Here’s a quick podcast summary from this week’s episode of the Reversing Climate Change podcast by Ross Kenyon.
If there are so many inhabitable planets in the universe, why haven't we made contact with other civilizations? One terrifying answer is that very few civilizations are able to create world-altering technology without also killing themselves off in the process.
This monologue episode introduces the concept of Great Filter Events through the work of Dr. David Grinspoon's outstanding book, Earth in Human Hands: Shaping Our Planet's Future.
Go read it, and listen to the shows I've done with David Grinspoon in the past! Links below.
“The real problem of humanity is the following: We have Paleolithic emotions, medieval institutions and godlike technology. And it is terrifically dangerous, and it is now approaching a point of crisis overall.”
― E. O. Wilson
This episode's sponsors

Philip Lee LLP: legal resources for carbon removal buyers and suppliers
Arbonics: forestry project developer in the EU
Listen to the RCC episode with Lisett Luik from Arbonics
Become a sponsor by emailing carbon.removal.strategies[at]gmail.com
Use this affiliate link to use Riverside to record your podcasts
Sign up for the 9Zero climate coworking space with my referral code
Resources
Earth in Human Hands: Shaping Our Planet's Future by Dr. David Grinspoon
47: David Grinspoon, Astrobiologist
Geology Cage Match: The Sapiezoic vs. the Anthropocene
S2E15: Are you a wizard or a phophet?—w/ Charles C. Mann
Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI)
The Wizard and the Prophet: Two Remarkable Scientists and Their Dueling Visions to Shape Tomorrow's World by Charles C. Mann
Nuclear War: A Scenario by Annie Jacobsen
More from the show
Ad-free episodes and other benefits come with a paid subscription.
Carbon Removal Newsroom, the news show that ran alongside this one, is over. Its episodes are still up, on the feed Climate Workers Anonymous now uses.
Carbon Removal Memes is still goofing around.
The books that come up on this show are collected on my Bookshop shelf.
🎧 Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube
Paid subscribers get this episode ad-free. The ads in the free feed are inserted by Spotify when you press play. They are not in the file I make.
Full Transcript
Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening to Reversing Climate Change. I'm your host, Ross Kenyon. Before we get going, I'd love to tell you a little bit about our sponsors. They make the show possible. I would love it if you could listen for just a minute while I tell you about Philip Lee LLP and Arbonics. If you work in carbon removal, you very well may have come across Philip Lee LLP's work. I originally saw Philip Lee give a presentation about some of the common provisions within offtake agreements, and I was impressed by the quality of their scholarship and their work. And I'm happy that we're able to stay in touch and finally do this together. I think the law is an underrepresented part of what happens within carbon removal. We assume it's the background. We assume it's the mechanics. It actually takes a very smart and creative person to be a good lawyer.
Ross Kenyon: I think if you've Yeah, absolutely. We're awarded Environmental Finance's VCM Law Firm of the Year for each of the last two previous years. They have offices in the US, Europe, and the UK. If you have business law needs around nature-based carbon projects or engineered ones, if you're working with sustainable aviation fuels and the integration with Corsia, anything to do with the VCM generally, Article 6 of the Paris Agreement. The CRCF that's coming out of the EU now. Get in touch with Philip Lee. If you're working in this space, you really do need a good eye to the law. These projects need legal care. There's a lot of structuring that takes place. It's really not turnkey at this point still. And there's a lot more innovation and creativity that's going to be needed to make sure that the Link is in the show notes. Go check out Philip Lee.
Ross Kenyon: Our other sponsors are Bonix. Bonix is great. They've been on the podcast before. I did a show with Lizette Luik, which I'll link to in the show notes too if you want to go listen to that show I did with Lizette. Bonix is working on forestry in the Baltic states of Europe. Europe used to be much more heavily forested. The great majority of forestry projects take place in the global south, which is generally a good thing. But we also do need forestry to take place in the EU and in Europe as well. Arbonics has put out some great research recently about the state of afforestation projects, about the bottlenecks in the industry, why the high quality credits are selling out far ahead of issuance, what that means for people who want to be buying carbon removal credits for forestry but cannot. It's a really important set of questions that Arbonics addresses with grace.
