Episode 373 of the Reversing Climate Change podcast. You can listen in on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you like to enjoy podcasts.
Adaptation begins at home. But it doesn't end there. What do you plan on doing with your family as climate change gets worse? Are you already making plans whether to stay or go? How should states respond as people flee disaster? Who should get access to fish stocks as they migrate to new regions? Once one starts asking these questions, they really don't stop...
Today's guest is Susannah Fisher, author of the new book, Sink or Swim: How the World Needs to Adapt to a Changing Climate. It's a wonderful catalogue of questions that asks and frames so many crucial discussions around people, nature, and politics.
Much of the first half of the show is about how it feels to start thinking about adaptation and resilience rather than more optimistic mitigation work, and why adaptation can bring its own solace. We might not need to panic just yet... and I enjoyed getting some emotional centering from Susannah's deep experience in A&R research and policy work.
This episode's sponsors

Absolute Climate: the only standard that’s developed independent of registries
Philip Lee LLP: legal resources for carbon removal buyers and suppliers
Listen to the RCC episode with Peter Minor from Absolute Climate
Listen to the RCC episode with Ryan Covington from Philip Lee LLP
Become a sponsor by emailing carbon.removal.strategies[at]gmail.com
Sign up for the 9Zero climate coworking space with my referral code
Resources
Susannah Fisher's Sink or Swim: How the World Needs to Adapt to a Changing Climate
There are various services where you can enter your address and view statistical flood and fire risk. Unfortunately since I last used it the one I used to use has been taken down..."
Yellow Jackets in France protests
Katrina: Come Hell and High Water by Spike Lee
More from the show
Ad-free episodes and other benefits come with a paid subscription.
Carbon Removal Newsroom, the news show that ran alongside this one, is over. Its episodes are still up, on the feed Climate Workers Anonymous now uses.
Carbon Removal Memes is still goofing around.
The books that come up on this show are collected on my Bookshop shelf.
🎧 Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube
Paid subscribers get this episode ad-free. The ads in the free feed are inserted by Spotify when you press play. They are not in the file I make.
Full Transcript
Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening. This is Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of Reversing Climate Change, the podcast you are listening to right at this very moment. Before we get into the bulk of today's show, I'd love to tell you about our sponsors, Absolute Climate and Philip Lee LLP. I've made great radio with both of them. They should be familiar to you if you listen to this show, but I want to tell you about why you should learn a little bit more. The first sponsor is Absolute Climate. I did a show with their founder, Peter Minor, a few months back. And a lot of people love that show. I was asking a question of, can registries design their own methodologies for carbon markets without it being a conflict of interest? And Absolute Climate's thesis is no. They shouldn't be in the business of doing that. We actually need to disintegrate functionality within carbon markets even further.
Ross Kenyon: They are literally the only independent standards body for carbon removal that exists. Their name is very well chosen. I think they are some of the most aggressively idealistic people within carbon removal. It's come up on Reversing Climate Change so many times about how and why there's tension between commercial teams and science teams within carbon markets. There's some fundamental tension between the rules of running a business, or I should say the rules of running a profitable business is maybe a better way to put that, and climate impact. And I think Absolute is one of those companies that, at least from my experience of what I know of them over there, I think they're going to be some of the staunchest holdouts, just trying to make sure that there can be a justified true belief that a tonne purchased is a tonne truly removed. They're betting big on not compromising.
Ross Kenyon: It's an old strategy. I respect the absolute hell out of that. Absolute is very much doing things their own way and they stand out to me and I will never mistake them in a lineup. Go check them out. I'm seriously fascinated by what they're doing. And that's also true of our other sponsor, Philip Lee LLP. In fact, I told them to pitch me on some weirder legal shows. I really like doing shows about the law. I think the law is such a fascinating part of our shared social life. It structures so much of it. It's badly understood by most people. And just structuring deals within carbon removal is hard. I'm talking grown up deals here. Like when you're trying to put together an enormous package, complicated structuring. A lot of money changing hands. The stakes are high. You really do need a good lawyer. I'm sorry to tell you that if you are a startup out there in carbon removal, you're going to probably pay a fair amount of money to lawyers.
Ross Kenyon: There's just no way around it. Your choice is basically, do you get a bad lawyer or a good lawyer? One really cool thing I can say on Philip Lee LLP's behalf, well, one... Ryan Covington and I did a very fun show about how basically no one except for an elite few really know what bankability and project finance even mean. And he lays it out very clearly. If you'd like to go listen to that show, it's awesome. And it's linked in the show notes. And also we ended up talking about Ernest Hemingway. So it keeps with the tradition of Reversing Climate Change. One also really cool thing is that they just won environmental finances VCM law firm of the year. They've run it three years in a row, 2023, 2024, and 2025. It's the only award for legal teams operating in the VCM, and they have offices in the U.S., Europe, and the U.K.
Ross Kenyon: You should check out Philip Lee LLP. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for listening to this, and thank you to our sponsors. You really make this so that it's something that, in a busy life with lots of competing priorities, I'm able to keep coming back and making more Reversing Climate Change. Thanks so much for what you do, and now, here is the show.
Ross Kenyon: Hey out there, thanks for listening. This is Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of this podcast, which is called Reversing Climate Change. Hey, here's a fun piece of news that will anchor this show. For the last unit of time, I'm not even sure how long at this point, I've been doing a fellowship with Lycan Ventures, which has been a lot of fun. They're a venture capital firm, a new one, focused on a number of different sectors. And I've been thinking quite heavily about adaptation and resilience investment and how to think about it. I come from carbon removal. That's where I cut my teeth. I'm still very, very passionate about carbon removal. But I'm also thinking a lot more about adaptation and resilience now. And I suspect you will probably see some of the shows that get programmed will go in that direction. That being said, there's a lot of adaptation topics that have come up on the show numerous times.
