Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Earth’s Oldest Miners: Microbes

Astrobiologist and CEO Liz Dennett on how microbes could help power the energy transition, why copper might be civilization’s next bottleneck, and what it means to mine responsibly in a warming world

What if microbes could help us mine responsibly? What if astrobiology—the study of life beyond Earth—held clues for how to fix the way we extract resources on Earth?

Today’s guest is Liz Dennett, CEO and founder of Endolith, a biotech startup using microbes to boost copper recovery from mining waste. With a PhD in astrobiology, experience at NASA, and a career spanning oil, gas, and data science, Dennett is one of the most fascinating polymaths in climate tech.

This episode dives into how microbes mine metals, why copper is civilization’s next constraint, and what it means to clean up an industry everyone loves to hate. Ross and Liz also explore the moral contradictions of “ethical extraction,” the realities of startup life, and how humor—and humility—might be the best renewable resources of all.

This episode's sponsors

Absolute Climate: the only standard that’s developed independent of registries

Philip Lee LLP: legal resources for carbon removal buyers and suppliers

Listen to the RCC episode with Peter Minor from Absolute Climate

Listen to the RCC episode with Ryan Covington from Philip Lee LLP

Become a sponsor by emailing carbon.removal.strategies[at]gmail.com

Sign up for the 9Zero climate coworking space with my referral code

Resources

Endolith's website

Earth in Human Hands: Shaping Our Planet's Future by Dr. David Grinspoon

47: David Grinspoon, Astrobiologist

Geology Cage Match: The Sapiezoic vs. the Anthropocene

Bill Nye

Eukaryogenesis

Abiogenesis

Entropy

Cobalt Red: How the Blood of the Congo Powers Our Lives by Siddharth Kara

The War BelowLithium, Copper, and the Global Battle to Power Our Lives by Ernest Scheyder

Deus ex machina
“If it falls to your lot to be a street sweeper, sweep streets like Michelangelo painted pictures, sweep streets like Beethoven composed music ... Sweep streets like Shakespeare wrote poetry. Sweep streets so well that all the host of heaven and earth will have to pause and say: Here lived a great street sweeper who swept his job well.”

- Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

More from the show

Ad-free episodes and other benefits come with a paid subscription.

Carbon Removal Newsroom, the news show that ran alongside this one, is over. Its episodes are still up, on the feed Climate Workers Anonymous now uses.

Carbon Removal Memes is still goofing around.

The books that come up on this show are collected on my Bookshop shelf.

🎧 Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube

Paid subscribers get this episode ad-free. The ads in the free feed are inserted by Spotify when you press play. They are not in the file I make.



Full Transcript

Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening. This is Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of Reversing Climate Change, the podcast you are listening to right at this very moment. Before we get into the bulk of today's show, I'd love to tell you about our sponsors, Absolute Climate and Philip Lee LLP. I've made great radio with both of them. They should be familiar to you if you listen to this show, but I want to tell you about why you should learn a little bit more. The first sponsor is Absolute Climate. I did a show with their founder, Peter Minor, a few months back. And a lot of people love that show. I was asking a question of, can registries design their own methodologies for carbon markets without it being a conflict of interest? And Absolute Climate's thesis is no. They shouldn't be in the business of doing that. We actually need to disintegrate functionality within carbon markets even further.

Ross Kenyon: They are literally the only independent standards body for carbon removal that exists. Their name is very well chosen. I think they are some of the most aggressively idealistic people within carbon removal. It's come up on Reversing Climate Change so many times about how and why there's tension between commercial teams and science teams within carbon markets. There's some fundamental tension between the rules of running a business, or I should say the rules of running a profitable business is maybe a better way to put that. And climate impact. And I think Absolute is one of those companies that, at least from my experience of what I know of them over there, I think they're going to be some of the staunchest holdouts, just trying to make sure that there can be a justified true belief that a tonne purchased is a tonne truly removed. They're betting big on not compromising.

Ross Kenyon: It's an old strategy. I respect the absolute hell out of that. Absolute is very much doing things their own way and they stand out to me and I will never mistake them in a lineup. Go check them out. I'm seriously fascinated by what they're doing. And that's also true of our other sponsor, Philip Lee LLP. In fact, I told them to pitch me on some weirder legal shows. I really like doing shows about the law. I think the law is such a fascinating part of our shared social life. It structures so much of it. It's badly understood by most people. And just structuring deals within carbon removal is hard. I'm talking grown up deals here. Like when you're trying to put together an enormous package, complicated structuring. A lot of money changing hands. The stakes are high. You really do need a good lawyer. I'm sorry to tell you that if you are a startup out there in carbon removal, you're going to probably pay a fair amount of money to lawyers.

Ross Kenyon: There's just no way around it. Your choice is basically, do you get a bad lawyer or a good lawyer? One really cool thing I can say on Philip Lee LLP's behalf, well, one... Ryan Covington and I did a very fun show about how basically no one except for an elite few really know what bankability and project finance even mean. And he lays it out very clearly. If you'd like to go listen to that show, it's awesome. And it's linked in the show notes. And also we ended up talking about Ernest Hemingway. So it keeps with the tradition of Reversing Climate Change. One also really cool thing is that they just won environmental finances VCM law firm of the year. They've run it three years in a row, 2023, 2024, and 2025. It's the only award for legal teams operating in the VCM, and they have offices in the U.S., Europe, and the U.K.

Ross Kenyon: You should check out Philip Lee LLP. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for listening to this, and thank you to our sponsors. You really make this so that it's something that, in a busy life with lots of competing priorities, I'm able to keep coming back and making more Reversing Climate Change. Thanks so much for what you do, and now, here is the show.