Ross Kenyon: I would recommend you checking out their work and also just checking out Arbonics in general. If you want to support forestry, give Arbonics a look. Link is in the show notes there. Thanks for listening. And now I will go into the show itself. Thanks for your time. Here it is.
Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks for listening to Reversing Climate Change. This is Ross Kenyon. I am the host. I've been working in carbon removal and climate tech for about eight years now. I love it. I'm obsessed with it. If you're listening, there's a decent chance that you are too. And if you aren't listening, you've been listening for a while, a great rating and review would be massively appreciated by me. Open up the podcast app that you're using right now, write a quick review and Reversing Climate Change is a wonderful show and I love it. Five stars, boom, you're done. Huge value. You could just contribute right back to the show if you spent time listening. It's something that feels minor but is actually really impactful. One other thing you could do to help the show along is becoming a paid subscriber. It's five bucks a month. It gets rid of the programmatic ads. You get bonus content and you get to support the show. There's also a Substack that I recently started. I've been doing little roundups of some of the central themes of the shows that I'm doing. I'd like to publish more essays. I like doing audio essays, essentially, but... Not everyone wants to listen. Sometimes people want to skim something and see if they do want to listen. So Substack is out there now too. The link is in the show notes. Any way you want to choose to support the show is wonderful. It's appreciated. Thank you.
Ross Kenyon: And now I'm going to tell you about a book that changed my life in the way that I see climate work. I actually don't see people talk about this book or this way of seeing very often. I don't know why, because the view from space and the view from planetary science is one of those paradoxes. Yeah, I think that's a good thing. And of Gaia and of the Earth and of everything at the same time. And big in the way that it makes me realize that humanity is in its growing pains and needs to learn how to step up to its role. It needs to learn how to grow into its role as effectively the manager of Earth. And that is an idea that should make you feel a little bit icky. But I think the way in which David Grinspoon talks about it is going to make it less icky than it sounds.
Ross Kenyon: The book is called Earth and Human Hands, Shaping Our Planet's Future by Dr. David Grinspoon. David's been on the show, I think twice in the past, but it's been several years. In fact, I'm probably going to use this episode as a chance to reach back out to him and say, We need to catch up. We need to talk about what's changed since we last spoke. It's a wonderful book. It's huge. I don't even mean in terms of length. I mean, thematically, it's huge. There's a lot that goes into the development of climate science and planetary science as disciplines about how looking at other planets has led us to think more about the feedback loops in planetary systems on Earth and how they can be influenced. It talks about SETI and the search for extraterrestrial life. Talks about what it's like having Carl Sagan almost like as your uncle who's just hanging out at your house as a kid and how could that not help but influence you essentially.
Ross Kenyon: And it also deals with things like the Lovelock, Margulis, Gaia hypothesis. We tend to see the Earth as a series of discrete systems that we can separate from one another, but they're all weirdly connected. Bizarrely so. Did you know hydrology impacts plate tectonics and that if there was less water on Earth, there would actually be less volcanism? I didn't know that. I don't think most people know that the water cycle and volcanism are connected at all. It's one of those things where the more you pick at something, the more you realize how it's all connected. We didn't realize that your gut microflora can cause depression. Interesting. It turns out it can. Or at least there's some sort of correlation there that is happening. These systems are all deeply connected. But the reason I wanted to talk about David Grinspoon's work today is that the title of the book is Earth in Human Hands.
Ross Kenyon: There's both good and bad versions of this. I'll borrow Charles C. Mann's Wizard vs. Prophet terminology for this. He's also a podcast alum. I'll put his show in the show notes if you'd like to go back and check it out. If you're a prophet, the idea that earth is in human hands is a terrifying thing. It's too much power for us. We should turn our back on this much power and retreat from this responsibility that's been thrust upon us. It's godlike. We shouldn't have it. This is when bad things happen, when humans think that they are greater than they are, and this hubris causes our downfall. You know, of all the myths like Icarus, there are so many of them where hubris gets us in trouble and even dabbling, touching, merely grazing the idea that Earth could be in human hands is a sign that we've grown too big for our britches.
