 2023, 2024, and 2025. It's the only award for legal teams operating in the VCM, and they have offices in the U.S., Europe, and the U.K.

Ross Kenyon: You should check out Philip Lee LLP. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for listening to this, and thank you to our sponsors. You really make this so that it's something that, in a busy life with lots of competing priorities, I'm able to keep coming back and making more Reversing Climate Change. Thanks so much for what you do, and now, here is the show.

Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening to Reversing Climate Change. This is the host, Ross Kenyon. The show comes out mostly weekly, and it covers so much of the deep dives within the cutting edge of climate tech, carbon removal, and so many connections to the humanities that really are important for making sense of a climate change world. If you love the show, you're listening, it's not your first time here, please open up your podcast app. Give this show a great rating and review in iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Spotify. Write a quick review that says that you really like this show. It is so helpful. I cannot stress that enough. There's also an option if you'd like to get rid of the ads that I don't read myself, you can pay $5 a month on Spotify and become a paid subscriber. You also get bonus content that no one else gets access to.

Ross Kenyon: And my sincere thanks. Today's a cool show. You'll notice moving forward that there's going to be a number of shows coming up, or at least I intend for there to be shows about alternative exits, alternatives to VC outside of the normal model of tech development. If you watch the show Silicon Valley, which by the way, I've been rewatching strangely enough recently, and it's funny to see how many things, with more experience, like that doesn't really work that way. That's not how that happens or that would never happen. That's not how this goes. I think when most people think of startups, and this is true even in climate, even in deep tech, that there's a passionate, youngish, wunderkind kind of founder. They come up with a prototype. They raise a bunch of money. And the goal is to IPO or to have some major acquisition and to become fabulously wealthy.

Ross Kenyon: It's all built around how software has developed. And that is no longer the model for how things are going. Insofar as that was ever the appropriate model for carbon removal and climate tech, it's less so now, specifically in carbon removal. Carbon removal is in a tricky spot right now. There aren't the policy and Department of Energy tailwinds that we were counting on for several years. The winds of change have come to the world. The centers of innovation may be shifting outside of North America or at the very least up to Canada. While there's still quite a lot happening in the United States, there's a big question of how stable it might be. Fulfilling a major offtake is difficult work. A lot of people think that once you get the offtake, you're able to relax a little bit. It is not so. It's hard work. Once you get the offtake, you have to fulfill it.

Ross Kenyon: And there are milestones you need to keep hitting. And if you don't have those offtakes, it can be quite difficult to generate enough revenue to receive future investment rounds, to demonstrate growth, to demonstrate traction. And I suspect, and I'm not alone in suspecting this, that 2026 is going to see a fair number of closures, of mergers, of acquisitions. And I'm interested in doing more shows about this. In fact, I have a couple already scheduled. And from my podcaster's lips to God's ears, I don't know if they'll get recorded. You never really do until they're in the can and published. But I'm trying to do more shows about alternative ways that people have exited their companies or being acqui-hired or ways of doing things that are outside of the conventional, we raised money from venture capitalists and the goal is to 10X, 100X, 1000X and grow into an enormous company that is very, very valuable.

Ross Kenyon: And there's a bunch of other ways of doing things that people have either done quietly or that are coming and haven't been announced yet. It isn't only going to be that software-driven model of success. We're going to see different things happening. Today's show is really great because it is about the Wren and Pacific Biochar deal. On the Wren side, I have Sophie Westover on. She is Wren's head of climate. What is Wren? We have a good laugh because what even is Wren? It's so many things. At least in my understanding, it originated as a B2C platform for selling carbon removal and other types of carbon assets that they deemed worthy of being listed on the platform. But it's also become a lot more than that. It's also a place where you can donate tax deductibly to various types of climate action. And because of the way that their company is structured, they actually have a fair amount of flexibility in how they choose to do business.

Ross Kenyon: And that means that they can work quite catalytically. They don't necessarily have to be scrapping for lowest cost per tonne and just trying to move units. A lot of it is about how do you maybe pay a little bit more now? So it gives companies more breathing room and allows them to grow. And one cool thing is that Pacific Biochar was one of their suppliers for a long time. And they recently announced that they acquired a majority stake in Pacific Biochar, which is really fascinating. Like, okay, there's B2C, but also donation, but also some B2B carbon moving mechanism that is Wren acquired a project developer, or at least a majority stake in a project developer. Josiah Hunt, who is the founder and CEO of Pacific Biochar, is on to talk about this deal, of what it was like getting to a point where you might even consider selling a majority stake in your company and that you perceive that to be the right move for the climate, for success.

Ross Kenyon: That's really fascinating because I think when we enter into the climate business, first of all, if you're here just trying to make gobs of money, there's easier ways to do it, right? Like it's a very difficult field to work in. You have to know a lot about science, a lot about policy. Basically, anyone will tell you this is very demanding work. And to the right kind of person, that's great. But it's not necessarily the simplest way to make a huge amount of money. Founding a company, there are so many things that you have to keep in mind. And it's one of those lines of work where, well, maybe there's a lot of lines of work kind of like this, but the decisions you make now, you may not know the full ramifications of until several years later. The term sheet that you choose, if you have that luxury of which investors to take into your company and put on the board.