Ross Kenyon: Hello and welcome to the Reversing Climate Change Podcast. I'm Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of Reversing Climate Change, and I've been working in climate tech and carbon removal for the better part of the last decade. Today's show is cool. It's about biomimicry. It's about mining. It's about processing ore. I'm going to tell you all about it. But first, if I could make a quick ask of you, if you love this show, open up your podcast app right now, give it a great rating or review or both. It really helps a lot. Also for $5 a month, you can become a paid subscriber. You get bonus content. It gets rid of all the ads, except for the ones that I read at the beginning of the show myself. And you get to be a power supporter of the show.

Ross Kenyon: Today's show is with Dr. Liz Dennett. Liz is the CEO and founder of Endolith, which is a company that is using microbes to better extract copper from ore. Much of the copper inside of the ore is wasted. It's just not worth the effort of pulling it out of the ore. But with Endolith's system, they can use microbes to make much of that copper much more available. And we need enormous amounts of copper. Elizabeth and I talk about this in the show. Almost no matter what else happens, we're going to need more copper, especially as we begin to electrify so much about our world. One cool thing about Endolith is that literally today, they're announcing that they just raised $13.5 million in a Series A product. At least from the press release I'm reading that there is potentially an oversubscription at hand and there may even be more funds coming in a second tranche. I love plays like this. I love when you're able to use biology to enhance a process and that's what's happening here. Liz is a multidisciplinary person, has had a fascinating career. We start off by talking about how did life originate at all? Some of the basic biochemistry of the world. It's a cool show. We also explore what it's like trying to transform an extractive industry and which levers to pull at which points. Should you be trying to change the entire mining industry? Can you change a plug and play process that makes it much better without trying to change any of the fundamentals? How does one begin to transform an industry as old as civilization itself? Great questions. I hope you enjoy. Here's the show with Liz Dennett.

Ross Kenyon: Liz, thank you for being here.

Liz Dennett: It's truly my pleasure. I'm very excited to be here.

Ross Kenyon: I'm so happy to have you. God, you have so many board games behind you. I don't think I've ever interviewed someone with your background.

Liz Dennett: First time.

Ross Kenyon: Which is funny because you have so many books behind you. And then you said it wasn't even a real background. So Riverside is lying to you. We will get you a copy of this and you too can have the same background.

Liz Dennett: Although I can touch these. These are actually real board games.

Ross Kenyon: People are going to be like, are you weirdly obsessed with Liz Dennett? Like, why do you have her background? And people are going to make this connection. I'm going to look strange.

Liz Dennett: If they do, it'll be amazing. Are you kidding? I'll be like, Dad, you're president of my fan club. If you're listening to this podcast and want to be part of my fan club, wow, that's the most egotistical thing I've ever said. And I am a micro-influencer on LinkedIn.

Ross Kenyon: Micro-influencer? Oh, gosh.

Liz Dennett: Yeah, I have more than just my mom following me on LinkedIn. I have, I don't know, probably 15,000 people that follow along for my stream of consciousness musings that are not written by AI.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah. That's a fair amount. I feel like there's LinkedIn influencers who are obviously bigger than that, but probably for the specialized field in which you traffic, that's probably very impressive.

Liz Dennett: It is actually. It's pretty novel given that most of my postings are like, I have strong thoughts about this niche topic, about copper markets or about microbes or about whatever the daily topic is.

Ross Kenyon: I love that about people, though. I think basically everything is interesting. And if you can get passionate about it, I always love the Martin Luther King Jr. line where he said, if you sweep floors, you sweep that floor like Michelangelo painted ceilings. And if you love biomimicry for mining and mineral extraction, then you paint that ceiling. That's you.

Liz Dennett: These are the friends that I run with. I have a really cool group of friends out here in Denver. And I've had some incredible friends my whole life. And we have the nerdiest conference. I mean, I don't think they're nerdy. I think they're fascinating. But they go down into the weeds very, very quickly.

Ross Kenyon: I like those people too.

Liz Dennett: I mean, some of them can wear my patience. It depends on how good of a listener they are. They have to pair the combination of those things or they're just exhausting. You need the IQ and the EQ, both of them at the same time.

Ross Kenyon: I know. I think the longer in life I hang in there, the more I'm like, hmm, balance is key. One of those dominates over the other, life outcomes decrease in some way. You've clearly discovered something as well, parallel to that.

Liz Dennett: Yeah.

Speaker: It's a good policy. I think that's pretty wise.

Ross Kenyon: Liz, when I look at companies like yours, I have a hard time. Let me put it this way. If it turned out that there was a hidden camera and this was all made up and I just did a podcast with something that doesn't actually make sense, I wouldn't be surprised. I'm like, how could microbes possibly enhance mineral extraction? It sounds made up. I'm like, wow, you're one person, you're valued at like hundreds of millions of dollars, this is crazy. So quick

Liz Dennett: Dinosaurs came in here around your nose, eyebrows died out right before your head. All of humanity is a single hair on the top of your head. So humans are a little blip in terms of geologic time, but microbes are the OGs. They have been doing so much stuff. They are able to oxidize and reduce all redox sensitive elements out there. My PhD was in astrobiology where I worked for NASA looking at how they could oxidize and reduce iron and sulfur phases on early Earth as a proxy for life on Mars. What should you make your head around that? Using them and harnessing them to get more copper out of low-grade ores is not actually that crazy.

Ross Kenyon: Okay, I have to ask you, are you friends with David Grinspoon? Are you guys pals?

Liz Dennett: Yeah. We go way back. We first met at this FameLab competition in 2010, 2011.