Ross Kenyon: We need to retreat. If you're a wizard, you probably think technology will save us, that we're going to grow and develop our way out of all problems, that we'll continue solving problems as we create them, and things are probably gonna be okay, as long as we don't slow down technological and economic development. The idea that the earth is in human hands probably to some sounds like a great opportunity, a great business opportunity. That sounds more cynical than I really mean it to be, but there is a sense of dominion, a biblical dominion here that we're supposed to be fruitful, multiply. You know, bring the world under our plow and manage it for our exclusive benefit. That might be a tiny bit uncharitable. It might not be entirely correct. But I think people who do tend to see technology and economics in this way have a bit more of that Ayn Randian, you know, the human mind is what values.
Ross Kenyon: We should be maximizing for the human mind. And lesser minds incapable of even understanding value should not have a place in determining what the world looks like because they aren't even capable of having that thought. I recognize that's a provocative way of putting this and not everyone who is a wizard has that sort of Randian approach, but that is the extreme version of it. I can be unfair to the prophets if you want to, people who think that, you know, we should just be eating sludge, live in little shacks, not try to develop any technology because any amount of technology puts us in the same spot. It's like as soon as we start experimenting with fire, as soon as the first wheel exists, we're on the road to technological singularity. In our own doom and primitivism is truly the only hope for long duration human sustainability essentially is to never leave Eden.
Ross Kenyon: I think that's sort of the exaggerated position of the prophet. So whatever, I sketched out some extreme versions of both of those ideas. And David Grinspoon is coming into this debate and trying to honor both of those positions as they each have a part of the puzzle. They're each write to some degree about their critiques of the other. And they're seeing this in particular in the light of the Anthropocene, which is a debated stratigraphic term about the epoch or era or eon that we're currently in. There's a lot of debate about is this a small event that's relatively minor? Is this a longer era that is going to be the beginning of a new human-dominated geological time series? Or not? And this is not a question we're going to solve here because stratigraphy is something that people are going to be arguing about for a long time.
Ross Kenyon: Even among people who think we are in the Anthropocene right now, a human dominated geological moment, set of moments, longer than moments. When it even began is open to debate as well. Is it fire, agriculture, the Manhattan Project, going to space, going to the moon? Will it be when artificial general intelligence arrives, if it does arrive? There's a lot of questions about when it would even begin. But the question to Grinspoon is not whether or not we're in the Anthropocene and whether it's an event or an era or some other geological unit of time. The interesting question is, is it going to be a good Anthropocene or not? Is it going to be a mature Anthropocene where we learn how to deal with the power that we now have in our hands? Or is it going to be a period where we collapse in on ourselves and fall apart?
Ross Kenyon: The way that it's often put is that our technology has advanced faster than our political systems have advanced. We're a toddler with a race car, and we really don't know what we're doing. In fact, a toddler with a race car would be relatively safe because I don't think it could operate it. But maybe, I don't know, whatever metaphor you want to stick in there, we're just not prepared for this responsibility. At this point now, we can't easily just walk away from Earth systems and retreat to the caves. The Earth will be fine if we do that. The various feedback loops that balance the Earth's climate will continue at pace. Ecology will adapt. Some ecosystems will die. Some will move. The ones who are able will evolve and life will still continue. Life will not end on Earth almost no matter what else happens. It would have to be incredibly cataclysmic for life to truly die out in this way.
Ross Kenyon: That isn't to say things are going to be great for humans though. Our civilization is adapted to conditions within a fairly small climatic range. And as we get outside of that, it puts pressure on the systems and the expectations that we have built over millennia. What do we need to do to become a civilization that does not rise and fall, but that might actually become permanent? What does it mean to think of ourselves as truly at home on earth and to create the kind of civilization that could persist for tens of thousands of years without incredible danger facing us around ecology and climate and toxicity. And even just things like every so often an object hits the planet. An asteroid killed the dinosaurs 65 million years ago. Those things happen. And with the right technology, we could be monitoring and making sure that that does not happen again.