Ross Kenyon: When everything is going well, to glad hand and pat each other on the back and laugh and share a scotch. In my mind, VCs are drinking scotch and celebrating your wonderful future that you're going to create and all become wealthy. And that's fine. As long as there is that up into the right dynamic with your company, but that isn't always the case. And depending on how much control you still have at the company in terms of board seats, in terms of ownership of the company, things could change. People that were saying that you were a brilliant, once in a generation visionary one week might decide that they prefer more competent, experienced leadership the next. Giving up control of one's company is a big decision. Josiah choosing to do this, I think is really fascinating because it enabled them to get a lot of help with cashflow.

Ross Kenyon: It enabled them to experiment with a new model for how to do things. And I'm really curious, are acquisitions led by marketplaces a future for project developers in carbon removal in 2026? Will we see other marketplaces make moves like this? It opens up questions of favoritism and conflict of interest, of independence. It opens up questions of, do marketplaces have core competency in investment decisions? They're typically not built for that. The kinds of people who work in investments or sit on investment committees at VCs or PE firms, they're almost like a different kind of person than marketplaces. And maybe there's some overlap career-wise. Some people are operators one day and investors the next. But they're not the same people typically. So like, is this the right move? Like if we saw other carbon removal marketplaces get involved in the project development business, it would be a big change.

Ross Kenyon: And I'm not sure marketplaces necessarily want to be in that business. They like having their independence. They like being isolated from the same risks that cause project developers to seek relationships with marketplaces in an acquisition framework. That's a complicated way of saying, if someone is coming to you because their product development company is having a hard time, are you sure that you want to buy that hard time? Are you sure you want to step in there? Is this a sound enough company that we want to be doing that? Those are really fascinating questions and we definitely do not want to see talent leak out of carbon removal. I think a big fear that people have is that we are going to see an exodus of talent out of carbon removal as times get tough. If the trends continue, the companies that are not able to keep it up in the next bit of time, many of these represent years of experience of founders learning the hard way what works in carbon removal, building relationships, developing that institutional sector-specific knowledge that is tacit, non-transferable, and that's going to evaporate.

Ross Kenyon: Is this a way that we can make sure that for the right relationships, the right companies that they can partner to stay alive and make sure that companies that feel this have this option? And why I wanted to do this show is because I'm not even sure that people are thinking on this level yet. They're not necessarily thinking is an acqui-hire possible. And a scenario that I might sketch here is I suspect there will be companies that are in a position where their runway is running out. Maybe they raised a couple of years ago and the time has come to raise money and it's not going well. And when it's not going well, the decision companies have to make is, well, we can change our valuation. We can do a flat round where our valuation stays the same as the previous round and do like a little bit of a bridge to the next stage, like city state.

Ross Kenyon: Or maybe you have to raise a down round. In a down round where valuations go down, it means that the dilution is so much greater than it was previously. And founders and early employees and even early investors run the risk of being diluted quite seriously and losing a proportional stake in the company to a greater extent than they would really want to. It's also possible that investors say that maybe the company doesn't have what it takes to survive into this next era and to wind down. If you are in this position and you want to talk about it, go ahead and send me an email. My email is in the show notes. Let's talk because I think there's room for creative solutions here. There are deals taking place that preserve the IP of the company that maybe are able to keep core staff going. It's just really fascinating to see companies trying to make the best of a situation like this.

Ross Kenyon: So Wren and Pacific Biochar being able to strike a deal like this, I think is amazing leadership. The deal deserves a lot more attention. And I think if you are at a well-capitalized company and you are able to think creatively about what is best for carbon removal and not necessarily only your company, not everyone has that luxury. It could be because being a public benefit company or a B Corp gives you some extra flexibility besides fiduciary duty that you're able to make decisions like this. But if you are in a position to try to make sure that companies are able to stay alive and not just their IP, but the actual staff are able to stay in carbon removal, you should be looking at deals like this. I think if you put out there that your firm is open to deals like this, you'll probably see some interest.

Ross Kenyon: The downside of this is that if you are at a company, the old yarn for this is that companies don't get sold, they get bought. And any company in a position to get bought, it's not necessarily going to be the exit that you get to retire on and buy your yacht off of. In fact, if you've raised venture capital, there are preferred shareholders that have priority over you in case of a liquidity event, and they're going to get paid before you. And if there's any liquidity preference, or even if the amount is just small that you're being sold for, especially in the case of an acqui-hire, you're not getting paid. Or if you do get paid, it'll be a small amount, but it's potentially more likely that this will not be the comically large check moment that you imagine in your head. But is that why we're here?

Ross Kenyon: Why do we have that expectation? I think there is something weird about going into climate, thinking that the goal here is to become a billionaire. I understand why that might be motivating to certain people. If you can make a lot of money doing something that's very valuable for civilization, that's great. That's a really cool thing. But most of the people I meet are not here because they sniff windfall opportunity. I think a lot of people are here because they're very concerned for the future and they feel like they can help. And so if you relax that expectation that you're going to become fabulously wealthy off of your climate work, and you want to make sure that you're able to keep this company going and keep the staff engaged and working on this, I think you should be looking at what are some deals that make sure your runway doesn't run out.