Ross Kenyon: Nice. He's been on the podcast a couple of times. I'm one of the top percentile of Earth and Human Hands fanboys out there. I think he's just a, yeah, the view from space, planetary science. It's very represented in this space. I don't know why. It calms me. It encourages me. It helps me. I don't know why people don't lean on it more.

Liz Dennett: One of my life goals was completed at New York Climate Week about two weeks ago when I got to meet Bill Nye in person.

Ross Kenyon: How was that?

Liz Dennett: I knew that I was going to meet him all day. And so I had the full day to prep and mentally like rehearse what I was going to say. I was so ready to play it cool. And there's a series of pictures in a video of him being interviewed and me going up there and just being like.

Ross Kenyon: I'm sure he gets it a lot.

Liz Dennett: Yeah, but normally not for like almost 40 year old CEOs that have also done a fair number of things and are PhDs in their own right. And I was like, well, he's sort of in the millennial pantheon.

Ross Kenyon: I think everyone really is.

Liz Dennett: And like they always say, never meet your heroes. And that is a lie. It was one of the best moments of my entire life.

Ross Kenyon: Wow. I get kind of spiritual, kind of just wowed, and my mind gets blown by just thinking about how eukaryotes came around. Does that do something to you when you look at that too?

Liz Dennett: Yeah. And there's a reason that I grew up in this little tiny town in Alaska, middle of nowhere. My undergrad was in geology, which is actually really funny because I was back up in Alaska last week working with the same geology professor, Dr. Liane Monk, that I first started with 20 plus years ago. So many of these are full circle moments. Fun story. Once upon a time in college, I was an RA in the dorms and I picked up some extra shifts during college to make money. And I was a big fan of science fiction. So I read like every Michael Crichton book that was out there. I read The Andromeda Strain. I read Jurassic Park. And then I was like, I don't really know much about DNA in general. I should take a biology class. And that led me into taking chemistry classes, which eventually led me into this astrobiology field when I was like, this is the coolest thing I've ever done.

Liz Dennett: And there are still frequently, not just the development of eukaryotes, which if listeners are not keen on the ways of eukaryotes, they're actually thought that one prokaryote gobbled up another one and that became the mitochondria. But so many of these pieces of life and how crazy life is just still give me goosebumps thinking about them. A few of them. Us as humans, we are star stuff. We are carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen. The planet as a rocky body mass is oxygen, silica, aluminum, iron. We are not of this planet. We are of the stars. If you look at the elements made by Big Bang nucleosynthesis, they are the carbon, the oxygen, the nitrogen. They are what we are made of. So we are much more like these stars than of the planets. Also, every life organism on Earth had to evolve from one universal common ancestor.

Liz Dennett: And about three point something billion years ago, the Earth had this thing called the Late Heavy Bombardment, which meant that the surface of it was bombarded pretty much liquid, lots of liquid magma, and microbial life survived through that. And if you look at the traits that all life has in common, or if you look at phylogenetic trees, the things that are deeply rooted are thermophilic organisms that can oxidize and reduce iron. And it's thought because those are the only thing that survived that late heavy bombardment. That's why I went on to study them and that's why we think they could have evolved on Mars. Mars was more Earth-like before Earth was Earth-like. Mars had running water, it had rivers, it had the atmosphere, it had everything that we think of as early Earth. Earth had a late heavy bombardment. We were getting the crap beat out of us, whereas Mars was beautiful.

Liz Dennett: And so there's a whole thought called lithopanspermia that life evolved on Mars and came over to Earth, which actually isn't that crazy because if you look at things like asteroids and planetary bodies, they have the building blocks of life, they have amino acids, they have DNA and nucleotides on that. They're not uncommon in the universe, but creating them into self-replicating molecules is very uncommon, or at least that's what we think, given the Fermi paradox and some of the other paradoxes is the uncommon block.

Ross Kenyon: I mean, it just kicks the can, though. Abiogenesis trips me out as well just as much. And how could you get amino acids and heat and whatever and somehow it becomes self-replicating? How could, how? What's like the best theory for why that even happened?

Liz Dennett: Geez, Shakespeare. What's the saying about thousands of monkeys and Shakespeare's? No, I think it's more that entropy always wins and self-regulating molecules typically, and I have friends that are massive experts at this, but if you look at conservation of energy, if you have a system that is going to ultimately be able to have the optimized energy systems, it's going to win out given time. And also we're not looking at all the times life didn't start at hand. Potentially a billion or half a billion years to try and try and try and try again. It's still mind blowing and still crazy, though. But also keep in mind that we all use one chirality of amino acids. We are not evil Star Trek where the other universes and evil Spock use the one handed amino acids. I think they're right handed. We all use left handed amino acids here. So there really is an order to how life has evolved on this planet.

Ross Kenyon: Oh my goodness. I mean, how long was it between prokaryotes and eukaryotes? It's like a billion years or something where it's just like one...

Liz Dennett: No, it's three billion years.

Ross Kenyon: Three billion years? Okay. And then one of them ate another one and somehow it didn't get digested. It just became like teamwork, collaboration. Teamwork makes the dream work.

Liz Dennett: One time. It took three billion years. It happened one time, potentially. Maybe multiple times. It just never divided in the correct way. It only survived one time. And then once we had eukaryotic cells, which, all but pretty much one organism that's eukaryotic uses oxygen as a terminal electron acceptor. So all life on Earth, you need an electron donor, an electron acceptor. Oxygen is the electron acceptor. It's why we breathe oxygen. It gives us so much more energy than anything else. Since microbes are so small, they don't have to use oxygen. Most of them actually thrive in places without oxygen. But to support the cellular mass that you need to be a eukaryote, you need oxygen if you want to get big and strong.

