Share from 0:00
0:00
/

The Climate Cup: How Sports Could Lead on Carbon Removal

Why the games we love are multiplying, and how dealing with the environmental costs of growth could fuel fandom.

Episode 371 of the Reversing Climate Change podcast. You can listen to the episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you enjoy your shows.

Much of legacy media is dying. You know what isn't? Live sports. Where the outcome is uncertain, people want to watch.

That means bringing together large numbers of fans and athletes. And what does that all add up to? Emissions. And emissions that could potentially be detached from profitability, leading to budgets large enough to support meaningful carbon removal.

But will sports leagues move in this direction? Or is it better that it stay at the level of individual teams jockeying for brand value from climate action?

Today's guest is Dr. Aidan Preston, Senior Impact Manager of Milkywire and former Advisor to the United States Department of Energy.

Aidan is a sports fanatic and the author of Milkywire's latest report, "The Climate Cost of Growth in Sport: An Opportunity for Sports to Win on Climate".

We discuss the evolving media landscape around sports, the creation and surprising rise of new sports, the omnipresence of sports betting, and how all of this might play out for carbon removal and climate action.

This episode's sponsors

Absolute Climate: the only standard that’s developed independent of registries

Philip Lee LLP: legal resources for carbon removal buyers and suppliers

Listen to the RCC episode with Peter Minor from Absolute Climate

Listen to the RCC episode with Ryan Covington from Philip Lee LLP

Become a sponsor by emailing carbon.removal.strategies[at]gmail.com

Sign up for the 9Zero climate coworking space with my referral code

Resources

"The Climate Cost of Growth in Sport: An Opportunity for Sports to Win on Climate", a Milkywire report by Dr. Aidan Preston

350: Robert Höglund Presents: The Many Perils of Being Catalytic in a Carbon Accounting World

FIFA

"Mohammad Ali — Amazing Speed"; watch this video for the out-of-this-world dodges alone

America's Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders; you can see the F1 and golf series on Netflix too

30 for 30

Kayfabe

Aidan recommended this Michael Lewis podcast on sports betting

Aidan sent me the link to this study on how talking to strangers brings satisfaction
Acquired episode about Indian Premier League Cricket

https://www.derekthompson.org/p/why-everything-became-television
CUR8

Taylor Swift and the Chiefs/NFL

Jason Isbell on being the subject of the documentary, Jason Isbell: Running With Our Eyes Closed: "Yet Isbell admits there were times during the filming process when he needed a moment to himself. 

“I would leave the room, or unplug my microphone and get away from the camera. Sometimes it was too much,” he says. “But once the footage was all there and edited together, I didn’t use any sort of veto power or take anything out.”"

The Gulf of Aden (sorry, Aidan; I couldn't help it...)

More from the show

Ad-free episodes and other benefits come with a paid subscription.

Carbon Removal Newsroom, the news show that ran alongside this one, is over. Its episodes are still up, on the feed Climate Workers Anonymous now uses.

Carbon Removal Memes is still goofing around.

The books that come up on this show are collected on my Bookshop shelf.

🎧 Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube

Paid subscribers get this episode ad-free. The ads in the free feed are inserted by Spotify when you press play. They are not in the file I make.

Norman Rockwell + pond hockey + DAC

Full Transcript

Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening. This is Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of Reversing Climate Change, the podcast you are listening to right at this very moment. Before we get into the bulk of today's show, I'd love to tell you about our sponsors, Absolute Climate and Philip Lee LLP. I've made great radio with both of them. They should be familiar to you if you listen to this show, but I want to tell you about why you should learn a little bit more. The first sponsor is Absolute Climate. I did a show with their founder, Peter Minor, a few months back. And a lot of people love that show. I was asking a question of, can registries design their own methodologies for carbon markets without it being a conflict of interest? And Absolute Climate's thesis is no. They shouldn't be in the business of doing that. We actually need to disintegrate functionality within carbon markets even further.

Ross Kenyon: They are literally the only independent standards body for carbon removal that exists. Their name is very well chosen. I think they are some of the most aggressively idealistic people within carbon removal. It's come up on Reversing Climate Change so many times about how and why there's tension between commercial teams and science teams within carbon markets. There's some fundamental tension between the rules of running a business, or I should say the rules of running a profitable business is maybe a better way to put that. And climate impact. And I think Absolute is one of those companies that, at least from my experience of what I know of them over there, I think they're going to be some of the staunchest holdouts, just trying to make sure that there can be a justified true belief that a tonne purchase is a tonne truly removed. They're betting big on not compromising.

Ross Kenyon: It's an old strategy. I respect the absolute hell out of that. Absolute is very much doing things their own way and they stand out to me and I will never mistake them in a lineup. Go check them out. I'm seriously fascinated by what they're doing. And that's also true of our other sponsor, Philip Lee LLP. In fact, I told them to pitch me on some weirder legal shows. I really like doing shows about the law. I think the law is such a fascinating part of our shared social life. It structures so much of it. It's badly understood by most people. And just structuring deals within carbon removal is hard. I'm talking grown up deals here. Like when you're trying to put together an enormous package, complicated structuring. A lot of money changing hands. The stakes are high. You really do need a good lawyer. I'm sorry to tell you that if you are a startup out there in carbon removal, you're going to probably pay a fair amount of money to lawyers.