Ross Kenyon: That you're just able to keep going. Thanks to Sophie and Josiah for being on. I really respect what you're able to do here. I think it's so fascinating. I love that Wren is thinking on this level. Kudos to Wren for being so forward looking and courageous in how you structure deals. Hope you enjoy the show. Thanks for listening. Here it is.

Ross Kenyon: Josiah and Sophie, thank you for being here.

Sophie Westover: Thank you, Ross.

Josiah Hunt: Yeah, thanks for having us.

Ross Kenyon: Your announcement caught my eye and we've been talking about doing a show on this, I don't know how long now. It's one of those shows where you start talking about it months ago and then finally it arrives and now I'm here. What do I even want to ask you guys about? I don't even know. Probably best to start with the basics though. How did a deal like this happen? There is no other marketplace that is an equity partner in a project developer, as far as I know. Correct me if I'm wrong with that. And also just tell the story of how this deal came to be.

Sophie Westover: Yeah, I can jump in first. Wren has been partnering with Pacific Biochar since 2021. And we really have enjoyed partnering with them over the years. And we see biochar as one of the most effective pathways to achieve carbon dioxide removal. And when Josiah approached Wren with this opportunity, our thinking was this is a way that Wren can achieve impact beyond purchasing carbon credits. Our mission is to reverse the climate crisis, and we are creative and innovative in the ways that we deploy capital. We saw this deal as just yet another way that we could be innovative in the way that we deploy capital to have maximum climate impact. So that was kind of the origins of our thinking. But Josiah, maybe you have more to say on where you guys were coming from and how you approached the deal with Wren.

Josiah Hunt: Yeah. So, for listeners who don't know much about Pacific Biochar, we're a biochar production company. We're a climate change mitigation company, achieving that through biochar production and applications. And we're a California benefit corporation, which is something that we share with Wren. Which is a signal that we are a mission driven company, because built into the DNA of that is that not only does the board have to consider benefit to shareholders, but benefit to humanity. And those must be considered on equal par, if not putting benefit to humanity above shareholders even. And so we share that in our DNA. And that's really shown itself not to just be some words or ideals that we started with, but in the actions. And so when Pacific Biochar was first figuring out how to get biochar in the ground, which is basically an equation of the carbon has to be worth more in the ground than it is in the furnace.

Josiah Hunt: Because anywhere you have a furnace, you're generally going to be of size that you can also generate some sort of energy value. And so you have the opportunity there to burn it instead. So we have to make it worth more in the ground than it is in the furnace, and how do we do that? And before we did that on ag revenue and loans, we survived a meager existence for several years, but struggled to ever really get much scale and survive, with the mission always being to mitigate climate change, but never having access to any financial reward for the carbon services provided. So then, 2020, we registered the first biochar carbon credits for any company in North America. It was a first for us. That was a big deal. I think that's kind of around what I think is an inflection point in the biochar industry for us and many others when you could finally get financial reward for the climate mitigation services.

Josiah Hunt: But then the world's still trying to figure out, like, well, what does this mean? What is a CDR and how does this all work? A carbon dioxide removal. And we priced it too low. We underestimated the true cost of how to get this all done. And so one of our first deals with Wren, we priced it really low. And then we came back to them. We were like, hey, guys, we goofed and we need to raise the prices. And they didn't blink. They said, well, that's what you need. That's what you need to get the job done. And we talked about it a bit and they felt it was justified. They're like, okay, we get it. Yeah. Here's your new price. And I was just kind of taken aback. Like, oh my God, you're really here to support us. I felt like it was a team.

Ross Kenyon: Did they get the price for the credits that already sold?

Josiah Hunt: No, for the next round of credits.

Ross Kenyon: Okay, I was going to say, Sophie, that's probably too generous.

Sophie Westover: No, yeah. No, we try not to do that, but for the next round.

Josiah Hunt: And then not too long after that, we come back and we say, hey, we're having a problem because we are having trouble accessing financing. And we have a lot of opportunity to grow. And the opportunity to grow is having dissonance with our cash flow. And so we need to bring in cash up front. When you get some sort of financing, we need to get cash ahead in order to grow into, especially because there's a delay between our production and our issuance of credits. And so we said, we'd like you to pay up front for the credits. And they said, yeah, okay, done. Let's work that out. And it was just like, oh my God. And it was like a game changer. And it just felt really nice to have that support and to be able to work with a company that really seemed to be taking to heart that we're all a part of a larger organism and that they need to do what they can to support us in a way.

Josiah Hunt: And they were so very fluid and quick with that. It was surprising and wonderful. And yeah, it came later, it was earlier this year that we came to them and said, hey, we're in a pickle. We're at risk if we take this next prepayment from you. We're kind of in a pickle right now. We might increase our cost of debt. And it's not purely sure we'll ever actually be able to get that paid off. But if we don't take this prepayment, we sure are in trouble. And here's our finances. Here's what we've been doing to try and raise money. And here's how everything looks. And they're like, oh, this is solvable. That's pretty reasonable. This is like a cash flow problem. It's like working capital kind of stuff. Why don't we take a look at this? And then we took a look at it all.