Ross Kenyon: But rather than looking up to our future, we're very much on a planet that we are strangling and in a pretty fair amount of conflict between ourselves. I'm cautious about looking back and saying things were better back then or things were worse back then and we're so much better off now. I think we're in a very precarious moment in human history. I think it is one of these moments that we're either going to arise to a new level of maturity with regard to how we treat one another and the planet or we might end up hitting a high watermark for human development and go down to a much lower level of complexity. I think that's a real risk for us right now. David Grinspoon is a planetary scientist. He's an astrobiologist. And so in order to frame this discussion about this moment that we're in, about whether we're going to have a good or a mature Anthropocene, he points to two very famous equations, thought experiments that took place within the development of the planetary sciences.
Ross Kenyon: The first is the Drake equation. This was an equation that was put forward by Frank Drake. Trying to calculate the theoretical bounds of how many alien civilizations that might exist that we might be able to reach. Within the Milky Way galaxy, if there's this many stars, and we know that this many stars tend to have inhabitable planets, then how many civilizations might we expect to see out there? The estimates range from thousands to hundreds of millions. And then if you even look beyond the galaxy, the numbers are just mind-boggling. It's hard to even make sense of numbers that big. So if there are that many inhabitable planets, why don't we see evidence of life anywhere? Not even intelligent life, just any amount of life. Because you can look at the atmospheric composition of planets and determine to what degree it's likely that organic life has transformed the atmosphere in some kind of way.
Ross Kenyon: There are signatures you can look for. And obviously, any scientist finding this would be a career-making event to have achieved, and yet it hasn't happened. So why not? Grinspoon points our attention back to another peer of Frank Drake, Enrico Fermi, essentially asking, why aren't there aliens? Like, why don't we see them? Like, we know these numbers are huge. The universe is vast. We should expect to see something. So why don't we see anything? There are a number of great, thought-provoking, terrifying reasons why we may not see life elsewhere in the universe to date. One reason why is that abiogenesis, creating life from a lack of life through amino acids in a stew, it's actually really difficult. It doesn't happen that often. It takes a really long time for these proteins to fold in the right kinds of ways and to combine and for replication to sort of take hold.
Ross Kenyon: It just doesn't happen like we might expect. It's not automatic. That's one explanation. Another explanation is that we're living in a zoo. The aliens know that we're just not ready to become a transplanetary, mature civilization. We're just not there yet. And they're giving us a chance to either work it out for ourselves or they're watching us for their own amusement. That seems maybe less likely because any sufficiently advanced civilization is probably evolved past the point of schadenfreude if they're able to create a stable government on their home planet such that they can pursue exploration of the universe. Another theory is that the universe is super dangerous. Civilizations that broadcast their existence are at great risk of being attacked by marauders. And therefore, civilizations know that the universe is a dangerous neighborhood and they keep quiet. That one's possible. Grinspoon ends up on the optimistic side that any civilization that is able to conquer homeworld politics and expand to become transplanetary is likely not predatory in the way that we might expect.
Ross Kenyon: I don't know. It's a possibility that we Another potential thing that happens here is that there's a number of what are deemed great filter events. These are events that prevent further evolution past a certain point. Or when civilizations reach them, they fail to supersede the problems of the great filter event and produce back to a lower level of complexity or die entirely. Some of them are natural and biochemical in nature. For instance, I don't know if you've ever weirded yourself out about how eukaryotic cells happen to exist where two different organisms combined... And created multicellular life. Took a super long time to go from prokaryotic to eukaryotic life. The first time it happens then, and it sticks, those mutations are passed down genetically, and it radically changes the composition and trajectory of life on the planet. And it's possible that that is a great filter event, that's just natural, biochemical.
Ross Kenyon: If that does not happen, if that random act where rather than being consumed, they end up teaming up in a way that allows for a new type of life, if that doesn't happen, then that's a great filter event that prevents the further evolution of that civilization. There are of course others, but we may be at a great filter event right now. Our technology is powerful. With the arsenal that humans possess, the world could be destroyed or made uninhabitable several times over for many of the creatures on earth. And I know it's easy to ignore the threat of nuclear war, but if you haven't read Anne Jacobson's book about it, it's terrifying. I do recommend. Learning about just how dangerous the North Korean nuclear situation was during the Obama administration and then under the first Trump administration is also dangerous. Really fascinating how close it came and how dicey it's been.