Ross Kenyon: So in some ways, it's probably not as big of a change as it sounds like. But today's show is absolutely an adaptation show. I'm gonna tell you all about it. First though, before we go down that path, please allow me to request of you to open up your podcast app and give Reversing Climate Change a five-star rating in whichever app that you use. If you use Apple Podcasts, you can also write a quick review and you can just say, this show is great. I love it. That would be so appreciated by me. And even five stars there does a heck of a lot of good. The same is true for Spotify. Open it up right now and give it five stars and that would be terrific. If you use some other podcasting app, that's also great. Please do it. Also, if you're a super fan, five dollars a month gets you access to bonus content that no one else gets.
Ross Kenyon: It's only for paid subscribers. It gets rid of the ads that Spotify puts into this show. And that would be wonderful. But also, hey, it's not strictly necessary. Thanks for just coming and listening and spending time with me and my brain and the people that I think are interesting. I'm grateful to you even for that alone. Okay, so this show today, Susanna Fisher, who wrote Sink or Swim, How the World Needs to Adapt to a Change in Climate. With a title like that, how could I not be interested? Susanna is a longtime researcher, deeply involved in climate change. Climate politics has been focused on adaptation for a long time. I think adaptation, at least within the climate tech spaces I've been working in for the better part of a decade, was a bit of a backwater for a long time. That's probably unfair. It probably represents just my orientation where I was focused, but it felt like adaptation wasn't as prominent when things were going better.
Ross Kenyon: When it felt like we were making progress, even during the first Trump administration and the Biden administration, just felt like there was momentum behind us. Like things were going in the right direction and we were making progress on climate and mitigation was working. Decarbonization was happening. Carbon removal was starting to wake up and starting to get to scale and it was coming. And now that just doesn't feel like it's happening to the same degree. Maybe you feel some of that. Maybe not. That's just sort of where it's been from where I sit. And as a result of that, the adaptation conversations are much more prominent. Everything from physical infrastructure of how should we build cities, rebuild cities, protect them, abandon them. Questions like that. Thinking about the spread of disease. I just saw 10 minutes before I started recording, I just saw an article saying that mosquitoes have been found for the first time in Iceland, and that's going to have an impact on adaptation.
Ross Kenyon: That is something for adaptation to address. We're going to have more mosquitoes, different kinds of mosquitoes in different parts of the world than they've been previously, and that will have major implications for public health. And those are the kinds of questions that will need to be dealt with. I'm really happy that Susanna was here to write this book, to frame this for me much better than it was previously, and also just to answer a lot of the questions that I have. A good chunk of the start of the show is dealing with grief and thinking through what it means to have a fundamentally adaptationist orientation to climate. That's been a bigger switch for me and I'm trying not to just shove all the feelings down and just get right to like, oh, well, how are we going to do personal cooling units? I'm trying to think through what it actually feels to be in a world where this technology is increasingly necessary.
Ross Kenyon: That's a non-trivial thing. And thinking about the personal ethics, we start from a very small, personal way of viewing this. What do you do for you and your family, given that the world is changing, the climate is changing, and you're trying to protect yourselves? Should you be thinking about immigration and going somewhere else? Or do you see your role as being a helper in a place that is going to face changes and is going to be potentially hard up, but you want to be there with your community? What actually do we owe one another? And how should we conceive of our obligations if you even believe such a thing exists? And then we start zooming out to bigger questions of how do we determine which fish stocks belong to which country or which companies, given that they're also migrating as a result of climate change?
Ross Kenyon: How do we avoid some of the worst problems that will result from the feedback loops that when there's mass immigration, how do we just avoid the sort of scarcity mentality that we have when, if the world is getting hotter and where people can go is limited, I think we're going to have to face a number of very difficult decisions about ethics, about governance, about food systems, about physical geography. About how we treat one another. These questions are so big. And it's one of the reasons why I love podcasting about climate change, because it truly is about everything. Everything touches this. Everything is touched by this. It's all over the place. And it's very useful to be thinking ahead, both for you personally, like how do you want to adapt? What kind of plans can you start making now? And also what kind of person do you want to be when you're asked to adapt or when you're forced to adapt?
Ross Kenyon: I think being able to grapple with this ahead of time and having a plan is a really important thing for determining which kind of person you want to be in the world, what kind of legacy would you like to leave to the world when you're gone? And how do we make sure that whatever does happen, we're able to best protect people, that we're best able to make sure that the worst effects of climate change and the downstream effects of it are mitigated as much as possible. So thank you to Susanna Fisher for being on the show. You should go pick up a copy of her book, Sink or Swim, How the World Needs to Adapt to a Changing Climate. I really liked it. I like that it's oriented around questions. I think that's a really cool thing about a book. It gave me a lot to think about.
Ross Kenyon: So thank you again. Here is your show.
Ross Kenyon: Susanna, thank you for being here.
Susanna Fisher: Thanks for the invitation.
Ross Kenyon: I'm very happy to have you. I read your book, really enjoyed it, gave me a lot to think about. And oftentimes I ask authors, why this book? There's so many books you could have written and yet you chose this one. But I'm going to skip that one and ask you a different kind of question, which is how did it feel to write this book?
Susanna Fisher: Wow. Well, it felt a relief in some ways because this book was really ideas I've been thinking about for probably at least a decade and were kind of building up and I was kind of putting bits together, both from my academic research, but also from my practical experience. But I hadn't really had the time to kind of sit down and think. It was a pretty long document that I was really able to get my thoughts in order and actually think, what is my contribution here? I've been feeling a bit dissatisfied with some of this for a long time and really wanted to make a big argument around it. Finally, through having the discipline of having to sit down and produce that manuscript, I kind of was able to really clarify about what I thought and what I wanted to communicate. So yeah, in the end, to get it out and get finished feels like a huge relief.
Ross Kenyon: I imagine some portion of the relief is publishing any book and finishing any large creative project is a relief. I ask this because I sense a lot of grief in your writing. It's hard working on adaptation, resilience. And recently, when I publish this, I'll probably have to announce at the same time, but I'm currently doing a fellowship at a new venture capital firm called Lichen Ventures. And I'm focused very closely on adaptation and resilience investments and which of them are actually backable in a venture capacity.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah.