Josiah Hunt: And they said, hey, why don't we join you as equity partner? I mean, it wasn't exactly that. I'm taking a big amount of communications and just squeezing them up. Anyways, it was in that same frame though. It's like, oh, you guys are facing an understandable contextual issue that we are in a position to help solve. So let's work that out. And that was my recollection of kind of how it went. And I'm sure from theirs, from our side, we were looking at internally, what would this be like for them to be an equity partner? And I'm sure they did a lot of internal diligence on the dynamics because right at the head there, Ross, you brought up a really good point, which is, it is a unique situation. They are kind of a marketplace, although I'm not sure if that's exactly how they would describe it.

Josiah Hunt: They're just Wren.

Ross Kenyon: I love that about you guys. Like, who else would even do a deal like this? It's really courageous and cool.

Josiah Hunt: Yeah. And so that's kind of how I felt leading up to it. And so I had to lay so much groundwork because I felt like all of those earlier things were very much in line with what this most recent transaction was, which was them identifying that if we're going to be doing a really good job supporting our suppliers, who are kind of the front line of putting the carbon in the ground, what does that look like? And this is kind of a result of that. Does that seem appropriate? Sophie, do you think I characterized that all right?

Sophie Westover: Yeah, absolutely. And I think you're kind of touching on one of our key priorities, which is we are willing to work with suppliers in the way that's best for them, ultimately. And that's across the board. That's not just with Pacific Biochar. And that means when I'm starting to engage in supplier relationships, I'm trying to understand what do you need now? What do you need today to succeed in the future? And so is that an offtake? Is that a spot purchase? Is that a pre-purchase? Is that an investment? And I think that having years of relationship building prior to this deal really helped make our decision making a smoother and easier process because we knew Josiah. We had gone out and visited one of their wineries where they were deploying biochar. We had kind of personal relationships with our suppliers. And that's one of the things that we really try to prioritize at Wren: breaking down the barriers between buyer and supplier, understanding their priorities, understanding their needs.

Sophie Westover: Having that kind of basis to work off of made our decision a lot easier. And ultimately, yeah, that's our goal at the end of the day, is what do we need to do today to succeed in the future? And in the context of prepaying for credits, we recently started using Kita insurance to help us kind of gain some more confidence. Risk management tools, I suppose, and deploying that capital and being confident in how we deployed that capital. So prior to the deal with Pacific Biochar, we had actually laid on insurance to the credits that we were pre-purchasing from Pacific Biochar. And yeah, I think that the TLDR is we will work with suppliers in the way that they need to. And maybe that makes us a unique market player that we're not just looking for the lowest cost, high quality credit out there, but we're really trying to think within a systems change perspective of what do we need to do today to get the system to a place where we're actually going to achieve large scale climate action.

Ross Kenyon: It definitely reads that way. And if you're listening and you'd like to learn more about carbon removal insurance, there's a great episode, a personal favorite even, with Kita that I'll put in the show notes if you'd like to go back and listen to. So Sophie, it sounds like Josiah is a long-time trusted supplier for Wren. Facing headwinds here, comes to you and says, the fundamentals of our company are strong, but we have some contextual difficulties, as he said, cash flow problems. And you agreed and said, okay, it seems like it is a temporary thing. It is a contextual thing. We want to make sure you do not collapse. Do not go out of business. Do not face some sort of panicked acquisition scenario. Let's stay alive and stay independent in this kind of way. Is that broadly correct? I mean, if you're looking at CDR.FYI, Pacific Biochar is, I pulled it up while you guys were talking. You're very close to the top of deliveries, Josiah, like among the most successful companies that exist in carbon removal, which is also fascinating. Like how could a company this successful also be in a pickle in this kind of way too? Like that's really surprising and scary for the industry as a whole, but sorry, Sophie.

Sophie Westover: Yeah, no, absolutely. And that's exactly right. Josiah came to us with this pickle that he was in. If we're looking at CDR supply globally, we're just going to watch one of the largest suppliers go out of business when we are able to step in and help them succeed. Wren was in a financial position where we were able to access a loan and able to send those finances over to Pacific Biochar and save the company. And at the end of the day, we just wanted to see them succeed and continue to scale and continue to be at the top of that leaderboard.

Ross Kenyon: Is Josiah a special one-off case? Are there others that you might look at and feel the same way about? Is this a pattern we should recognize from Wren?

Sophie Westover: I think that if we can prove that this model works over the next 12 months, then I could see a situation in which Wren does this again. I think from a buyer's perspective, the number of developers who come to us and are in similar situations, whether that's they just need operating finance today or they're struggling to get the investment that they need or whatever the case may be. I think the long and the short of it is there are so many great companies out there doing fantastic things and there's not enough money to support them. And if there's an opportunity where Wren can step in and provide that support, I think that that's a potential down the line. I think it definitely helps when we have a longstanding relationship with a project partner and we kind of know the ins and outs of how the project is operating, who's behind the project, you know, their management structure, that definitely helps. But I think, yeah, if we can prove that this works and we can prove that our customers and businesses that we work with are kind of down to accept our kind of theory of change, so to speak, and are willing to kind of support carbon removal issues.