Ross Kenyon: There's just no way around it. Your choice is basically, do you get a bad lawyer or a good lawyer? One really cool thing I can say on Philip Lee LLP's behalf: Ryan Covington and I did a very fun show about how basically no one except for an elite few really know what bankability and project finance even mean. And he lays it out very clearly. If you'd like to go listen to that show, it's awesome. And it's linked in the show notes. And also we ended up talking about Ernest Hemingway. So it keeps with the tradition of Reversing Climate Change. One also really cool thing is that they just won environmental finances VCM law firm of the year. They've run it three years in a row, 2023, 2024, and 2025. It's the only award for legal teams operating in the VCM, and they have offices in the U.S., Europe, and the U.K.

Ross Kenyon: You should check out Philip Lee LLP. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for listening to this, and thank you to our sponsors. You really make this so that it's something that, in a busy life with lots of competing priorities, I'm able to keep coming back and making more Reversing Climate Change. Thanks so much for what you do, and now, here is the show.

Ross Kenyon: Hello and welcome to Reversing Climate Change. I'm Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of the show. I'm going to describe myself differently today. I'm a climate tech worker. I have been for nearly a decade. Today we have a topic that as far as I can remember, we've never touched before. We're talking about sports, entertainment, how these industries have evolved over time and how they might support carbon removal. Before I go into that, if you could please open your app up right now, before you start driving, before you start washing dishes, before you start walking your dog, give the show five stars on Spotify or Apple Podcasts or whatever you're using. If you are using Apple Podcasts, write a quick review, just say, I love this show. It could be that simple. It helps get the show to more people and that's a wonderful thing. There's also for $5 a month, there's an option to become a paid subscriber, which gets rid of all the automated ads.

Ross Kenyon: You get bonus content and my appreciation. So anyways, for today's show, Aiden Preston, who's now at Milky Wire, formerly of the Department of Energy, where he worked on carbon removal. He's now the Senior Impact Manager of Milky Wire, again, working on carbon removal and supporting many of the other amazing efforts that Milky Wire puts on. Milky Wire in today's show gets described as the Moneyball of carbon removal, which I think is true. Milky Wire is the first step for many companies within carbon removal. Before they're mature enough to receive a big deal with Frontier or Microsoft or Google, they're oftentimes getting their start with Milky Wire. Milky Wire is very focused on catalytic carbon removal support. I think they're really creative too. They're not only looking at how do they buy credits in cool ways. I think they're oftentimes looking at structural ways where every marginal dollar that goes into the ecosystem is something that's helping us scale towards a future where carbon removal increases.

Ross Kenyon: If you want details on exactly how Milky Wire works and thinks, I did a show with Robert Hoagland not long ago. I put the link in the show notes. You should definitely go check it out. Really have a lot of respect for what Milky Wire has built and what Robert has helped support. So the show with Aiden though, Aiden is obsessed with sports. He'll tell you that. We start talking about it right away. He doesn't even seemingly care which sport it is. He just loves the entire process, basically all sports, except for cricket. We talk about that too. He hasn't gotten into cricket yet. But we talk about why in an age where so much legacy content is just less profitable, less valuable, and there's so much more of it. And the way that we consume media is changing, except for sports, it hasn't really.

Ross Kenyon: We still really care about watching things live. It ruins the enjoyment for most people watching sports if they know what the outcome is ahead of time. And the growth of live sports entertainment has meant a lot more emissions in sports leagues and teams. There's an ability for them to maybe get out and lead. And also what's really cool about it is that because sports is inherently competitive, there is a way where individual teams within leagues can actually compete against one another to grow their values. One of the things that I really like thinking about is how sports are coded politically. I think if you're an American, you know that the NFL tends to be a right of center proclivity. I mean, lots and lots of people enjoy football. It's not just a conservative sport, but it certainly has more of that feel, especially if you compare it to something like basketball, blue coded, for sure.

Ross Kenyon: Soccer, soccer for me, I associate as being very left wing in general. But I know that isn't universally true. This is just how it feels in America. But this is all to say that various sports teams in the league might buck those traditions or might be even within a left-coded sport, there might be a team that in a certain area has a right feel and vice versa. And because these sports have diversity of values, both within teams and across the entire league or the entire sport, there's a chance for these teams to try to appeal to their fans to either acquire new fans or to make the attachment of their existing fans more strong. There's a lot of amazing work here that can be done. And this work has barely started. I think this is a really cool show. I think it's one of those areas that has a lot of room for growth.

Ross Kenyon: Sports are one of those areas where it seems like so much of the value is not directly coupled with manufacturing processes that have a linear feel to them. No matter how big a steel company gets there's likely just some structural limits to how profitable that company will be unless they make some enormous innovation. But sports are one of those things where the right media deal could make that franchise way more profitable. And when you have high profit that is above the fixed rate of emissions growth, then you have opportunity for extra budget that is available for things like carbon removal. So sports just might be one of those growth areas, especially as the competition for eyeballs gets harder. Granted, you're not competing for Aiden's eyeballs because he's seemingly watching everything already. But for his fandom, you can compete for that. Whatever. Aiden, thanks for doing this in a new way.

Ross Kenyon: I also just love that you brought your own passion to carbon removal because we all have personalities and interests outside of just carbon removal. And when we bring ourselves to that, I think it unlocks valuable new syntheses that didn't exist previously. This is something that is very much of you and I really respect and appreciate that. So without further ado, here's the show with Aiden Preston. Aiden, thank you for being here.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, Ross, thanks for having me.

Ross Kenyon: At which age did you know that you're a sportsman?

Aiden Preston: Oh, I feel like I came out of the womb with a stick in my hand or a ball. I had two older brothers who were pretty merciless about not letting me score the basketball or score a goal. And my parents would ask like, aren't you ever going to let them win? And they're like, nope. Yeah, that lasted until about like 13, 14.