Ross Kenyon: That's cyanobacteria.

Liz Dennett: Thank you. Yeah, we didn't have oxygen until the microbes did it.

Ross Kenyon: So this is inspiring for you. You're looking at all of these planetary, impactful biological processes. You have a geology background, a biology background, and you're just thinking, how can these things combine in this way that can unlock in a biomimicry orientation mining?

Liz Dennett: No, no, that would make way too much sense. That is like us as evolved humans looking back on three, four billion years of evolution and being like, obviously, you did it in this organized system.

Ross Kenyon: I was going to put it in a nice narrative for you.

Liz Dennett: Apparently, there's no narrative. It's chaos. It mimics so much of the evolutionary pathways we're going to talk about, where if you look at how microbes, for instance, microbe, single-celled organism, doesn't have a membrane-bound organelles. If you remember back to your biology, mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell. They don't have mitochondria. But the way microbes move through space is typically there will be like a chemotactic gradient. And a microbe will pick a direction and it will go in that direction and be like, is it better here or is it better there? And it will walk in that direction and be like, okay, it's better here. I'm going to stay here and I'm going to keep doing it. Like the optometrist, better one, better two. And microbes will do this somewhat random walk that ultimately moves them in the position towards whatever chemical or whatever stimulus they want to move in. That's how my career is going. So after my PhD, I was an oil and gas geologist in Houston for a few years, then left for a startup that came to pitch to us. It was the coolest startup I'd ever heard of at the time. Did that for a few years. Was going to get an MBA, but instead decided to learn more about computers and the cloud. So I went to work for Amazon Web Services as an architect. Completely pivoted my career. Did that for a few years and then left to join a company based in Scotland as a VP of Data Architecture and Data Engineering. Then became a CTO of a company called Semvita and then spun this out and decided to become a founder and CEO of Endolith.

Ross Kenyon: Yes, you're making me feel bad. You keep good at all these things, Liz. Can you chill out a little bit?

Liz Dennett: I never thought I was great at any of these. I have been surrounded by absolutely incredible people at all of these who have taken chances on this girl from this little town in Alaska. And that my superpower is not that I, it's very rare that I am the smartest person in the room, but I will work my ass off. Like, I like to think I'm a duck, calm on the surface, but underneath, like, nights, weekends. Four in the morning. So I'm an early morning person. I will outwork anyone I permit. So that's the only thing you can control is your work ethic.

Ross Kenyon: Huh. Okay. Interesting. Well, you're almost too specialized to be a generalist, but it seems like being able to weave together a bunch of these things is probably how you put together the pieces of Endolith. Is it not?

Liz Dennett: I am a little too much ADHD to be anything other than a generalist.

Ross Kenyon: Not a lot of generalists with PhDs in this way. Certainly not STEM PhDs.

Liz Dennett: Oh, science is so cool, though. We got to talk about astrobiology. Like, I don't remember what we're supposed to be talking about, but I'm pretty sure it's the origin of life and all of those things. That's why we're there. I guess.

Ross Kenyon: So why Endolith, though? It sounds like you could have gone a lot of different directions. A lot of things probably could have captured your attention. Why did this seem like the most fun, the most important? Probably both. Why this?

Liz Dennett: Yeah. So once upon a time, I was sitting in a pub in Scotland. It was raining outside. I had a podcast I was doing about the energy transition, and we'd recently recorded one about copper. And I was sitting with some brilliant research analysts about what's going to fuel the zombie apocalypse. And that was really a proxy for what is going to trigger these big challenges in the planet. And I kept thinking it was going to be the lack of potable water, like the lack of fresh water. I know how many gallons of water going to making the chips on my phone. And one of them was like, no, is it going to be copper? And it's like, what are you talking about? We'll just recycle pennies. And they're like, first off, pennies have no copper. Secondly, you don't know about recycling. But we're talking at each other through conductive copper wires.

Liz Dennett: My electric car takes five to 12 times more copper. Copper is the backbone of literally everything in the energy transition. It's very easy to think through rare earth elements being the critical limiter or things like nickel or lithium, but those have much more volatility. There's a lot of other ways we could potentially get to those. But copper, that's the rising tide that lifts all ships. And humans have been using copper since the Bronze Age. Bronze is mostly copper. It has been part and parcel to human development and evolution, pun intended, back to our evolution earlier, for thousands and thousands of years. And because of that, all the good copper is gone. And so at this pub, we were talking about how right now mining companies take rock, they crush it, they spray sulfuric acid on it, they only get about half the copper. And I was like, oh, why don't they just take microbes, like engineer them to get more copper out, ding, ding, boom, Bob's your uncle, we're off to the races.

Liz Dennett: And someone looked at me and was like, I don't know, Liz, we're going to be drinking here with us instead of actually doing that. And I was like, how can it be? Hmm. Spoiler alert, incredibly difficult. But that was one of the nights that I just didn't sleep at all. And I was like, well, this is an inflection point in my life. I'm not getting any younger and I'm child free by choice. So like, what is the impact I want to have on the planet? What is my calling? What is my meaning? And turns out it has to do with bugs and copper.

Ross Kenyon: Is there a synthetic biology component to this?