Ross Kenyon: So exciting. I love it. I imagine Wren is the majority shareholder now. Is that correct?

Josiah Hunt: Yeah.

Ross Kenyon: You've relinquished majority control of your company. What's that like being an entrepreneur and going through that?

Josiah Hunt: Well, you always wish that it came with a massive paycheck or some massive thing, right? You still have to work, huh? I mean, that's not why I came into this. If a paycheck was why I chose this career choice, that would have been a dumb choice. And I've been really enjoying having Wren as an investment partner because one of my biggest concerns with taking on investment partners has been the change of focus. When we had been looking at potential investment partners, we talked with quite a few in 2023. And some early, sorry, I'm sorry, in 2024. And it was kind of disheartening, to be honest, how many of them were prioritizing profit. They would have climate or impact or something like that in their title or somewhere in some mission statement. But when you got down to the brass tacks, when you got down to the nuts and bolts of diligence and things, mostly it was like, hey, can we increase profit?

Josiah Hunt: And then you'd be like, yeah, here's some options to increase profit. All of them reduce impact. Here's how we can reduce impact to increase profit or something like that. They're like, yeah, yeah, yeah, let's do that. And so there was like this juxtaposition where we're really a mission driven company. We're really trying to mitigate climate change and we're getting there the best we can. And profit is necessary. If I thought we could have done more as a nonprofit, I would have chosen that pathway. But I felt as though a for-profit company was a better vehicle in this kind of environment, in this market space to achieve impact. But we're still very mission-driven to actually achieve climate impact. And I felt that with so many of the investment opportunities, this isn't to say all of them, but with so many of them, there was oftentimes a lack of understanding in the problem that we're solving because there's money coming from somewhere else and they don't really understand the whole climate action and environmental space.

Josiah Hunt: And there were very clear signals that the ultimate guiding light is profit. And they would want us to flip it. They'd want us like, all right, how are you going to achieve somewhere between 10x and 100x in five years and give us, where's our return? Where's our exit? We need a five-year 10x exit or 100x exit. And that's ultimately a lot of the pitch decks, if you're going to an investment firm, will often be kind of tilted towards that. Basically, the ultimate slide they want to see is how you are going to give them a five-year exit with 10 to 100x returns. And then everything you do is just how you get there. And that can bring dissonance into a company. And I've seen that happen to other companies in the space where they had focus on technology and focus on a mission. And then a big influx of money comes in and then there can sometimes be dissonance in the goals of what to do.

Josiah Hunt: And sometimes that can be resolved into a successful pathway, but many times not. And so the concern over bringing in investment capital and bringing on new owners into the company that would not be aligned in the mission and maybe have less experience in the space would result in an outcome that I didn't feel good about. And I know that's a very privileged thing to say, like, well, I don't feel good about the outcome, so I'm going to try and do something else. Or maybe stubborn, I don't know, maybe a little bit of both. But yes, it concerns me a lot. Not just being able to access money, but being able to access money that was not counter to the overarching goal of what we're trying to do. And bringing Wren on, even as a majority stake owner, does not feel at all concerning in that.

Josiah Hunt: Like you were saying, you started the question with, do I feel like I can excel? Yes. Like, it's like, okay. We got some really good partners here. And they don't have as big of pocketbooks as some of the other investors that we had spoken with. And that's its own set of difficulties to overcome. It's not as though Wren has unlimited cash behind this round. So we'll have to go at that together. But do I feel as though it brought enough in to get us to the next stages? Yes. And do I feel very comfortable with the new arrangement in the ownership? Yes. Very happy with how it all laid out.

Ross Kenyon: Sophie, how are you able to not put that kind of pressure on Josiah, five years, 10 to 100x your return? Is it because of the way that you're incorporated? Is it just the ethos of the people who staff Wren? Do you actually want that and you think that you're just the better way of getting to a very good return for Wren in a more ethical or more complex kind of way?

Sophie Westover: I think there's a mix. We are a public benefit corporation, so we are bound by our mission, which is to reverse the climate crisis. And I also think it's the ethos of our staff. And as opposed to trying to make the most amount of money off of this, we're trying to make the most amount of impact off of this while still being financially stable and having a profitable company that's able to continue to achieve this impact over time. So as opposed to thinking of, you know, 10x returns, I want to walk away with millions of dollars in my pocket from this deal, we're thinking about 10x impact and how do we scale the company and bring Pacific Biochar to the top of the CDR.FYI leaderboard. Yeah. And I think that that ethos is very apparent in all of our staff and with everything that we do.

Sophie Westover: Oftentimes, I think even just in the context of the VCM broadly, there are places where we could nickel and dime our suppliers and try to get the lowest cost per tonne and try to do it as cheap as possible. But is that the best way to achieve long-term impact? I don't think so. I think sometimes it's good to pay the supplier what they're asking for, as opposed to trying to get the lowest cost on things. And that's how I purchase credits. We've been willing to buy $35 cookstove credits, which is the highest in the market so far. But we know that by providing that high cost per tonne today, we're able to get the company where they need to be in the future and close huge deals with large buyers down the line. I kind of feel like I'm beating a dead horse here, but at the end of the day, we're not trying to make a ton of money and be rolling in cash and paying our staff ridiculous salaries.