Ross Kenyon: That explains the chip on your shoulder, but not the love of sports. You would have thought that would have taken it right out of you.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, it's a good point. It says something about my psychology, perhaps, and my love of the struggle. That's a good transition to this climate conversation, I guess.

Ross Kenyon: Oh, what?

Aiden Preston: Just like the... Upload battles.

Ross Kenyon: So you feel like the climate space right now is like having two mean older brothers who don't let you win because you're the underdog. Honestly, that might be the best analogy for working in climate today that I've heard in a long time. How did you manage from below two brothers like that? Has that taught you any lessons for how to cope with difficulty?

Aiden Preston: Oh, no, it probably taught me just grit and perseverance. They were significantly older than me, like six and eight years. So there was very little managing. It was just getting better until I was actually able to beat them in the competitions. And I'm really excited we're talking about this. I'm really excited for them to listen. I'm sure they have different perspective. It's just, just endured.

Ross Kenyon: Whatever you do, don't get Nogi Jida. And if you can survive, it'll be okay.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, you learn strategies. Like if they're going to block your basketball shot, you get faster. You learn to shoot on the run. I'm not very good at basketball, probably because I learned bad fundamentals as a result of this. But you definitely learn to strategize. You learn to use your brain and not rely on your physical gifts.

Ross Kenyon: The old David versus Goliath technique here. You got the sling and you're hurling the rock. I knew you'd bring some biblical information into the podcast. So predictable.

Aiden Preston: What can I even do? I'm sorry. I forgot to study my old test. Game on, man. I knew I had reading to do. I stuck to the adjustment. I'll give you a bibliography after we're done. It's okay. Don't worry.

Ross Kenyon: When people bring in their own interests like this, I always think it's so fascinating. I mean, we're just joking about it. That's what I do with my show. I'm like, okay, these are like combination of things that I think are interesting that actually do fit together. And I think when people think about sports and entertainment, they're not thinking of that as a market to sell into. I think everyone is so ensourced by the high profit, low emissions buyers that currently dominate CDR. And you're saying, I care about sports. There's a huge opportunity here for them. Their patrons want them to do this, but they're not really doing it. Why not?

Aiden Preston: No, you're exactly right. And yeah, it is true. I absolutely love watching sports. I'm pretty much not picky at all. If people are competing to the best of their abilities, I will sit down and watch them compete. And especially these major events, I get up for the World Cup, for the Olympics. The summer of 2004, when the Olympics were in Sydney, I don't think I slept. I was just in my New Jersey living room watching Michael Phelps swim. And then people would wake up and I'd be like, two gold medals, baby. They had to wait for primetime, but I was watching it live. And yeah, I think relatedly, there's this trend for sports to grow, like to expand their competition, add more teams. Like the World Cup in 2026 is going to be in three countries. It's going to have 48 teams instead of 36. And so this is selfish. I'm like, man, it kind of feels like it's devaluing the competition a little bit. Like it used to mean something to like qualify. Now... Everybody's going to qualify. So I'm like a little bit less excited by that. And then I'm like, man, this also has a negative climate externality. And then I'm like, ooh, I get to defend my own beliefs here, which is like sports should restrict entry and not grow to make the games more valuable leading up to the championship. But they also shouldn't have this deleterious climate impact.

Ross Kenyon: What do you do in cases, though, like... Is there any sports organization that has a reputation as bad as FIFA? And can one expect them to genuinely care about something potentially as abstract as climate? I suppose if there's commercial upside for them, maybe they would. Is there enough of that to motivate people like that?

Aiden Preston: That's the million dollar, billion dollar question, I think. Ostensibly, they do care about climate. They have made climate commitments. They've tried to act on those commitments. They have not ultimately been successful in hosting net zero competitions. And they've lost in the court of a Swiss regulator when they're attacked for their carbon neutral claims. But the fact that they are trying to be... I really, really tried hard in writing this to not get sucked down greenwashing rabbit holes or making accusations. I think we've had quite a lot of that. So I wanted to kind of posit that like, hey, there's still room for you to take action for these hard-to-abate emissions that aren't going to get you brought to court. Like the market has grown. Yeah, you were buying $12 a tonne forestry credits, and that wasn't good to compensate with. But there are credits now that you can use that use proper accounting, are durable, are additional. The market has developed to a point where carbon removal can be a tool in their toolbox.

Ross Kenyon: I don't even know how to ask this question because it's so big. Why are sports... And there's new sports all the time too. Pickleball I'm sure is going to be on not just dedicated channels soon. I'm sure that will be increasingly mainstream as more and more people play it. Things like MMA was not a thing when I was a kid. It was just starting to be. It is absolutely massive and they charge a mint to watch it. And the NFL is in Europe and Brazil. I never would have predicted stuff like that. What is driving just the growth of sports?

Aiden Preston: Yeah, I think the revenues are ballooning for sports leagues to put stuff on TV. TV watching in general has decreased, but the percentage of people watching TV who are watching sports has increased. So I think last year, 75 of the 100 most watched broadcasts were live sporting events.

Ross Kenyon: Wow.

Aiden Preston: Or perhaps that was two years ago and the data is a year lagging. But in the last measured year, and this is true around the world, everywhere besides Sweden, where they watch the qualifiers for Eurovision the most, everybody who's watching TV is watching live sports. And I think in our modern television, we're really hitting my trifecta of three interests of television, sports and climate.

Ross Kenyon: Is that just like an ABBA hangover? Is Sweden really that into Eurovision?

Aiden Preston: They're the Yankees of Eurovision. You gotta start working for a Swedish company like me. Sweden always wins Eurovision. They're like dominant force. Everybody else roots against them.

Ross Kenyon: Oh.

Aiden Preston: Yeah.