Ross Kenyon: And I've been dealing with a lot of feelings about this because I come from carbon removal, which I think tends to be a very optimistic type of mitigation where, okay, we're going into overshoot, but we're going to be able to pull it back. Like the tech is happening. Good things are still possible. A&R work almost strikes me as we're not going to make it or we're going to be in overshoot longer than we really hoped. And I'm having a lot of feelings of melancholy and staring into what a future looks like where people are already placing bets on having profitable businesses that are based upon us failing to meet what we thought we were going to do for climate change. And I know you have some of those feelings. Maybe you feel more relief at this point. Maybe you process them. But I'm much earlier in this journey. So any free therapy I can get from you will save me on the therapy bills later. What can you tell me that will help me process some of these feelings?
Susanna Fisher: Well, I think firstly, it's important to not think about this as a binary, that we've failed or that we haven't failed. So greenhouse gas emissions and stopping burning fossil fuels is a kind of spectrum, isn't it? And unfortunately, we're not looking to reach the global average temperature target of 1.5 degrees. We're looking, unfortunately, at a rise above that, but also every fraction of a degree counts. So that's one of the things I hold on to. It's not only about a yes or a no with that side of the equation. It's also about, particularly for adaptation, a kind of spectrum about can we stop it getting any worse? And I think the answer is yes, we can always stop it getting worse. So I think that's one of the things I try and hold on to, especially when we see some of these deadlines slipping and there's a kind of doom narrative in the media.
Susanna Fisher: I think it's really hold on to the idea that things get more and more difficult. So it's not as if, oh, at two degrees we'll still be fine. Then 2.5 degrees is like every little bit counts. So I think that's a really important thing to hold on to. And I think the other thing I try and hold on to with adaptation is I think we can't think about it as giving up. So yes, we have reached a situation where we have to adapt and that is because we have failed on some aspects of mitigation. But also adaptation can be something to allow people to think again about their futures. And that's something I tried to think about in the book as well. Because as you say, otherwise it's like really tough because people's lives are getting worse. And as much as we can put in investments, it's only really to get them back to where they were before.
Susanna Fisher: And in many places in the world, people's lives are incredibly difficult without climate change, just adding an extra stress and it just seems impossible. So I think one of the ways you have to think about this is what could the additional climate risks also do? Like what could they open up in terms of finance or opportunity or like possibility space for people to try and design new futures for themselves? And I think it's maybe trying to think about it as that leverage point or that position or possibility of like a new politics.
Ross Kenyon: A wise answer, one that I'm going to probably listen back to several times in dark moments, trying to be like, okay, I need to keep this in mind. Because my mind often goes to, if we can attribute increased environmental stressors and disasters to climate change, and we're likely to have more of them this century, that could create crop failure, droughts, floods. This will lead to emigration. I worry that we're going to develop a more humane system that understands our responsibility and a need to practice genuine hospitality and understanding and warmth towards our fellow humans and species and other species, I should say. I worry that worldwide just get nastier, smaller, hotter. There's just a chance for us to redesign the social contract and what it means to be a human or what it means to be another species. Or are the odds good that we're just going to get more scarcity minded, more xenophobic, more protective of the little that we have that might be changing with climate change?
Susanna Fisher: So, I mean, I think you're kind of outlining two different futures there. And yes, the one that you've obviously spent more time thinking about and you're worried about is what I would think of as almost the sink scenario. This is if we don't manage to put in place policies, incentives, regulation, social organizing and mobilization around different ways of doing things. And yeah, it's a huge risk, what you say. And obviously, I see that too. And we see what's happening around the world right now. And the indications are that some of those triggers are being pulled and that people are responding by kind of putting down the borders and the shutters and creating a kind of us and them. And I think that's a real fear. And it's something that we see and we have to hold on to. But also, I think we have to, in the kind of words of Christiana Figueres, who's always about stubborn optimism.
Susanna Fisher: So, you know, the former executive secretary of the UNFCCC is kind of saying, well, we have to really hold on to optimism. And I think it's important not to be naive about optimism, but also to try and be what she calls gritty. So, you know, yes, we have those fearful scenarios and it could play out that way, but what would it mean to play out differently and what do we need to do? And so if we're thinking about migration, whether that's internal to a country or across a border, you know, what do we need to put in place so that places that are receiving people are not feeling put upon and that their services are massively, you know, under pressure and that they can't kind of cope with additional populations. So there are things that we can do and examples that we see elsewhere where this has gone much better.
Susanna Fisher: So I think we still have to think, like, what would it take to do things differently? And where is my place in that ecosystem to chip away a little bit at, you know, what might look better?
Ross Kenyon: You just mentioned that there are places that have done this better than others. What are those places?
Susanna Fisher: Well, I mean, in terms of movement, you know, we see, say, countries in the Caribbean have a regional movement protocol. So when they're hit by a hurricane, citizens can move from one country to another. They can take their social protection benefits with them, because obviously a huge problem is kind of the mobility of that type of support. And suddenly you arrive somewhere without your systems and everything. So, yeah, I mean, we see examples there, particularly around disasters. Obviously, more recently, we've seen, say, a migration pact set up between Tuvalu and Australia to look at climate-related migration for skilled workers. Anyway, so, I mean, we see these little pockets. And, you know, there have been political discussions at other times about humanitarian visas or climate visas. And they haven't gained traction, but they are kind of policy ideas in the soup. And I think, you know, in the context also of the ICJ ruling, which kind of put a much bigger emphasis on states having to address the issues of climate change and taking responsibility, you know, these things just might gain traction. And I think that the legal angle is one angle that that could go. But the other is seeing other policy examples from around the world and actually seeing that the long term benefits of that can far outweigh the short term political costs.