Liz Dennett: There's a synthetic biology component to everything. Oh, wow. People don't want to know that, by the way. I say that half-jokingly. We are not using engineered microbes like the CRISPR or Cas9. We're not using tweezers to go in there and augment the DNA. We've tried it. We've thought about it. It, for our techniques, is not the best. I have two wonderful dogs here. Here, let me show you. I have Flux and Delta, both chaotic agents of change down here. They're hypoallergenic, bougie-ass labradoodles. I love both of them very much. If we were in a zombie apocalypse, though, these guys would be the first ones out. They'd run up to a zombie, roll over. They want tummy rubs. The worst thing that ever happened to Flux is that his dinner was 20 minutes late one day. Growing up in Alaska, the dogs that we had were these brown mutts from the pound that would thrive in any conditions.

Liz Dennett: They were so great, and they were the best dogs I ever had. That is how I think about these types of microbial communities. Engineered microbes are my wonderful Labradoodle, Cocker Spaniel, Bernadoodle mixes that are specifically designed for very specific conditions like living in a townhouse in downtown Denver. The microbes that we want are not domesticated. They are ones that can thrive. They have cell-to-cell signaling pathways. And so we use this tool called adaptive laboratory evolution, where we take communities that know how to work in a team and we just give them different stimuli so that they can thrive even more. For instance, we'll make the sulfuric acid they're growing in, we'll make it a little bit saltier or we'll expose them to more and more arsenic so that eventually they can thrive in high arsenic ores.

Ross Kenyon: Okay. I'm sure that calms the nerves of some people who are thinking about it. Oh, sorry. Were you going to say something? I didn't mean to cut you off.

Liz Dennett: It's an evolutionary biology technique, but it's not synthetic biology. It also is a lot more effective. There are some cool startups out there that are working with synthetic biology. I tend to find, though, that natural organisms tend to be the best. Those brown mutts, going back to my dog analogy.

Ross Kenyon: In waste rock and waste ore from copper, are these microbes already present? Are you just enhancing them in some way?

Liz Dennett: So there are a lot of bugs that are already present. And we've been fortunate to work with mining customers to just do depth studies of what bugs are there. The right bugs typically are not there. There's massive dysbiosis. Think of it like if you were on a course of antibiotics and your gut microbiome is just completely messed up. That's what these heaps look like after they've been subject to lots and lots of sulfuric acid. So we come in with the right bugs at the right time and we use cloud computing to make sure that we can optimize and change these microbes over time. It's not one bug. It's not one chemical. It's a continuous system that is governed by the same types of cloud architecture practices I learned when I was at Amazon for a few years.

Ross Kenyon: Are these tailings and waste rock, are they just a waste product for these mining companies? Is there any value at all?

Liz Dennett: So what's interesting is that when you go into these massive heaps, so just to take a step back, you crush massive amounts of rocks and you pile them the size of larger than my house. Think of like Empower Stadium. I'm going to use another Denver analogy, but think about any large sports ball arena. These are massive, massive heap leaches where they use irrigation systems to put sulfuric acid on them. Now, the way it works now is these live for upwards of 10, 20 years, and only between 20 and 60% of the copper comes out. By putting microbes in with the sulfuric acid and doing that original production, we're able to get significantly, significantly more copper out.

Ross Kenyon: Are these microbes, do they qualify as extremophiles being in sulfuric acid?

Liz Dennett: They're in sulfuric acid, they're in elevated temperatures, sometimes they're in elevated pressures. All the cool bugs are extremophiles.

Ross Kenyon: Can you not just get rid of the sulfuric acid? Is it necessary for even this process?

Liz Dennett: Well, so the sulfuric acid is what mining companies already use. And our North Star, my North Star as a human, we've talked about this, is to fundamentally get more of these critical minerals like copper into the economy. The best way to do that with mining companies is to be plug and play with what they're already doing. There are some great startups out there that want to completely reinvent the value chain, but mining companies are historically slow moving. They're super cautious. And so we need to go in there and say, hey, we got you, boo. Let's do this. Like, let's pair where you are and make it as easy as possible so that your entire workflow stays the same. We just pump in our bugs, which we've shown are safe. If you were to put a handful of them outside on my patio, they would die very quickly. They're not optimized for these conditions.

Ross Kenyon: I see a lot of startups fall on those rocks pretty hard, actually, of trying to reinvent the entire value chain. And yeah, customers that are slow, plugging and playing in that kind of way. That seems like the way to go. And it seems like the go-to-market has served you well, sounds like.

Liz Dennett: We've been really fortunate to have some incredible customers. We are publicly working with BHP, with Rio Tinto. We're working with six of the other largest copper customers. We have line of sight of at least one field deployment in the next few months. We'll be starting in the U.S. And that really is a great culmination. There's a lot of tailwinds in terms of the critical minerals industry, and we've been able to work with our customers to really leverage those, the need for additional critical minerals in a more clean way.

Ross Kenyon: Hmm. What's it like working with an industry that has not the nicest reputation?

Liz Dennett: Well, I started my career in oil and gas.

Ross Kenyon: So somehow you found one that was even more beloved.

Liz Dennett: Which is actually an interesting cultural paradigm shift because living in Denver, I'm definitely in a different world than I've been anywhere else. And initially when I moved here a few years back and I would tell, trying to make those friends that I talked about, I was like, yeah, I work in mining. They'd be like, oh, mining, why? What's wrong with you? And I was like, oh, but I used to work in oil and gas. And they're like, oh, why would you make such a bad life decision? And I'm like, oh, you guys just don't get it. Like it is not a value judgment. It is an educational opportunity because first off, oil and gas, we are using coal. We're using petrochemicals and so many pharmaceuticals and so many plastics and so many things. Like when I'm climbing mountains with my friends, I'm wearing Gore-Tex. I am using hydrocarbons through and through.