Ross Kenyon: I had to go back like 50 years to even be like, oh yeah, ABBA. But that's not even true. So clearly I'm out of date. I mean, I know they're the Swedish favorite export, ABBA. And I mean, that's timeless. That's timeless music right there.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, it's not going to be Aquavit. I think it's safe to say that's not going to be their most favorite export. But anyways, your trifecta. Go back to that.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Aiden Preston: I think our TV diet has changed to streaming, binging shows. And people used to gather around like three channels and everyone watched Leave it to Beaver.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Aiden Preston: TV ratings for shows that were getting canceled back then are 10x what the best rated show on TV is getting today. So TV watching is going down. Everyone is consuming so much media. The only thing that needs to be watched at any certain time is a live event. What is the easiest live event to show on TV? Sports. And as more networks compete for these limited pool of sporting events, there's two options. The leagues can grow and add more games to fill the airwaves, or more new sports can get thrown on the TV channels because they have hours to kill. They're hoping to be shown in an airport or be shown at a bar in the middle of the day because that increases TV ratings, it increases media revenue. It's basically, can you have the lowest common denominator of something that's on TV that someone who's clicking through a channel will say, that's good enough.

Ross Kenyon: That's so funny because sports have to be shown live, it seems, because knowing the outcome can ruin it. And then also there's the growth of sports betting, which, by the way, I think is a really pernicious thing. It should not really be as common as it is, I think. But, oh, you're nodding. I don't know. Maybe that's controversial.

Aiden Preston: This is maybe a whole separate podcast, but I grew up... I was pretty enmeshed in the sports betting world from the start. And I also find it to be very pernicious. People are really bad at calculating like connected odds. So even when you win one of these bets, you should have won like three times as much because they just arbitrarily set the odds way lower and they're also harder to win. So that's why just look for every single ad for a gambling company. They're always talking about parlays because they want you. They just know our brains are not equipped to calculate the true value that you should be receiving if you do win these bets.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, I used to be so freedom-oriented. I'd be like, well, that's just personal discretion and you need to learn your limits and stuff like that. But I also heard enough stories at this point or known enough people at this point where you're like, gambling can be really bad at having more access and advertising for it. I'm fine if it exists, but the fact that it's half of all the commercials if an NFL game is on or whatever, I'm just like, do we need this much awareness that you can always be betting on all of this?

Aiden Preston: Yeah, I'm with you. And it's shocking if I told myself this 10 years ago, I'd be on this side of the argument. I'd be like, no way. But yeah, this second part is not just the parlays, but the vig, the amount that the casinos take, was always set historically at like 5%. And that seemed to be a fair deal for Vegas and the betting public, that they would always win. The house would always win. But it was fantastic. 45, 55. Now the house is taking 15% just for you to be able to bet on your phone. It's just way harder to win. It's more unfair gaming, in my opinion, that hopefully will come down.

Ross Kenyon: Wow. I mean, that's certainly true. Like one thing I've noticed whenever I've gone to conferences in Vegas or whatever, is that like blackjack is one of those games that is probabilistic, but so much so that you really know, like if there's six decks in play versus one deck. The casinos that have the good odds for blackjacks are the crappy ones. The ones that are just like, please come in. We'll do anything. Anything. But the ones that are like, you go to the Bellagio, it's like, how many decks are we legally allowed to put in here? Because we just are going to take all your money and don't care. And maybe you're here because you're staying here and you're not going to wander across to Fremont Street to go do this just because it's a little bit more convenient. I think there is something like maybe you use the app with the best UI or you got the promo to come in there. And now you're just like a captive. And even if it's a terrible, terrible set of gambling odds, you still might take the bet.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, we'll have to link to something in the show notes. One of your competitor podcasts talked about the stickiness of getting someone on your app. And that's why the deals are always like amazing deals when you first start because folks are really hard pressed to transfer accounts from one gambling app to another.

Ross Kenyon: Sorry, are you saying you're listening to alternative podcasts? Did you play that on my show?

Aiden Preston: I played the fifth.

Ross Kenyon: You played the fifth. Okay. For sports, it seems a major point of value here is not knowing the outcome ahead of time. But there are also, I don't know, like the amount of the proliferation of sports documentaries. Like my family's been really into the Dallas Cheerleaders one. That's been awesome. That's a really great show. But also I like going back and watching. Do you ever watch old clips of Muhammad Ali fighting?

Aiden Preston: Yeah.

Ross Kenyon: And like he'll be like an inch away and like not even have his hands up and dodge. I'll put a link in the show notes. Please go watch this. It's amazing watching how confident he is an inch away from getting clobbered and just heavyweight punches. So like I don't even care that much about the outcome. Some part of it is just I don't need to feel like the thrill of that. Sometimes the pure athleticism is enough, but maybe that's not enough to drive revenues that are ever increasing this way. It seems like it is very outcome dependent.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, I mean, there were channels dedicated to showing NFL films, NBA classics, the hardwood classics on the NBA channel. And I've seen the NFL and NBA both move away from programming that was showing classic games and adding live sporting events to those channels. So just based on observing that trend, I'd argue it probably is driving the bottom line revenue to have live programming above older games.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, I think it's dangerous to think that idiosyncratic me should dictate mass market trends. The jokes we've already made about this show guarantees that.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, go ahead. Isn't that why you started a podcast in the first place?

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, my own weird little freaky thing. But yeah, I'm like, oh, I like watching that thing that literally no one else likes watching apparently in sports. It's just me and...