Ross Kenyon: Man, I am such a downer because I'm okay. So there's a part of your book. I had it pulled up here, what did you say? Oh, it's on page 29. And it says, the good news is now that it's not very likely that we're headed towards a four degree or five degree Celsius warming world. The ship is turning slowly. And this, I know books take a long time to come out. I've worked in publishing. This is clearly written in a different US administration or.
Susanna Fisher: Yes, you can see that part.
Ross Kenyon: Yeah. And then even this past week, we had the International Maritime Organization say that they're not going to be dealing with emissions in the way that we were all really hoping for. Climate multilateralism is not a popular move right now. It's endangered. What's changed? Does this compromise some parts of the thesis of the book or is it just a temporary setback? I'm hearing myself say these things and honestly, I don't like being in this role. I like feeling more optimistic than this and I'm having a hard time with it personally.
Susanna Fisher: I mean, I think the economics of the transition is still in favor of what I wrote in the book, but with renewables becoming much cheaper, with the big push from China on solar in particular, that there is a kind of inevitable move towards that transition. And yes, there are really unfortunate policy hiccups in place, the kind of shipping example being a really sad one, because that looked like progress was being made and that would have been a really important step. But I think if we take the bigger picture, we are still heading in the right direction. And I guess it's a question of pace. So how quickly are we going to get there? And I think this comes back to the earlier point that speed does matter because if we're still heading in the right direction because of the economics of the energy sector, it matters whether we get there sooner rather than later because of the damage that will be done in terms of loss and damages around the world and the adaptation and the limits we're going to face.
Ross Kenyon: I'm able to take some comfort in what you said that every fraction of a degree does actually matter and does make a material difference for people that on the margin may or may not be suffering dependent upon the actions that are taken now or in the near future. And that is something that can be encouraging. If it was binary, we're either safe and no action is necessary or we're doomed and no action is truly possible. That doesn't leave a lot open. But this thinking in terms of gradations, I think is actually a very useful framing.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, and I've actually found that really helpful as I've thought through a lot of the arguments in the book and things that I've read in the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, for example. I think some of the ideas around like habitability, like where are places in the world that are going to become impossible to live? You know, I really increasingly understand that as a question, as not being such a hard limit as I had understood before, that it being quite values driven in terms of where are people willing to live? You know, what risks are they willing to bear? What measures can we put in place to help them live there? So I do think a lot of this is about kind of gradations and we can lessen the impact. And yeah, you know, there aren't as many hard limits as you might think.
Ross Kenyon: I think I'd like to start at the personal level. Well, we kind of already did. And then work our ways up to increasing levels of abstraction or ecology. I imagine every person listening to this show has had the thought, or if not, we're going to put it in their brain right now, of thinking in terms of the decades of your life and where it makes sense to build a life, where is a safe place to raise a family, how do you minimize the risks for your children over time. There's plenty of stories and research. I did a show with Clayton Aldern where we talked about some of both current generational trauma from extreme weather events, but also the epigenetic legacy of those that can pass on through generations and how you want to minimize exposure to disaster if you at all can. So where do you choose to be? But I've also been thinking as someone who is striving to be more humane and a good ancestor, if you will, or just a good influence in my community. I'm also not sure that my role is, if I'm right about this, and I end up moving my family someplace that is perceived to be safer than where I am in the United States, I might be... How do you think about that? For yourself, how should people listening think about it? I'm grappling with it. I'm surely going to do another show about the ethics of climate immigration on a personal level in the future. I'm thinking about it a lot. Please tell me what you think.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, I mean, it's such a huge issue, isn't it? Because there's what we experience personally as an individual and then how we think about our sense of community and what community we're actually part of. And then, of course, also what we do in our professional lives and how the knowledge that might influence. I think I mean, so for me personally, I live in what I'd say would be a fairly safe place in the UK. I live in London and we're protected by the Thames Barrier. So we have a quite serious infrastructure to prevent flooding.
Ross Kenyon: I looked it up after you mentioned it in the book. It is really cool.
Susanna Fisher: I mean, although you do read climate fiction about London being flooded and there being particular risks, I'd say that we are in a fairly stable position right now. And so in some ways, these decisions haven't really come across on my mind, I have to confess, because personally, I'm quite distant from some of these climate risks. But we see media stories all the time now about the fact that the UK is going to be facing increasing risk from, for example, food prices because of our position within supply chain networks. And if we were to experience any of the tipping points also, that could really shift because the UK would be really exposed to some of the ocean currents and circulations move. So although perhaps I feel a false sense of security now about where we're based, that could, of course, all change in the future. Although I should say that when we thought about buying a house, we did look at the flood maps.
Susanna Fisher: So at a personal level, you are looking at, is this at the bottom of a river? What's that going to look like from an insurance perspective? So you kind of are making micro-level household decisions. And also actually to say, I mean, extreme heat is becoming a bigger thing in the UK, which might sound like a surprise to some listeners. But I guess if you're not used to it, right, because our housing stock is very poor and our schools are not made to be ventilated. So the kids, for example, will have days off school if it's too hot because they just can't keep the places cool. So yeah, I guess it's a rambling way of saying that kind of from an individual way, we're all kind of weighing up our own risks. But I do really hear you about, is it ethical to make a move away if your place is at high risk?
Susanna Fisher: And what does that mean for others who can't move? And also, what does it mean for the place that you move to? Because, you know, there's a bit of a risk of climate gentrification where people who have the resources, money and kind of flexible employment situation to do so move to the much safer places, make them more expensive. And then other people can't follow. And yeah, I can't really offer the answer to that, except that we need to kind of weigh up every choice. And it's so hard because, of course, at the forefront of our minds is our own nuclear family in all likelihood and balancing that with wider priorities, both to a community and to a wider country is pretty tough.