Ross Kenyon: It's not always as far off as people like to think it is. We look back and think of Stop, Drop, and Roll and games like Fallout as being sort of hokey. And we've moved past them, but the threat is not gone. At all. It's easy to forget, but you really shouldn't. And climate change could also just be a great filter event. It's possible that intelligent life and David Grinspoon leaves it open to It's really weird to say a sentence like this in a way that includes humans. And cyanobacteria and also doesn't include the amount of agency that humans have but not cyanobacteria but certain beings change the atmosphere at points cyanobacteria killed off basically the entire planet or very nearly so by oxygenating the atmosphere And humans are doing that by releasing greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. It's not nearly as dramatic as the oxygenation of the atmosphere, at least in my layperson's understanding.
Ross Kenyon: But we haven't grappled with it. The attempts that we've made in good faith to deal with it have not been as serious as we would hope. And then also the world is backsliding and focused much more on security competition and geopolitics right now than climate. There are places in the world where climate policy is advancing, but in much of the world it's retreating. And the great filter event theory here, a thought experiment, imagines that other civilizations get to a point in their development where they're changing the composition of the atmosphere or facing some other change of feedback loops that they are causing or amplifying. And they need to develop the political institutions necessary to manage that before the consequences make their continued civilizational success less likely or impossible. And so humanity right now, if you see it this way, is in a great filter event.
Ross Kenyon: We will either grow in maturity such that we are able to successfully, humanely, with compassion, learn how to work with and manage Earth systems in a way that allows us to exist permanently on Earth. That we're not at risk anymore. Of killing one another or going extinct or killing off the insects that pollinate all of our food or making the ocean so toxic that it will defeat the trophic systems that much of the life in the oceans rests upon. And maybe other civilizations have gotten to this point and maybe most of them fail. That is perhaps the scariest solution to the Fermi Paradox is what if the universe is littered with civilizations much like ours who get to this point in their development and rather than developing the maturity to behave in a way appropriate for a species that is rising To a stage when it has to have a global consciousness in this very specific way and just cannot do it.
Ross Kenyon: We cannot supersede intergroup conflict. We cannot supersede greed. Just fall apart in the face of the biggest challenge that we've ever had. And I find this lesson from David Grinspoon to be incredibly motivating. I find it helps me relax in some ways, but it also lets me know that the stakes here are really humanity can become an organism that can stably exist here in flourishing in a permanent way, or it can't. And our job as people who care about the climate and care about the people who live on this planet is to figure out how we do that. And if we fail to do it, we will be yet another data point in the Fermi Paradox. A civilization passing by might wonder why we're no longer here, why we've reverted to such a lower level of complexity, that we're no longer a civilization that's looking towards the stars, but has failed to develop the maturity necessary to join them on the cosmic stage.
Ross Kenyon: I've been thinking about this book and these ideas for about eight years. I reread Earth in Human Hands recently. It's as amazing as it has ever been. I highly recommend it. It makes me think, it encourages me, and it chills me out. I find it to be a weirdly spiritual book and I think it deserves a much stronger reputation within the climate community. I think this is a book that will help people think about things in a way that maybe they haven't in the past. It's a way of making sense of being both a wizard and a prophet here. What kind of civilization can be permanent for tens of thousands of years to develop permanent defenses for Earth against asteroids that can make sure that the world is not in danger of ecocide or of collapsing insect populations? It's one that is simultaneously wizardly and prophetly.
Ross Kenyon: It takes the best of both of those traditions and focuses on being a humane species that is worthy of that name. I hope you enjoyed this. A great rating and review is always appreciated. Go pick up a copy of Earth in Human Hands. Go listen to the shows that I made with David Grinspoon back in the day. And thanks for listening. I really like these audio essays. I find them to be a fun way to communicate that takes the pressure off of writing and also is more fun. Maybe more personality comes through and you're able to go about your day, maybe think about something new. I'm just glad. I'm glad to be spending the time with you. Thanks so much for listening. Tell a friend if you like this show, and I hope you have a wonderful day.