Aiden Preston: No, I think you're right. Those classic highlights, be it boxing or Barry Sanders breaking 15 tackles. Yeah, they're amazing. But I think those are also highlights. So it's like, what do we do? Do we program? Now that we say this, there are those channels that are like 20 second clips of people doing stuff that's amazing. And sometimes it's like old sports clips. So I think there is an appetite for this. And you can go on MTV and watch whatever they're showing these days because I think it's this kind of programming where it's just like short clips of people doing something that's cool and you can kind of watch it and brain rot.

Ross Kenyon: Okay, but if it's live sports, though, and we're getting away from pre-recorded stuff from the past, even if there are highlights, that is not driving the growth of sports media. And even if it were, the emissions from that are negligible. You already filmed it. It's done. You just got to re-air it again. So, yeah, the NFL bringing an entire team to Brazil and to London on a regular basis, those are emissions. You have FIFA matches that include many more teams in the world, more emissions. What do we do with those?

Aiden Preston: They'll read it and see the argument for using carbon removal to compensate for their emissions and then be more open and willing to chat. What I would say is, I think I've also noticed in the past, it looks to me from my research, that a lot of sports leagues have used carbon credits and have not had good experiences doing so. There's been a recent story in the news about Clippers player Kawhi Leonard, who was getting paid for a no-show job, allegedly, and it may circumvent the NBA salary cap rules. The job that he was not showing up for was this carbon credits company that was involved in fraud. And that part of the story is not making any news. But it's just a no-show job.

Ross Kenyon: So clearly you are from Jersey, though, as I understand.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, yeah, definitely.

Ross Kenyon: Sorry to break your flow there. But I don't even hear that in like the context of, like, The Deuce or Sopranos or stuff like that. But yeah.

Aiden Preston: Yeah. And honestly, full disclosure, people have been referring to it as a no-show job in the media. So I'm kind of stealing and cribbing their language. Again, allegedly. But I think I've seen a lot of organizations that thought they were doing the right thing, thought they were credibly offsetting their remaining emissions, or it was the only option for them because they couldn't reduce their emissions. They said, okay, we'll buy these credits. And then they were caught either making inaccurate claims based on what they purchased or were caught buying a fraudulent credit. And even some of these organizations that leagues have partnered with, like I'm on a website right now that's offering me a 12 pound afforestation project credit, and it's labeled as SVTI compliant permanent carpet room. And this is an organization that I've seen show up on a number of different sports leagues' sustainability pages as a partner.

Aiden Preston: And again, I'm not trying to mudsling in this report or be negative to anyone's actions, especially if they're acting in good faith, which is the assumption I've been trying to make. But I think here's my hypothesis. They acted in the past. They may have not felt amazing about it. They may have thought, is this right? Is this going to work? Well, what else are we going to do? They went ahead with offsetting. Some people got in trouble. The Guardian wrote an article about it. Some people read those Guardian articles and said, I hope they don't write about us. And they got really scared away from offsetting emissions at all. My hope is that they will read this report. They'll say, you're right. Travel is an unmitigatable emission. We're going to continue to use fossil fuels right now until the SAF market develops. And even then, we might want to use CDR in lieu of SAF if it's cheaper.

Aiden Preston: Let me reengage with the carbon market as a possible solution to these issues.

Ross Kenyon: Okay. I'm curious how this gets... Wait, did you watch the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders doc series?

Aiden Preston: No, I haven't seen it.

Ross Kenyon: Whenever Netflix is making these sports docs, it doesn't even matter what it is. They're all just like, oh, you want to learn about golf? Cool. I don't even care about golf. It's great. But yeah, the cheerleaders were making... It was some terrible salary. They all had to work multiple jobs. And they recently got a 400% wage increase. So presumably six figures or very nearly so. And it was enough for them to focus on cheerleading exclusively. But the fact that Jerry Jones' family cannot afford to pay these people what is frankly a pretty basic wage for being at the top of your athletics, your discipline. That's as good as it gets, is becoming a DCC as far as I understand it. So they can't afford to pay that? Why would they pay for some enormous amount of carbon removal that no one is forcing them to? There's no union of cheerleaders coming after them saying, buy carbon removal.

Aiden Preston: Hey, that's a good go-to-market. You should consider that.

Ross Kenyon: That idea is fine.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, we'll hire a team of athletic women to bat down the doors of all carbon removal buyers, maybe. I think that you're pointing to an issue, which is that a lot of these decisions are decentralized and are not controlled by the league itself. The NFL does not direct the sustainability actions of its teams, nor do other leagues in the U.S. And that means that the market itself is split up into, in the NFL, 32 different teams with 32 different sustainability managers who have 32 different priorities and also 32 different owners who might value, I won't say a good word about the Dallas Cowboys because I'm a diehard Philadelphia Eagles fan. And the Eagles owner is one of the most progressive of the 32 NFL owners. So you might see them taking more aggressive action that's pro-climate than some of the 31 other owners in the NFL who may share a different perspective. So I think it's a difficult pitch, because you have to make 32 of them, or 30, depending on the league. But ideally, there'd be some sort of follow effect. One team takes significant action, is celebrated for that action. The other teams want that celebration. They want people to feel good about watching this team. Liverpool FC, another team that I consider a rival to my Everton Toffees, they've purchased carbon removal credits. And I'm like, dang, that's badass.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Aiden Preston: Oh, I hate them a little bit less now. Like I really do think it moves the needle. I mean, maybe I'm a sicko, but for me, I'm like, yeah, that's really like cool, credible action. They're involved. They're making smart decisions. I've like kind of switched my allegiance in F1 to Mercedes who have done a good job with their decarbonization strategy and have contributed to, or I've purchased carbon removals as well. So I was never that big of an F1 fan. I followed along after the ESPN doc or sorry, Netflix documentary. But I mean, I switched my allegiance, so it does have an effect.