Ross Kenyon: It's a really tricky one, and it's not just about climate either. This argument gets brought up in private insurance for healthcare. It gets brought up for public schooling, where the parents who are wealthier and or very engaged with their children's education will pull their kids out of the public school and send them to a better school. But then you just don't have parents who are as engaged as otherwise might be. You might improve the public school, or you have healthy people who opt for better insurance, but then they make fewer claims on the system, but then they're no longer there to pay into them. If you're able to think collectively about it and abstract yourself out of it, you think this is clearly inefficient and probably the wrong way to dole out risk. But also if you're the person whose kid has to go to a dangerous or inferior school when you have the option to otherwise, it's hard to look a parent in the eye and tell them that they're a horrible person for doing that.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah.
Ross Kenyon: I feel both of those things really strongly. The positionality really changes how one might feel about it, which is a good indication that there's maybe multiple valid perspectives here. I'm not trying to cast a universal moral rule so much as trying to figure out what kind of life I want to live and who I want to be in that world. And I think previously I would have been like, well, pull my kid out, like put them in the best place for them and everyone will go to hell essentially. And I don't actually know that I want to feel that or be that as strongly as I once did. I don't think I'm very proud of that attitude.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah. But I think, as you say, when you look at it from the lens of your children or young people that you know, it does kind of change your perspective. And I think thinking about the future of my kids in the climate change world definitely brings it home in a way that thinking about it for me doesn't necessarily. And maybe that's just a failure of imagination on my part, because we will see lots of this within our lifetimes, but it's just so hard to really feel that, where somehow feeling it for somebody or something whom you've got responsibility over makes it more poignant, for me at least.
Ross Kenyon: I think at some point you probably just enter a time in your life when you're thinking more about your own death and know that it is inevitable. And knowing that you have to die sometime makes it easier to make decisions about like, okay, am I supposed to cravenly eke out as many years as possible in the safest place? Or what if I could add a lot of value and help a lot of people being in a more dangerous place that might shorten it? I think as a younger person, you might be attracted to that from...
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. It's just a tricky intersection.
Ross Kenyon: You didn't expect the interview to go this way, I don't think. This is why I love talking about climate change, though, because it's never just as simple as, well, do we need more seawalls? Do we need personal cooling devices? That's part of it, but I think that's kind of downstream from the bigger questions that, I mean, your book is really nicely organized because it asks questions and you pose them well, but it doesn't seem like you're always telling people the exact way to slice every issue either. How should we deal with fish that are migrating in the oceans and maybe moving to different places? Do you have the final say on exactly the right way to do it? I don't think you pretend to.
Susanna Fisher: Well, phew, that's a relief. Yeah. I don't either.
Ross Kenyon: How do you deal with that?
Susanna Fisher: I didn't set out to provide the answers. And I think that's because I'm a strong believer that there are no right answers. They're incredibly complex, political, but also I've been talking value-based decisions, right? So it's about what people value. And there needs to be a political contestation about that. And who am I to sit here in London and say this is right for the Pacific Islanders and their fisheries? Absolutely, I do not have the answer. But what I'm trying to do is really open up the questions because I think the questions are quite invisible sometimes. So if we can even see what's on the table, then people can start to think on what might be the right way that we would want to address this in our place at this time.
Ross Kenyon: Which of your hard adaptation questions do you think are the most invisible that we should bring up right now?
Susanna Fisher: Well, I think the one on the role of the military. Before I started really researching around that, and I've worked in adaptation for at least 15 years, I hadn't really thought about it, I have to confess. But when I was reading much more widely across the literature and the kind of scholarship, it just seems so apparent to me that, you know, the role of the army is changing and we're using them in different ways. And that could be beneficial, but it could also have some negative consequences. But it's kind of, I think, not on the table. So, yeah, I think that's a really interesting one.
Ross Kenyon: Coincidentally, and this is totally by accident, but Erin Sikorsky, who just wrote Climate Change on the Battlefield, will be the episode right previous to yours.
Susanna Fisher: Oh, great. Maybe we should leave it to her because she's written a whole book on it.
Ross Kenyon: No, I think it's a fascinating one about the missions that are changing, about how much disaster relief and preparedness militaries are being asked to do, in addition to normal military duties. It's a really big question. And also, it's surprising to see how much they're already expected to do that is fairly invisible, I think, to most citizens.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, and of course, it's pragmatic, right? You've got a resource there. It's got redundancy, but it's got redundancy for a reason, though it can respond to a sudden unexpected threat. So if you keep using it to respond to the UK flooding often, then that has implications. But also I think it's a question about do we want our disaster relief to be managed by the military? Maybe we feel it's fine in some contexts, but in some contexts it really might not be. And certain groups will not get the benefit of that. So I think it raises a lot of questions.
Ross Kenyon: In the United States, we have...
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, like a civil defense corps, but then obviously you'd have to pay for it. So there you'd come up against whether that's how countries want to invest in their disaster planning.
Ross Kenyon: I also imagine the kinds of people that you would be able to recruit would change. I think a lot of people who join the military join it because of the opportunities that are there or because they're very much invested in that military culture. They come from a family where there's heritage in there. I don't think a lot of them are joining because they want to line up sandbags when it floods somewhere. I think that's like a different kind of person almost.
Susanna Fisher: They'll do what they feel they signed up for, yeah.
Ross Kenyon: Yeah, they'd be like, what the heck? I want to be rocking a .50 caliber on top of a Humvee. I don't want to be out here in the dirt or fighting a forest fire. I'm not a firefighter. Now somehow I'm a firefighter. So I wonder how that might change. Also, good Aaron question. So if you're listening and you missed that, just go back and listen to the Aaron show, which I also haven't recorded, which is a paradox of time. I'm caught in a time loop right now.
Susanna Fisher: She's the expert on that one. But another one which I think is really interesting, which maybe you haven't got an episode right before on, is also the nature angle. So, you know, I was also kind of struck by this fact that in the adaptation world, we don't talk so much about nature as we should. And, you know, biodiversity has been very separate from the climate conversations. But not only is nature a huge way to adapt to climate change, it's also, you know, we need to adapt nature in that species are moving up to the higher latitudes. They can't exist anymore in some of the places where they are. And unless we support those kind of movements, we're going to have these mass extinctions. So I think it's maybe a bit of an extension of how the adaptation concept is being used so far. But if we think holistically, I think it's really important to think about how do we also adapt the natural world around us.