Sophie Westover: We're trying to achieve impact and maybe that's a unique position or like an ideological shift in the way that investment has been done traditionally in any company and climate companies. I was saying that there are institutional investors that he was speaking to who really wanted that high rate of return. And that's just not our motivation. Like our motivation is to create a world where we're not sizzling up and burning and dying. I know that's dramatic, but that's actually the problem that we're facing, is an unlivable future for ourselves and our children and our grandchildren. Ultimately, I think that's why everybody at Wren works at Wren, is we want to create a livable future. And I think that there's, I might be going on a tangent here, but I think that there's a tension between like capitalism and the desire to make a ton of money and working as a nonprofit and like, where's the sweet spot.

Sophie Westover: And that's why I wanted to go into the carbon market originally, because I think that market based solutions can be extremely powerful. And when you pair profit with impact or become a triple bottom line company or public benefit corporation, when we tie incentive structures to like reasonable financial returns, I think that's when we see growth in the marketplace, generally growth in climate solutions, broadly speaking. I don't know if I'm answering your question succinctly, but yeah, I mean, I think at the end of the day, we're not like trying to make the most money. We're trying to have the most impact while being financially stable.

Josiah Hunt: Yeah, I'll interject there. Yeah, I agree. And something you said earlier, which I think is a really important one, you were saying that you're not necessarily looking for 10x returns, you're looking for 10x impact. And you talked about this kind of tension between the traditional drivers of the markets we work in, traditional drivers of capital, and then also achieving the goal of climate mitigation. There's a tension between these two things sometimes. And yeah, I think that's a really important part to dive into in some of what I saw in difficulties of accepting cash and finding cash and also why the deal fits so well with Wren. And so I just want to express a lot of sympathy for a lot of the funds that are out there trying to achieve this impact because you'll have some beneficial donor who's going to put $100 million into this fund.

Josiah Hunt: And it's going to be a fund that is going to go help invest in companies that are doing carbon removal and climate impact. And the directions of that fund is basically achieve impact and increase the fund, right? And if you're that fund, one of the best ways to increase your impact is also to increase your fund, right? Larger fund equals more ability to invest equals larger impact. So they're often kind of stuck within this model where they're looking for companies that can provide 2x impact and 10x returns, right? Because that helps achieve impact and grows the fund because they're not all going to succeed. You need those high returns because you're also going to have some failure. And so if you're a fund, oftentimes that's kind of the natural direction that things will go. And it makes sense. It's a rational position to take. But then that also can sometimes be at odds with a lot of the companies in the space.

Josiah Hunt: They're like, dude, I'm on the opposite side. You're looking for 2x impact and 10x returns. I'm the flip. I'm aiming for 10x impact and 2x returns. And I think that's a divide I see so commonly with companies in the space that they're coming at this passionately and they have a technology and they really want to help solve the problem. And they're aiming for 10x impact. But oftentimes there is a balance between impact and returns. You can't always equally get both. There can be a little bit of sacrifice between one and the other. And so I think that is part of the tension in the space that can make it difficult and why I think the investment between us made sense and was a fairly easy fit because we're both aligned in that same direction. 10x impact, 2x returns. Sorry, I just wanted to dive a little bit deeper on what I think is a pretty important part.

Josiah Hunt: And not to blame, oh, it's all the VCs, it's all their fault. They are making rational decisions based on the context of what they have at hand.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, their LPs are mad at them. They're all rushing to get their deals done by the end of the year. To understand all is to forgive all. And even if there are structural problems with VC dominating carbon removal or other things, we can still have sympathy for the actors caught within that dynamic. I feel those tensions too. I feel like everyone feels the responsibility of their role weigh upon them. I do like the way that you split this up, Sophie, in your elaboration on it, Josiah, of purely capitalistic organizations on one side of the scale and then pure nonprofit on the other. And maybe Wren is just choosing to split farther towards a nonprofit style and that unlocks a lot of creativity. A question I had related to that though is, okay, Josiah, I know you're a regular listener, so I'm going to do like a peak Ross self-parody kind of thing right here.

Ross Kenyon: This one sentence is so annoying, but I'm going to say it anyways. I don't know if it's from Anna Karenina or War and Peace, but the Tolstoy stand-in in one of those ends up liberating his peasants before the 1861 liberation of the serfs. And it goes terribly. None of them trust him. They all think it's some sort of scam. Why would a landlord do this? And insofar as what happened with Pacific Biochar and Wren, it's an act of charity or kindness. And you can dispute that framing in a second. But if it errs on the side of kindness, there's a little bit of a sense that there could be a no good deed goes unpunished kind of thing. I imagine, Sophie, that maybe there's been like, is there favoritism towards Pacific Biochar? How do we get in on this? Is this a conflict of interest for you to even take a stake like this?