Ross Kenyon: Wow, that's pretty fascinating. Do you wish that you could go before the NFL commissioner or something like that and get some sort of ruling and get the, what's the old joke about it? The prior written consent of the NFL for carbon removal.

Aiden Preston: Yeah. The express written consent.

Ross Kenyon: There you go. Is that what you want for like broadcast? What do you like it being heterogeneous and therefore there's more innovation? People are trying new things like what's better, do you think, for sports and carbon removal?

Aiden Preston: Oh, that's such a good question. Well, I guess the easy answer is like if the central body was able to encourage people to act in the most effective way possible, then we would want centralization. Honestly, a good parallel for centralized control of our current government. Like, do you want to build state capacity? Or do you want to have a weak state? Sometimes strong state capacity can lead to negative outcomes if you have less than ideal leaders, to be vague. But I do like the idea of teams being innovative in their approaches to sustainability. And I think it has led to some cool outcomes with decarbonization of stadiums and food and waste management at facilities. I just don't think it's led to innovation development when it comes to accounting for the emissions that are associated with sports and namely sports travel. I think just for the nature of sports being competitive, I like it being at the level of teams.

Ross Kenyon: I like the idea that they cause you to switch allegiance or that it deepened your love for the Eagles. Like something like that is a really cool thing that I think we should preserve. I think it would maybe suck some of the magic of sports out if it was just like the NFL top co decided to do this. That's not really as interesting.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, I mean, that's the dream, right? If the teams or leagues are actually competing on sustainability, and SailGP is a sporting league that has a separate scoreboard for impact, and one of the categories on that is sustainability work, and that's such a cool model. Oh, my team might have come in fourth this year, but we were the best on sustainability. I mean, that's like full nerd alert, but I appreciate it.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Aiden Preston: I mean, frankly, we are in an increasingly polarized society and solidarity is the only path forward. Sports is an opportunity for people to recognize each other's common humanity and it can build a coalition. So I think your teams competing and you being able to follow your team and celebrate them for their successes can maybe bring along more people into the climate realm, the climate industry.

Ross Kenyon: It's funny that you say that as recognizing our common humanity because I think sports is typically seen as a way of sublimating our warlike impulses and splitting into groups and trying to kill each other in socially acceptable ways. And even the way that you put it, even if Dallas did something great, you still couldn't celebrate it because you're an Eagles fan. Does it actually draw you closer to fans of Dallas football or does it keep you separate in some artificial way?

Aiden Preston: Yeah, I think it's on two levels. Locally, it brings people together. Walk around the city of Philadelphia anytime, really, but especially during football season, and it's all midnight green and Kelly Green. I think that helps the eastern part of the state of Pennsylvania agree on one issue, which might help them agree on other issues. Whether or not those Philadelphians might agree with the Texans, yeah, that's to be determined. And they may have the opposite effect. But ideally, those common decisions being made between members of different states are occurring in higher levels of government where people are not being too reactive to the teams that someone might root for.

Ross Kenyon: I mean, if you did meet a Cowboys fan... I mean, the animosity has a little bit of a kayfabe approach to it, right? Like, it's part of the fun, but you don't actually hate each other. Like, there's actually probably a commonality of loving the sport. Like, for the love of the game, that's why you're there, right?

Aiden Preston: That's a really, really, really fair point and something I probably should have mentioned. Like, every time I see somebody in a Dallas Cowboys shirt, I say, oh, are they handing out free t-shirts somewhere? And they say, no, why? And I say, well, because I can't imagine anyone choosing to wear that. And most times it doesn't go over that well, but then other times people laugh and that would have been a stranger I didn't talk to, but a common language between us allowed us to break the ice.

Ross Kenyon: Wow. Your trollish nature brought you together in hating on their story.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, yeah. Maybe not forging a long-lasting relationship, but yeah, there is some commonality.

Ross Kenyon: Well, I think there's a lot of research actually about the power of weak tie relationships and how important they are. And even making small talk with a stranger is one of those things that empirically improves your day. You might be resistant to it, but if you allow yourself to go with it, it will, against your own will, make you feel better.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, this was a study in Chicago, right, where they forced people to talk to others on a train.

Ross Kenyon: I think so. I think I got it from Jonathan Haidt, I should say. I'll send you a link. We'll put it in the show notes.

Aiden Preston: Okay, yeah, please do.

Ross Kenyon: But yeah, I doubt it's the only one. I think there's a fair amount of research that shows that small talk is just good for us. And whatever, you want to goof around and sort of josh someone about their choice of sports teams. I think we probably could just use more of that overall. Everyone else is buried in their phones. If you want to tease someone politely, then it's probably an improvement, I think.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, to be determined, I guess. But I think Alan Hershkowitz is probably the father of sports sustainability, and he has a quote on his Wikipedia page about trying to build up NRDC presence at sporting events. And he's been talking about trying to reach untraditional allies. And basically, I think he was talking to Robert Redford, rest in peace, who said, if you want to meet real Americans, go to a baseball game or go to a football game. That's where people who probably aren't thinking about climate all day, or that's where people who aren't thinking about politics all day are. So you can meet someone as a human being first and then build solidarity. Then you're able to solve problems such as climate change or any of the other numerous issues facing us today.

Ross Kenyon: If they're watching baseball, you know they have free time available.

Aiden Preston: So that's really great. Well, they sped up the games to great success. And as someone who watches like 100 Mets games a year, I really appreciate it.

Ross Kenyon: How? I'm always like shocked. Like, how can baseball put on that many games, you know, 13 NFL season games or whatever, like 100 baseball games? How many even are there?