Ross Kenyon: I remember reading stories about this. I think I originally started hearing these stories from Elizabeth Kolbert talking about how species on mountains have nowhere left to go.
Susanna Fisher: Exactly. They've reached the edge of their adaptation point. They've gone as cold as they can get.
Ross Kenyon: Yeah. Yeah. And that's also happening at the latitudinal layer too.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah. The polar regions. Yeah. Yeah.
Ross Kenyon: And I imagine they're just human built infrastructure that blocks them a lot of the time. They just cannot move like they once might have in terms of.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, exactly. I mean, we don't have these in many places, these huge wild ranges anymore where animals can just move across where they need to. And yeah, there are efforts to build those kind of transboundary corridors, but often, of course, you get kind of people-wildlife conflicts, which have to be managed. So for example, rewilding has been something that has been also put forward as a potential strategy, but that's often full of conflict too, because the farmers don't necessarily like it. You know, bring the beavers. That seems great. They're really helping out with the kind of damming around the rivers. But on the other hand, they're also apparently releasing methane and, you know, getting into people's crops.
Ross Kenyon: I mean, I like some of the research that I've seen of paying ranchers for livestock kill. So if a wolf outside of Yellowstone kills a cow or a sheep or something like that, under certain conditions, they're eligible to be recompensed for that, which is great because it reduces conflict or at least doesn't make it cool. I'm glad the abstract Yellowstone environment is better, but I'm made more poor as a result. I think that's just bound for conflict. I think some of these things will probably require some amount of greasing of sympathies. Just be like, all right, here's a payment. You're going to have some beavers and they might eat some of your crops sometimes.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And I mean, we've seen that on the other side of the coin, right? When we tried to phase out coal, for example, we've used payments. Like in Germany, they've set up great pensions and social benefits for coal miners to help them rescale and move over. And it kind of gets rid of some of the resistance that you have to something new is to help the people who were benefited by the old system grow. To kind of see what the new system could offer or at least compensate them for their loss. I mean, or else the kind of resistance that you receive, especially, you know, something like the agricultural lobby is absolutely massive. And, you know, fair enough, they're having a pretty tough time in many countries producing foods under the global context and all the subsidies and everything. So, sure, they feel under pressure. So, you know, we've got to think, what are the incentives and regimes going to be that's going to bring them on board? Because, I mean, they're kind of, you know, it's a bit of a struggle in biodiversity, but in a few aspects of how we might adapt land, it's often a question of how can we bring the farmers on board?
Ross Kenyon: You have some line in the book that's near the end of it where it's just something like, reforming agricultural subsidies is tricky business. I was like, understatement of the book, like circle, circle, circle. I had a conversation recently with someone who was criticizing environmentalists for ethanol. I'm like, I don't think I know any environmentalists who even like ethanol. I mean, they might work with biofuels to some extent for various other projects, but I don't think it would exist were it not for the ag lobby that just sort of has subsidies and making the best of it. I think pretty much everyone I know who's environmentally motivated is like, yeah, we should probably just not do ethanol. It costs more in energy than we get out of it. And it's basically just a giveaway to farmers. And it doesn't really make sense. I think I said the same thing like seven times and I still didn't get through like, well, environmentalists really love this. I'm like, I work in this space. I don't think I've ever heard anyone say anything nice about it. And yet it's just stuck. I don't think it's going anywhere, probably forever. I don't think you could get rid of it and stay in office. So I can't imagine what it's like in places like India, where it seems like the politics of agriculture are much more close to the bone. Not just will I keep the farm, but maybe I'll starve or be seriously endangered. Tell me about why changing ag policy is so difficult.
Susanna Fisher: It's tricky.
Ross Kenyon: Thank you. Okay, next topic.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, I mean, as you say, agriculture is so close to people's lives. And I mean, depending on where people live, it's really like just a matter of kind of subsistence and literally how they're surviving versus more of an industrial enterprise and a business. And I think in many places, it's become really, really tough over the years, you know, for a variety of reasons of which climate is one, but there are many others. And so those places have often become or those kind of groups have often become really strong political blocks pushing for their needs because they felt that they had to. And I think, you know, it's important to come to adaptation with a bit of a lens of kind of empathy and that nobody's just trying to resist what's good for the planet because they're bloody minded, although we might take that argument in other places.
Susanna Fisher: But right now, let's kind of take a generous lens and say, you know, farmers are having a really, really tough time in many places. And so they just feel they can't take anything else on. And also often the things that have been offered, you know, to try and support biodiversity, I think kind of with the European context, have been like hugely bureaucratic and kind of, you know, the money's hardly been worth it. So, you know, fair dues, we have to design something better. Yeah. In many cases, it feels like the taking away because we've got so many subsidies in place now that actually aren't really fit for purpose, but they've just built into how people have made their lives. So to take something away is a really tough, tough option. So like I said, I think it's kind of about, if we think about the comparison with energy being the just transition to move out from coal, I feel like with agriculture, it's like, what is the just agricultural transition?
Susanna Fisher: Like, what payments do we need to make? You know, what do we need to put in place as subsidies to incentivize this action, but in a way that farmers actually care about rather than what's been just, you know, not enough for them really in the face of what they see. But I also think that increasingly, you know, agricultural producers are feeling the cost of climate change. They're feeling the escalating costs of insurance for the crops. The loss on the supply chains, the kind of risky nature of some of it. So I think there'll be a push in the other direction as well. And I think, so for example, in Europe, there was a big push by the kind of agricultural block against a restoration law, a kind of nature restoration law. But actually, when you looked at some of the things that people wanted or kind of agricultural blocks wanted, they also wanted things that were going to protect them from climate change.