Ross Kenyon: I'm sure maybe there's been some concern about that driven your way. And I'm curious, one, am I onto anything? And if so, how have you dealt with that?

Sophie Westover: Yeah, I mean, we thought a lot about conflict of interest and what does this mean for Wren and Pacific Biochar and how do we avoid conflict of interest? And if Pacific Biochar, for some reason, goes off the rails and is now charging ridiculous amounts for their carbon credits and I can get the same impact from another supplier or whatever the case may be, we thought pretty deeply about how do we separate these things enough that we're not doing anything immoral or unethical, I suppose. And so the way that we kind of thought about that internally is first, if we're going to continue to buy credits from Pacific Biochar and have those credits insured, is our insurer still willing to cover that? And we checked with Kita to make sure that those bases were covered and they were still fine doing that. Second, I think that we're still being thoughtful in the way that we're purchasing credits from Pacific Biochar and are willing to reevaluate the project if new information arises, if there are other solutions that are providing similar impact but are much more cost effective.

Sophie Westover: I haven't seen anything that has come across my plate that is like, oh, wow, this other company is doing this for half as much as Pacific Biochar is. We haven't kind of crossed that bridge yet. But surely I think that part of the reason, just being honest, like part of the reason why we were willing to make a deal with Pacific Biochar was because of the relationship that we had with them. And maybe that is like favoritism in some way, for sure. I can't say that it's not. Like if we didn't know Pacific Biochar and they came to us, I don't know that we would have been willing to work with them. Yeah. But I maybe almost want to frame that in the same way as trust-based philanthropy is pitched. You trust a nonprofit to do good work. You give them the money and say, go do the good work.

Sophie Westover: And that's a very normal pathway to doing effective philanthropies. Non-restrictive, multi-year giving. Go do the work. We trust you. But you need to have some sort of relationship with the organization that the philanthropist is funding in order to actually have that trust in place and just go and say, yeah, here's the money, go do a good thing. I don't know quite what I'm getting at here, but I think that that's kind of like a similar kind of thought process is, yes, maybe people could argue it's favoritism, but we also have like seen proof of impact from Pacific Biochar over the last four years or however long it's been. We've gotten credits delivered. We've seen them on the CDR.FYI leaderboard. We understand Josiah's kind of ideology or theory of change, we believe in what he's doing, and have gone out and visited the project twice and we have that level of trust.

Sophie Westover: And so, yeah, I think there are areas where conflict of interest could arise. We're doing what we can to keep things as ethical and separate as possible. We're not trying to play favorites when it comes to purchasing decisions. I'm still having conversations with plenty of biochar companies, seeing if any of them can knock Pacific Biochar off the leaderboard or off our preference sheet, so to speak. That hasn't happened yet, but I think we're doing what we can to reduce any conflict of interest.

Ross Kenyon: Josiah, I wonder if people...

Josiah Hunt: And we're probably going to see more of that, I think. Yeah, I think there's a lot of stress, a lot of distress. And I think there is kind of a natural tendency of, you know, no good deed goes unpunished. Which I think, I'll bring up a great example. Let's say Acme Corp goes out and decides to purchase some carbon credits and then some other corp. Is it from their own bill sales? NUCO. Okay, we'll have NUCO over here. I'm just thinking of lame names, right? There's NUCO and Acme. Acme goes out and purchases some carbon credits. And then it turns out that those carbon credits were imperfect somehow. Meanwhile, NUCO did nothing. Who's going to get slandered in the news? Right. And I mean, you know the answer. I don't even have to say it. NUCO is fine. They did nothing to contribute to climate action.

Josiah Hunt: They did nothing. And Acme Corp, meanwhile, is going to be punished for doing good. No good deed goes unpunished. And I bring that up as an example because I think it's something that we in this entire community are quite guilty of. And I think partly because many of us are distressed. And so sometimes it's like we're like crabs in a barrel. And so instead of like, hey, how could this be wrong? How could this be bad? Like, how could this be good? And I think one of the ways that it's great is that Wren is getting a much better understanding of what it's like for a supplier, for a boots on the ground supplier. And so through their gaining of understanding of what it's like for boots on the ground suppliers, they have a better understanding of the needs and concerns of all the rest of their fleet of suppliers.

Josiah Hunt: So by us working with them in this way, it can benefit every other supplier they're working with because now they have a better understanding of what it's like. And by having regular communication on this, they can see like, oh, wow, maybe we should ask questions that we hadn't been asking before. Because I think a lot of companies are struggling, but it's not a place of strength to announce your struggles, right? If you want to get the next round of funding, if you want to get those next credits, if you want to get the next partnership, whatever, you best appear strong and sturdy and the water is calm. Come on in. It's great. So I think the incentive is to understate the difficulties and overstate the successes. That's just what we're all incentivized to do. And I think because of that, there's a lot more distress and difficulty than most people tend to be aware of.