Aiden Preston: There's 162 in a season. This is a really great example of like the playoffs and baseball have expanded a couple of times over the years, adding more teams to the playoffs.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Aiden Preston: For me, I mean, I love watching playoff baseball, for sure. That's the thing. I'll sit there and I'll watch it, so I'm like a sucker. But I'm like, man, we played 162 games. Don't you think we could have just had a Final Four at that point? Do we really need to have eight teams make it from the 162? Shouldn't the 162 matter a little bit more? And the same thing for college football. College football playoffs, it was two teams playing in one game. That wasn't enough. That was probably unfair. So they made it four teams. Four-team playoff wasn't big enough. Some people felt like it was unfair, but I would say TV revenue, also a big reason for the expansion, expands to 12 teams. Now they're already talking after one year of making it 16 teams. And these are college athletes. And yeah, that's just cross-country travel because these teams are not in conference. Although conferences are also changing to aggregate brands and have more eyeballs on TV. I mean, now what used to be a regional football league, like the Big Ten, has teams from Oregon and Washington. So those are cross-country trips taken by college athletes and not just in football, but in volleyball and soccer, swimming. So these are public universities that are now increasing their admissions quite a bit in the name of, yeah, to accomplish basically increased sports revenue from the college football season.

Ross Kenyon: Wow. Here's a counterpoint though. The most profitable sport that I know of is cricket, I believe. And the number of games they put on is basically nothing. There's a dearth of cricket games. And they might actually be like the high profit, low emissions. Like, go talk to cricket. They might actually have the money to do this because they're not traveling that much. It's like going between Pakistan and India and like some of those countries in like South Asia. Like, there you go.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, they might have lower emissions though. It might make it harder to...

Ross Kenyon: That's what I'm saying though. They have lower emissions, but they have higher profit because it is just like that profitable fun. There's not that many games that they have to even put on. Like the profitability per game I think is the highest. I think I got this from the Acquired podcast. They did a show about cricket. Anyways, that's another free one for you, Aiden, of my brilliant ideas. You have to learn cricket now. You're clearly not as passionate about cricket.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, this is one of my, admittedly, one of my weak spots is the cricket competitions. But you know what? There's always time in life to learn new things. And it seems like a pretty interesting sport. I've seen a lot of cool highlights where outfielders make really good catches at the fence. And I love those kind of clips.

Ross Kenyon: What was unexpected about doing a report on this? It sounds like you know the subject matter very well. But doing a report, I'm sure you just come across things that were genuinely surprising. What was that for you?

Aiden Preston: I was genuinely surprised by how many leagues or teams had or have offsetting programs. I did not expect to see much of a history with using offsets. So every time I found one, usually buried in some not updated sustainability page, I was like, oh, look, they tried this. And then it also makes me sad because I'm like, I bet they got burned. I bet they didn't love the attention they may have gotten, whether it was negative or positive, or didn't feel like the dollars they were spending were actually accounting for the emissions that were being released into the atmosphere. That's my guess. Again, another hypothesis. So I would say that was the biggest surprise, this different smattering of teams across leagues and across the world who had tried offsetting at some point. I wish the market was more developed back then so someone could have pointed out and said, hey, if you're solving the climate crisis with $11 a tonne, yeah, probably not legitimate or worthy of making a compensatory claim against it.

Ross Kenyon: Well, you're very well positioned to do this. And then Milky Wire here, I'm going to try something out. Let me know if you like this. Robert, Anna Samuelson, if you're out there listening right now, Milky Wire is the Moneyball for carbon removal and climate action. You guys are finding those undervalued, weird little catalytic things that have been overlooked. You got that Jonah Hill vibe in there. What do you think about that?

Aiden Preston: Oh my God. You really could not be hitting me in a sweeter spot than the movie Moneyball. Like I said earlier about playing against my brothers, it was all about finding strategies to win and overcoming your physical limitations. And like nothing is better than Billy Beane and the Oakland A's organizing a team of misfits to go against the Yankees. And yeah, I do think we might have different aspirations than the Oakland Athletics at Milky Wire, but I think if you're looking for impact on a dollar spent, yeah, we're a team equipped to help you accomplish that goal.

Ross Kenyon: Are you getting a good...

Aiden Preston: No, Ross, this is the podcast that launches me into those conversations.

Ross Kenyon: Oh, okay.

Aiden Preston: I'm counting on your reach to break into the boardrooms of our major sports teams.

Ross Kenyon: I know a couple people that work at sports teams here. We'll talk about this later. I'll see if I can help you. One thing I really like about Curate in the UK is that they are focused on entertainment as a future pathway for carbon removal that can be really, really great. I think there are people who are starting to think about beyond the Stripes and Microsofts of the world. We all know that the budget just really isn't there without policy to force manufacturing companies or power generation companies to deal with this. It seems like entertainment is maybe one of those places where consumers are very sensitive. They might even switch allegiances based upon the politics of their organization. Sounds like you did. I know people always get really pissed off or they love it when something like, think about what happened with Taylor Swift and the Chiefs. Could there have been a better thing engineered even by the Pulpo City team at the Kansas City Chiefs than that?

Aiden Preston: No, I don't think the Chiefs could have asked for any more attention than what they got there. But I think artists also are contributing quite a bit to the climate problem with their private flights and should probably try to account for those emissions. So I think the entertainment industry, like the sports industry, is dependent upon travel emissions for its success. And to me, I think that these higher margin, higher profit industries kind of have an obligation to help decarbonize the hard to decarbonize, like aviation sector, for instance, because their profit margins are much lower and they probably aren't going to be able to invest in SAF and CDR alone to decarbonize. But why can't the sports industry, why can't the entertainment industry work to contribute to something that they depend on for their revenues?