Susanna Fisher: They wanted more support for droughts and floods. So, you know, there's a lot, I think, that goes into the feeling of resistance. And some of it is actually things that addressing climate change could help with.
Ross Kenyon: It seems that you're very well positioned to calm yourself emotionally, be able to change your language depending upon the audience you're speaking with, and maybe find some of those potential upsides without the bludgeons that the left uses sometimes on climate that are genuinely alienating to people who are maybe making agricultural income. Is that a way that you might identify? Do you think you're good at something like that?
Susanna Fisher: You know, we've created the agenda as being too small and it's been perceived increasingly to be elite. And it has to build a broader based coalition because the kind of response we're going to need, not just on energy, but on adaptation is going to need, you know, a much wider group of people involved and feeling like it's their agenda and it matters to them. So a big part of my kind of philosophy is how do we get people on board to realize the impacts of what's going to come, but also to kind of make it relevant to their daily lives and the challenges that they experience. So it doesn't feel like some kind of high level, you know, green only agenda. It's basically an agenda about how we live our lives and how communities around us live our lives and how we can make that work in the next 20 to 30 years.
Ross Kenyon: I like this frame. I think it's an especially productive one. And I like it better as well, more than the counter bludgeon of what if we just reopened coal plants and operated them at a loss just as a make work program for coal miners in the US. It offends our moral sensibility. And there's also a cobra problem here, too. Do you know that one? Is that familiar to you?
Susanna Fisher: No.
Ross Kenyon: The British Raj in India offered, they were trying to get rid of cobras, and they offered a head price for every cobra that was brought in. So, of course, people just bred cobras and sold them to the British Raj. So, it didn't actually result in India. So you might encourage more dictatorly behavior because there's a chance of a payoff in the future. So if you've just ignored the second order effects of that for a second, you're like, it might offend our moral sensibilities, but in the U.S. especially, I think we have an attitude that may not be as common in other places that you chose your profession and that hopefully involved you making a risk determination for a lifetime of productivity that you were taking the risks of the upside and the downside of your. It seemed like a great opportunity 20 years ago. Now that's changing potentially with AI.
Ross Kenyon: You didn't see that coming. And too bad for you. You're now unemployed. And we would kind of say, like, sorry, that's just the way that it is. And maybe we do need to treat this more as a generalized insurance thing. We actually don't know when people are born who will be disabled or not. And so it makes sense to treat that as just like it's a luck of the draw and it shouldn't be like on the family alone to take care of a family where it's just genetic lottery in that kind of way. And maybe that's true of careers too. Maybe someone chose to be a farmer or was born into that and that just seemed best and it's changing now. And we can't just say, well, like, sorry, I guess you need to sell your farm and debt and you may not be able to retire.
Ross Kenyon: Maybe we just need to think a lot of people are going to need to be paid off to do something that might just feel better, be easier, be better for the planet in general. It comes very unnaturally to Americans. I don't know if it comes any more naturally to the British people or people in Europe, but it offends our moral sensibilities, I think, at a really core level to be like, you chose wrongly, here's a million dollars as your buyout. You don't like it that much.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, I mean, I guess the question is why you're doing it, you know, because if people can, say with the software and AI example, if you've got a highly skilled population there who have made the wrong bet or translators being another one, they can fairly easily switch over. They've got a great skill set. It's no problem for them. And they're also kind of not holding anything back for the greater good, as far as I know. But if there is a software lobby, we can discuss that. I guess the issue of the kind of re-skilling agenda or like the supported move agenda is, for me, is when those kind of employment groups are like seriously blocking action that we need for the collective good. So, you know, if we really can't make progress on how we manage land in a biodiverse way, for example, because the agricultural blocks just won't allow it, then that for me is when there's a kind of collective case for, okay, well, we're going to have to, you know, pay out essentially to transition this over and to help those groups kind of see the bigger argument. And yeah, and perhaps it does come easier from a more kind of state interventionist perspective, which is, you know, I guess what we're sitting over here on the European side of the fence. And maybe we can try that first here and, you know, see how it works. Because I guess it's not like solutions are going to be rolled out globally. So I guess it's going to be a situation of people are going to try something, you know, see what works, try a bit more. Lessons will be learned, hopefully.
Ross Kenyon: So let's see. A lot of these problems feel that they don't fit inside of most of the timelines that politicians work with. This might be some abstract, generalizable good, but if you're up for election, this might just represent a tax hike. Seemingly, that's a giveaway to a powerful lobby. I don't know if it's good politics.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, I think lots of adaptation is long term risk management. It's not short term good politics. And that's why we haven't really progressed so much. I mean, yes, you're right. On the one hand, the cost of something like that, but many other things as well, like preventing people from building along coastlines or, you know, stopping businesses going into floodplains. All of that doesn't look good. Well, at the same time, you're arguing for affordable housing and, you know, business growth. And the kind of stability of your town. So, yeah, I think one of the central questions I'm wondering in the book and in myself now, in my future work, is that how do we manage that short-term political cost and that long-term political and economic and societal gain? At what point will those longer term, and I say longer term, but really I'd say like medium term now, when will those benefits be able to win out? And what are the conditions under which they'll win out?
Ross Kenyon: Do you have any answer or a speculation, wild or otherwise?
Susanna Fisher: Was that, do I have any speculation? Well, I was just going to suggest maybe we should have longer term political cycles, but then I thought, oh God, I don't actually know if that's a good idea.
Ross Kenyon: Yeah, it might fix its own problems, but.
Susanna Fisher: Yes, yeah, yeah. I mean, you know, other people have thought about this in terms of should we engage young people? Should we have like advisory councils that kind of set the broader tone, you know, on these kind of issues? And then the government is trying to kind of just deliver within. So like in the UK, we have something called the Climate Change Committee and it's independent. And it at least provides a kind of, it has a mandate to look back and report on how the government's doing. So it's a way of verifying whether we're making progress that doesn't sit only with the political party of the day. But, you know, so saying their most recent report on our adaptation progress said we were making inadequate progress. So, you know, we have the ratcheting mechanisms in place, but it's still not perfect.