Liz Dennett: But secondly, when we think through the metals and mining industry, there is so much power that comes from meeting customers where they are. For instance, these large mining customers, they have really amazing internal policies around things like child slavery, which I love that I say that half with a smile on my face, but we spend a lot of time as a startup figuring out how we can be the change we want. And as an American that likes to sometimes Amazon Prime stuff, and I use a lot of technology, here's my reMarkable, that has a fair amount of copper and critical minerals in there, it is not fair to abdicate the production of those to developing nations or countries that we don't have oversight on. For instance, if all of our mining was to take place in sub-Saharan Africa and it wasn't line of sight, it wasn't in my mind, that I don't actually think is a great outcome.

Liz Dennett: Part of the reason I'm so keen on domestic critical minerals production is because I like having grown up in Alaska knowing that we can go and see the mines. I like being in Colorado and knowing that we can go and see the mines. It is not an eyesore. It is part of responsible consumption. We have regulations in the U.S. We have OSHA. We have lots of things like child slavery laws and making sure that our consumption is tied to how these critical minerals are being extracted in a way where we can have control over it. I think it's absolutely critical. As soon as you advocate that and say, you know, not my circus, not my monkeys, not my backyard. That's where people that don't have power can have very bad impacts to their life.

Ross Kenyon: I mean, what you're saying is broadly in line with what I understand about harm reduction philosophy, but there are some cases where you don't want to be harm reducing. You actually want abstinence. You want to go cold turkey. Are there any places like that where you think your line of reasoning might lead us to some bad places for your ultimate goals?

Liz Dennett: I think that we should be doing more for recycling. Recycling is a huge opportunity and that is not one that our domestic supply chain and even the production lines that we have are not set up to. When you order a USB cord, it is covered in plastic. It's not easy to recycle any of the critical minerals out of that. I think that we could do a lot more in that space. And I think some laptop brands, for instance, have tried to make parts that are replaceable, but we just have so much planned obsolescence and space and everything we do to grow our GDP. So that is one thing where I think policy and other products

Ross Kenyon: So I've read a lot of horror stories, especially about artisanal cobalt mining in the Congo, and that sounds truly hell on earth and awful, and children being in tunnels that are collapsing. It's horrifying. What would happen though if they just didn't have a cobalt industry? Would they on net be better off? Would it not be better to buy from them but have much better standards that are somehow enforced by the purchasers of this? Maybe that's just impossible and that's a pipe dream. But if it's just going to wealthier Americans for mining, they might on net be worse off if their safety were covered under an alternative regime. How do you make sense of that?

Liz Dennett: Yeah. Honestly, it comes down to a lot of yes in my backyard, yes innovations, the more that we can control our own supply chain. This is a position where I find myself existentially aligned with people that I'm not necessarily politically aligned with in other ways, because the more that we can drive our own destiny here, the more that we can have say over things like who is working in the mines, which sounds like a meme from somewhere, who is working in the mines, but there are atrocities. And the worst thing that happens in mining, like the worst thing that happens if you're in a B2B SaaS startup is like maybe your cloud compute goes down. The worst thing that can happen in a mining company is people die. We have a safety first culture because it's a real risk when you are out there dealing with these very large mine sites.

Liz Dennett: Focusing on new technologies like Endolith, like some other ones, there's a slew of startups that are happening and bringing those from the idea stage to the actual commercialization stage. That enables us to get net access to more resources in places like the U.S. where we can actually drive it. It's a tough road, though. Being a CEO of a mining startup is incredibly, incredibly daunting and challenging, especially since customers are typically not used to change. Going back to a comment you made earlier, starting my career as an oil and gas geologist in Houston and growing up in Alaska, I had to live in a place that didn't necessarily reflect my values. I had to show up with a reusable water bottle and reusable coffee cup and drive my electric car to the office. Actually, I walked to the office and that was such an outlier. And so I think there is something to be said for figuring out where you can act locally.

Liz Dennett: Like what is the boundary of things you can do regardless of anything else? How can you reduce your own consumption? Do you need that extra USB cable? Do you need that new cell phone every six months or every two years? There are still small things. Micro-rebellious activities that we as American citizens with a disproportionate use of these critical minerals can do that aren't always part of the conversation, but every little bit does help.

Ross Kenyon: If we got better at extracting copper out of ore, would it solve the problem? Or would we just Kuznets curve ourselves into using so much more copper and just kind of kick it down the road? Are we going to be satisfied with the amount of copper? Or do we just need so much that it doesn't even matter? We just need an enormous quantity, which is like Ernest Scheyder's book The War Below. Really seeing a lot of how much copper we're going to need and some of those YIMBY fights that are happening over the years. Maybe we just need so much that it doesn't matter because of the curves. We just need it.

Liz Dennett: The answer is probably both. I mean, between now and 2050, we need more than any history of human civilization. Some chip manufacturers are looking at ways that they can reduce their demand on copper some places, but the reality is it is the best non-precious conductor. So anytime you are channeling electrons like the power or like through, I guess we're probably doing bits through my internet, which is fiber optic. I don't think it has any copper. But anytime you relay that, there's always going to be a need for copper, even if we can invent our way around it. However, as humans, we have been evolved to think in front of us. We are used to like, is a predator running at me? Am I stressed? Am I going to make it to see tomorrow? We are not the best at long-term strategic planning beyond what we can immediately see. So balancing those two is something that is probably more for the philosophers.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Liz Dennett: It's a yes answer. You know where you are right now. But yeah, that's the kind of thing that we often get into. Wait, you made a podcast and we started talking about astrobiology and space impact? I like it all. It's all cool. There's basically nothing I don't think is cool. Yeah. And the reality there is we can't just keep using technology as a deus ex machina to say that we are somehow going to be okay. We need to start with our consumption patterns. We need to start at what we ultimately need. Those are very unpopular things to talk about, though, because no one likes to hear that.