Ross Kenyon: Aiden, something that is interesting to me is how conditionally you speak about this. They should probably try to work on this. There's three different ways you let them off the hook in that single sentence alone. Why don't you just tell them they got to do this? Come on, guys. This is the earth here. This is humanity not killing itself.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, this is fair. I think I've been trying to take a tack of someone who isn't throwing rocks because my guess is that these folks have heard those kinds of arguments before. So my argument is a positive one, is that they can actually make a difference in this industry. It's so early and it needs champions. This is a golden opportunity to be that kind of champion. And then secondly, yeah, you also have an obligation to do this. I left that out potentially. Like the internal tension of you trying to communicate this.

Ross Kenyon: Rough to watch, Aiden.

Aiden Preston: Yeah. Well, yes, I agree. It is rough to watch.

Ross Kenyon: Is it rough to feel as well?

Aiden Preston: It is rough to feel. It is rough to feel. I mean, this is probably the impetus for me deciding to write about this topic is I love watching the World Cup. I love watching the Olympics. And for those things that I cherish to have negative externalities bums me out. So I'm like, man, we really should figure this out. So we don't have to compromise on our beliefs in order to watch our favorite things on TV or go to see our favorite artists perform live. And now where's the money for that coming from? Well, these things I'm watching are generating record revenues. So maybe they should be contributing from that record revenue budget to carbon removal. And they should recognize that those revenues are going up as a result of their expansion. And as a result of their expansion, their emissions are going up. And they should take action to compensate for those emissions.

Ross Kenyon: There we go. I love that. You can edit out my conditionality from earlier.

Aiden Preston: No, that's a really important thing. I also speak that way sometimes, too, where it's really hard, actually, to issue a really affirmative...

Ross Kenyon: The declarative thing, Americans especially, we use kind of, we use things that soften it so that it's easier for someone to gracefully back out of what you just said. It's a big part of how we speak. And I think even in climate where you're like, no, we actually do really need to be doing this, is very serious. It's interesting, I think, when it does go there. I can remove it if you insist, but I think it's actually a really cool point.

Aiden Preston: I think it's fair. I won't insist on you removing anything.

Ross Kenyon: Jason Isbell is a country-ish folk artist, and he had a documentary come out recently, and he was a producer on it. A lot of these new documentaries that come out, the producers, the artists themselves, the producers, and obviously there's a huge conflict of interest there. And he said in an interview that he didn't ask them to remove anything. And he's like, they told me I had the power to cut things, but I felt like it's not really true if I cut anything. And he said, you know what? I didn't exercise that cutting power. So I don't actually know that I had it. If you don't use it, you don't know that they were lying to you. So that's how I'll approach this interview. I won't exercise any power. So I'm just going to assume that you would have honored my request if they did come.

Aiden Preston: Yeah, of course. No, I think I like the realness of it, too. And I grapple with how I speak about that as well. There's something that really makes even me feel a sense of vulnerability in declaring something so discretely where I'm like, it is this way. And you should do this. Can you give me an example of a time where someone was told you should do this? You need to do this? And they listened? I don't know. It has a very strong hierarchical authoritarian kind of frame. And I think even if it's right, it doesn't feel good. I remember being a kid and even in hindsight, we were like, yeah, my dad was right about that. Even still at the time, like, God, this feels like such a bully or God, this feels terrible. So, yeah, I think you're right about that. I think we've tried, as folks who recognize the gravity of the climate crisis, we've tried as individuals to name and shame, and I don't think it's gotten us very far. If our governments want to name and shame, yeah, I'll support those people for sure, because regulation is up to governments, but I'm not a regulator. I'm just a guy on a podcast. I'm looking at another guy.

Ross Kenyon: She's also on a podcast. I didn't want to ruin the rest of the quotes. What do we call the gap between the self-interested reasons for doing this, the more altruistic ones too, and the name and shame? Why don't we call that the Gulf of Aden? You know, why not? That name is on tape.

Aiden Preston: I really, really do not like the idea of renaming gulfs, especially not my own name.

Ross Kenyon: Oh, yeah. Okay, fair enough. Wow, I didn't expect it to go that way. That was probably one of the more esoteric wordplay jokes in this show. So thanks for listening. This show's history. That's saying something. It's out there, the Gulf of Aden. Okay, it's back. Is there anything that you want to single out before we conclude that's really important to you about this, that you'll just be heartbroken if you don't share?

Aiden Preston: No, I don't think there's anything else. I think, well, maybe this is a good parting thought. One of the most endearing parts of my personality is my Mets fanhood. As I said, I watch probably like 100 plus games a year and they've made me happy four times in my whole life. But the Mets have two sayings that I think are helpful for us who work in climate. The first being, there's always next year, which is inevitably printed after the Mets are knocked out for the season. That, okay, the world's not over. There's always next year. There's always tomorrow. We can still turn the tide. And then perhaps most importantly is you got to believe. And you got to believe. And that's kept me in Mets fanhood. That's going to keep me in the climate fight. And I do believe we can solve hard problems when we work together. I think we have an uphill battle in front of us in terms of working together on anything and then solving the climate crisis. But you got to believe.

Ross Kenyon: Aiden, thanks for being here. I'll put a link, of course, to the report in the show notes. Thanks for doing this. Thanks for getting, we went all over the place. I think we toured most of sports and how to speak. We did a lot of stuff. This is a classic episode of Reversing Climate Change.

Aiden Preston: And yeah, glad to participate.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?