Ross Kenyon: I had thought this might be a good role for a non-executive head of state like the UK has, where cannot the House of Windsor, which I know King Charles is famously like longtime environmentalist. He's into climate change. Like, is this not a role for like longer term political leadership? This faces its own dynamics as well. But that's like the probably the best like objective case for having this, I think, is longer time horizons.
Susanna Fisher: And this is your case for the monarchy, is it?
Ross Kenyon: I mean, that and I think the tourism dollars is probably all you've got. The rest of it just looks like it's cool.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, the tourism angle. Yeah.
Ross Kenyon: Is there a case to be made for environmentalists coming that way?
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, I mean, I think there's a case for moral leadership on their part. You know, like, obviously, Prince, now King Charles, has played that role for a long time. And now William is doing it as well with their Earthshot Prize and all of that. So I think they can kind of set a general tone. But I mean, ultimately, they're obviously not political decision makers. So that can only go so far.
Ross Kenyon: I've also read that the rivalry for moral leadership, even between father and son on that, is pretty tense. So even having an Earthshot prize is like, you're stealing thunder from the king right now and you shouldn't be doing this.
Susanna Fisher: Sounds like you know more royal gossip than me.
Ross Kenyon: Why do I, by the way? I don't know that that should be the case. You can probably read stories that are blocked at this end.
Susanna Fisher: Oh. Could be.
Ross Kenyon: I started watching The Crown is what happened and then I fell down the rabbit hole and I'm like, oh, this is actually sordid and fascinating and bizarre. And then I never came back out of it. So I have hope. I feel like that is the thing that they could do, but maybe you're right. Maybe it is at the level of persuasion. I think when royal activism does happen, I imagine people roll their eyes a little bit of being like, oh yes, the environmental thing that you'd like to do given that you have so much money in all of your estates and I'm glad you do weird eco farming there. But that's not real life. That's not how we live. I imagine there's probably some amount of eye rolling that even happens in the UK when there is royal activism.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah, I mean, I don't think that's the family to really bring it home to, you know, a local resident in Hull about what it is going to mean, which, by the way, is a city in the north of England on the coastline, you know, what it's going to mean for their lives if their flat gets flooded. Yeah, they can kind of provide a bigger narrative. But I mean, they're not obviously integrated into how most people live their lives.
Ross Kenyon: So then what? How are we going to get people to think long enough time?
Susanna Fisher: I think trying to make them more secure probably is a start.
Ross Kenyon: Yeah. Because if you have your needs met, I think you're able to forecast a little bit farther out. You're able to think about the future.
Susanna Fisher: Exactly. Yeah. I mean, how can you think about the future unless you're currently food secure and secure in terms of safety?
Ross Kenyon: And also if we frame this more in terms of, all right, people who are impacted are going to get paid out. We're not just going to expect you to foot the cost of this generalized phenomenon here that I think that whenever it sounds like you're going to take my farm away from me or you're going to force me to do something differently in this way, I think that also just strikes me as a loser. And that's also kind of how you get yellow jackets like in France. I think we want to avoid yellow jackets coming about.
Susanna Fisher: Yeah. Exactly. That's when you get resistance is when you kind of come in with this big agenda of loss. Like you're going to lose this and you're not going to be able to do this. And this is going to cost you a lot of money. And I mean, that's never going to be the way we're going to get around the short term political cost. It has to be an exciting, forward-looking agenda. It has to hook on to what people care about, which is employment, inequality, health, education, you know, all of which are at risk from climate change. So it's fairly easy to make that argument, but it hasn't been made very convincingly so far.
Ross Kenyon: And you're advocating that Meghan Markle should take up the laurel for that, and that should be our leader of our A&R movement. Is that right? I believe that was your suggestion.
Susanna Fisher: Oh, it was my suggestion. I mean, like, we're going to need unconventional leaders in it, aren't we? Because the political timeframes are short. So we are going to need, like, moral and other authority from all kinds of places to shift us in the right direction. If Meghan Markle's part of that, then great.
Ross Kenyon: I just watched that new Netflix three-parter Spike Lee New Orleans documentary about Katrina and the aftermath.
Susanna Fisher: I've not seen it yet.
Ross Kenyon: It's pretty good and disturbing in all the ways that you might expect. But in the aftermath episode, they talk about the housing program that Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie were super involved in. And it was a big failure. Like a lot of the houses, they just weren't made well and they got sued. That's unconventional leadership, right? That's celebrity leadership. But celebrity leadership, especially in the U.S., gets accused of hypocrisy or being sort of, I mean, granted politicians, are they much smarter than the average actor? I'm not even sure that's true. Maybe we shouldn't hope that much over there either.
Susanna Fisher: Well, I guess, you know, a politician, when they decide to, for example, do disaster relief, they're obviously not designing exactly what they do themselves. So at least we can say like with the state, if a politician's like, right, we need to do this, we'll invest the funds, then hopefully you'll have enough of a civil service behind there to make the kind of right decisions and find the right technical options. Obviously, it's usually problematic when you have individuals who've got enough money to jump in, but don't really have the know-how to do it. And yeah, I mean, we see that in a fragmented way. And I guess the question is, how can we harness those people's enthusiasm and effectively their money into something that is more systemic? Because also, you know, a dot here and a dot there, if it's not joined up, it's not going to be enough.
Ross Kenyon: Susanna, thanks for being here. I'm grateful that I got a chance to read your book. And if you're listening, you should go pick up a copy of it and read it. It made me think. There's so much about adaptation. We barely even scratched the surface of it in this episode. There's so much more to say. So thanks for entertaining my, what is likely to be your only interview kind of like this, I think.
Susanna Fisher: Thanks, Ross. It's good to chat.