Ross Kenyon: Well, so I was asking about harm reduction, because a lot of it sounds like you want to enable better use of existing supply chains so that we can either keep our current consumption or even grow it in the future when we need a lot more copper. But it seems like maybe your heart is split on that. Maybe you actually wish that we could look inside. Like, why are we doing that to ourselves and the planet?

Liz Dennett: I mean, the reality is we need so much more copper and the current way that we get it, half of the copper is just waste and immediately gets sent to the ground. That's like ordering takeout and throwing away half of it. Like there is immediately a way that we can solve that problem. And so that is to me a low hanging fruit that the microbes can easily help us get more copper on. For me, going back to my sphere and things we can influence, if we can do that domestically here in the U.S., places where we can see the safety, we can see that we are able to comply with things like OSHA, that's a no-brainer win-win.

Ross Kenyon: Are there parts of those extractive industries that are resource-oriented that maybe make you feel a little bit icky. Are there things that you see where you're like, I have to do business with people that maybe I don't always see eye to eye with? And maybe that's a very light way of putting it. Maybe you think what they're doing is ultimately putting shareholder value above people or the planet or something else. What do you do with those? And then the option is, do they not?

Liz Dennett: I wanted to make a joke about from a young age, all I ever wanted to be was someone that could maximize shareholder value. Shut up. That's what I've always wanted. But the reality is, I am a founder and CEO of the coolest company I've ever been part of. We have some incredible board members and we don't have to work with customers that we don't want to. And this is the first time in my life that we've been able to do things like our team is 60 or 70% female non-binary. I have purple hair. We don't look and talk like people that aren't like us. And so we are able to align with our values and our code of conduct in a way that I've never had the freedom to do that at any other job I've ever had. And that comes from the top, too.

Liz Dennett: You work at a company where the CEO just wants to get the deal done. The deal is probably going to get done. Say what you want in the meeting. In the all hands, the meeting is still going to, the deal's going to get done. And we have an incredible team. We're 15 people now. We recently brought on board a CFO slash Chief Commercial Officer, Andrew, who's based in Brisbane. Christy, who leads technology, has been in mining for her entire career. We're in the office culture, even though I'm calling in from home today. But we are whiteboarding out ideas. We are very blunt. I always tell people our core values are safety, critical feedback, and snacks. But that critical feedback goes both ways. There are times where I have thought something is the best idea, and Christy has sat me down and said, hey, boss man, absolutely not.

Liz Dennett: And that's what she calls me, boss man. Or Andrew is much more diplomatic and is like, let's think about the holistic ramifications of this. And I think, especially at small companies where you are more nimble and able to do those, having that

Ross Kenyon: No problem. Have you said no to opportunities like that so far?

Liz Dennett: We say no to a lot more opportunities than we say yes to just in general. When I was at Amazon, one of my mentors told me that your career at Amazon is governed not by things you say yes to, but by things you say no to, because there's always so many opportunities. And we have incredible, incredible investors around the table. We are just working and closing out our Series A. And I've told every investor I've met with that, like right now, we get a lot of good critical feedback and we have no massive, around the table, which means we can continue to have these conversations and weigh what our North Stars are, what our one North Star is as a company with how we're able to innovate our technology. And we're going to be able to do that continuously.

Ross Kenyon: I imagine you're probably pretty well positioned for acquisition or to remain independent. I don't know if you do license or do you actually operate your technology?

Liz Dennett: Operate.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah. That they go long term too?

Liz Dennett: Yep.

Ross Kenyon: Cool. What's next?

Liz Dennett: Well, after the round closes, I'm so excited to be done fundraising and to go right back into execution mode. I'm actually hopping on a plane to Australia in a few hours and then I'm going to present at a conference and then we are heads down getting to the field.

Ross Kenyon: You get 18 months off and then you're back to fundraising again. So enjoy it.

Liz Dennett: I know. I love that you say 18 months as if our Series B does not start the week after.

Ross Kenyon: I was being generous. Maybe you get a year. It's like being a politician. You're back on the road here real soon after you get elected.

Liz Dennett: Fundraising is the worst, but in many ways, it's also, living in Denver, we love our type 2 fun. We love things that aren't fun when they're doing it, but are fun after the fact. And so there is nothing, again, to that point about living your values, like pressure testing your commercial models, your business models by investors who mining typically moves like this and VC is typically designed to move like this. And so squaring that circle in a way that aligns with what you want to build is a really cool challenge. And even on the worst days, there's no job I'd rather have. This is the job I've been working my entire life for. The first thing I did when we kicked off for Series A, aside from like obsessing over our pitch deck and stuff, was I made a Spotify playlist. I made our Road to Series A playlist. And I will unabashedly say My Shot from Hamilton is on there because it really does feel like this is our shot. This is our chance to do it. In terms of what the future of the company looks like, I have no idea. I have a fiduciary obligation to deliver shareholder value like we've talked about and do what's best for the company. But it's really fun to grow. It's really fun to build. We ultimately just want to get more of these critical minerals out using these microbes or Earth's oldest miners. Did you say something? Or was that your dog?

Ross Kenyon: No, those are my two dogs who have decided to play right now. See? Say hi, guys.

Liz Dennett: Oh, that's, oh yeah, that's very cute.

Ross Kenyon: Okay, I gotta ask you too, how does Endolith play with the geopolitics of the current moment, with reshoring, with critical minerals? How do you fit into that? That's good for you, I imagine.