Josiah Hunt: And I think that inserts a fragility to the system that if we were more aware of, we could perhaps better assess and better treat. So I left a few things open-ended there, but I think putting back on the question of like, what are the positives of this? And I think there's some significant positives. And then also kind of what you're mentioning. Yeah, I do think there's quite a few other companies that are distressed right now and could use some help. There's a significant gap in ability to capture finance and there's a huge difficulty because generally with CDR your costs are up front and your revenue comes sometime later and the gap, even when it's consistent, that gap between cost and revenue is painful, but then you insert volatility because this whole thing is evolving quickly and with evolution comes the volatility. That gap moves. And typically it's extending, and sometimes the goalposts move after you even kick the ball.

Josiah Hunt: And so this can further distress. And so that, I think, is a great source of fragility within the entire industry. And there's not a lot of great mechanisms to help support companies working their way through that and scaling up. So yes, I would definitely say that we're not alone in wanting to partner with companies like Wren that can help us with financial assistance in difficult situations. And we feel very privileged that we were able to secure that opportunity. I don't know what to say. I wish I had answers for them all. I think like Sophie was saying, they only have so much capital. And I'm sure after this podcast, there might be a few more that hit them up. I don't know, like where is that big pile of money? I don't know to help us all out. I don't have the answer to that.

Josiah Hunt: But I do think it is probably a bigger problem than most people are comfortable vocalizing.

Sophie Westover: Just pulling on the thread, Josiah, about increasing the level of transparency between Wren and Pacific Biochar and being able to kind of get a peek behind the curtains has allowed me to learn more about what it means to succeed for a company and what the financial challenges are that are oftentimes going on behind the scenes. And I think it's true when I speak to companies, they are trying to present themselves in the best light. They want our money. They're trying to say, yes, we're going to be around in five years to deliver those credits or we're going to be able to scale impact X, Y, and Z. And so I think a lot of times these kind of really hopeful stories are being told to buyers about the company. And I do think it's okay to say, you know, a pre-purchase of $100,000 is extremely important for our company and is going to be what allows us to survive in the future.

Sophie Westover: Speaking from experience talking with other buyers in the Air Miners Buyers Club, when we're talking to suppliers right now, that's oftentimes a question that we ask to the companies. How impactful would a $50,000 purchase be for your company? And I think the sentiment within the group that I've been working with is we want to see just how impactful on a nitty-gritty basis that small purchase is. And so the deal with Pacific Biochar has just allowed me to understand a little bit more the nuances that go on within a developer. The decision-making, a $10 increase on a credit price versus a $20 increase on a credit price, how impactful that is for the bottom line overall. And so now when I'm diligencing projects, it's almost more important for me to get an understanding of their finances so we understand how impactful we're being and just better manage our risks overall, I think, generally when it comes to credit purchases.

Sophie Westover: So the TLDR there is just like the deal with Pacific Biochar has taught me a lot about the challenges of being a developer and how Wren can best support other developers in the space, best support the developers that we're currently working with. Better structure contracts and agreements to support developers over the long term, as opposed to maybe doing like a couple of spot purchases or a couple of small pre-purchases. Maybe we talk about a year-long contract or a two-year-long contract so they're able to go out and use that contract to raise funds down the line.

Ross Kenyon: Do you think this is a model that other marketplaces, even if we don't admit that Wren is a straightforward marketplace, could Carbon Future do this? Could Supercritical do this? Could any of the marketplaces pick up this model and run with it? Should they do that? How are you feeling about the replicability of this?

Sophie Westover: I think it depends on the priorities of the marketplace. I think that there are some marketplaces or players in the space who are more focused on systems change and impact. I think of Milkywire as being one of those organizations. They have their Climate Transformation Fund. And I think are looking at things through a beyond value chain mitigation lens, as opposed to a pure, you know, let's just help this company offset for the lowest price lens. So I think for the organizations that really prioritize systems change and are willing to be more flexible and catalytic in the way that they distribute funds, then this could be a really smart approach for them. I've also been approached for investment deals that allow you to have rights of first refusal on credits or some other kind of creative mechanism to secure credit supply down the line. And so perhaps that's another model that could be picked up. I think that maybe that model is more standard, generally speaking, just from conversations that I've had. I can't say that for certain. But yeah, it depends on the priorities. But I think for those who are really serious about systems change, then this is absolutely a thing that could be picked up and replicated.

Ross Kenyon: I'm curious if we're going to see more of it because I'm certainly not the first and won't be the last to predict that we will see a lot of mergers and acquisitions and shutterings next year. I hope there's not that many, not more than is necessary for an industry. I think we're starting to see more of that in direct air capture. I don't know. Is a marketplace going to start buying a biochar company? Are there other deals that might take place that I haven't even envisioned yet? Do you guys have any predictions on what it might be like as a project developer? I'm sure you probably said no to a couple of deals, Josiah. Did you shop this around, by the way? Was it just Wren?

Josiah Hunt: Yeah, I mean, it wasn't our only option. It was our favorite option, but not our only option.

Ross Kenyon: Josiah and Sophie, thanks for being here. I really like the structure of this deal. I hope we see more things like it. I'm really intrigued by it. Sophie, thanks for the leadership of you and your team. And Josiah, big respect for what Pacific Biochar has built over the years. Thanks for being on the show.

Sophie Westover: Thank you, Ross.

Josiah Hunt: Thank you.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?