Liz Dennett: I mean, when there were first announcements coming out and you can check the newspaper every day and see new big announcements, the first quote that immediately came to mind was like, this is our shot, this is our chance to drive this, but also like, why let a good crisis go to waste? Like, this is our time to really have a seat at the table. One thing that's been really monumental for us is we are part of this Alaska Critical Minerals Accelerator. So my first geology professor, Dr. Liane Monk, I had her as a professor over 20 years ago, and now we are co-PIs together on a grant. Just named an NSF Engine finalist. It's a massive 100 plus million dollar grant with NANA Native Corporation, a lot of the stakeholders up in Alaska to bring our technology to some of these rural environments. And that is something that I've been dreaming of doing since I was a kid, is helping these rural places get access to technology and mining to make their workflows more seamless, more environmentally efficient. And that wouldn't have been possible without the current administration. So that is an unexpected upside. Also, the investors we have around the table, Overture, who came in and co-led our seed round, is very connected to the administration. And then Squadra, who is leading our Series A round, has done so many amazing things in terms of helping us to unlock how we can leverage current policies to get to our field deployments in the U.S.

Ross Kenyon: Wow. That's even the right way to put this, Liz. Sounds like you have to live in multiple worlds here.

Liz Dennett: As a human, we all live in multiple worlds.

Ross Kenyon: I don't know to what degree you're supportive of the administration or not, but even if you have to play along to do business, it seems like maybe you're even able to do that pretty well.

Liz Dennett: I once had an investor tell me on our first or second call that he wasn't sure I looked like someone who could be the face of a billion dollar company because he did not see me playing nicely with certain politicians.

Ross Kenyon: They might discriminate against your hair. I feel like blue hair is a joke among conservatives.

Liz Dennett: It's different. It's more pastel now. But I have had a lot of very, well, let's use comments asking for my thoughts about those things. So it's always funny to hear the different perspectives.

Ross Kenyon: Well, what you just gave me was such a diplomatic answer and the composition of the company too. It sounds like the company is intentionally progressive, at least internally. Working in an extractive industry that is someone that I expect most people shop at either like Brooks Brothers for like the accountant types and then more of like Carhartt for the non. It's like, it's right-coded. You work in a right-coded field, you're left-coded.

Liz Dennett: But yet Gingerbread is coming into this round and they are an incredible syndicate that is based in bringing a lot of diversity into early stage startups, which in many ways to me like this, this amalgamation of America. This is how it should be. The best technology solving the best problems in a way that absolutely makes sense. Like that. The domestication and reshoring for me is really about having safe access and making sure that we are able to move away from child slavery.

Ross Kenyon: It's such an interesting dichotomy. Culturally, Endolith might be some Jackie Robinson for mining kind of play here. Are you expecting to?

Liz Dennett: I'm trying to look at the stickers I just put on the back of my reMarkable. I think we're just like this unicorn riding this triceratops.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah. I imagine there might be some cultural bumps. You seem pretty good at negotiating that. I could see you pulling it off and being charming and exuberant in the exact way that you are being endearing to certain people. A lot worse. Do you feel like you maybe lose opportunities because of some of those attributes that either politically or aesthetically maybe turn off some of the more conservative members of your industry?

Liz Dennett: I honestly don't know. And whenever I start to think about that and start to think about, ooh, should I dye my hair a different color? Should I do this? I just kind of set it down and I'm like, I'm going to continue to focus on our North Star and what we want to do and hire the absolute best team around me. Our team are mining engineers through and through. And with that critical feedback culture, I mean, there have been times they're like, hey, we got this meeting, like we're going to the field. They have their MSHA training. I don't know my MSHA training. They're able to operate safely. They run the point on our customer conversations. So it really is just keeping the dialogue and keeping it open to figure out how we can optimize.

Ross Kenyon: I think that's potentially one of the coolest things about Endolith because I don't know that many people who are going into an industry that maybe feels as distinctly something else and then seems like you have enough capacity. I mean, granted, we're both on stage right now, but you seem like you have enough capacity to have a big enough heart here to maybe try to slowly change some of those attitudes or maybe make some space for yourself and your colleagues. And maybe I'm being unfair to the mining industry. Maybe actually there's a lot of progressive elements in that. I just don't know. This is a reputation. And maybe I'm being unfair to them. But I still think it's the same thing to do.

Liz Dennett: I am on a panel at IMARC, this big international mining conference I'm going to Australia for. I'm on this panel. I am there with BHP and Rio Tinto and Eramet. And it's actually an all-female panel. And I didn't even realize that until someone in LinkedIn commented, all-female panel, go rock stars. And I was like, is it? I guess it is. Which is actually interesting because less than 15% of the mining workforce is female.

Ross Kenyon: 15?

Liz Dennett: 15, one-five, one-five.

Ross Kenyon: Okay, gosh. Okay, that makes more sense.

Liz Dennett: Yeah, our company's more than 50%. But at the same time, if you are going to sacrifice everything in your life to be a startup founder and CEO, you kind of got to take it to your internalized values, which is surrounding myself with the coolest people, having a culture where we laugh. We are going to celebrate closing our Series A round by ordering Domino's and watching KPop Demon Hunters.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Liz Dennett: Just because that feels genuine to what we want to build and who we are. And we take our work incredibly seriously, but you don't have to take every aspect of life so seriously. You don't have time to laugh or make jokes.

Ross Kenyon: Liz, thanks so much for being here. Love learning more about Endolith. Really respect what you're trying to do.

Liz Dennett: That's what, what? You didn't expect David Grinspoon to show up, but no one ever.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah.

Liz Dennett: That's your best timeline. It's fun. So much, Ross.

Ross Kenyon: Thanks, Liz.

Reversing Climate Change is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?