Share from 0:00
0:00
/

When carbon dioxide removal technology developers stopped being project developers

One Year of Residual Carbon with Co-Founder Ted Christie-Miller

Episode 391 of the Reversing Climate Change podcast. You can listen to it on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you enjoy your shows. You can also watch the full episode right below this text.

Carbon removal used to have technology developers who were also project developers. But oh, the times they are a-changin'...

What happens when grizzled CDR veterans pluck technology off the shelf and focus on developing projects that produce highly insurable, investable, and offtakeable carbon removal credits?

You get something like Residual Carbon.

Ted Christie-Miller is the cofounder of Residual and is on the show to discuss the lessons he learned from one year as the carbon partner of numerous projects he has under development, as well as his process of raising funds from family offices.

This episode's sponsors

Philip Lee LLP: legal resources for carbon removal buyers and suppliers

Listen to the RCC episode with Ryan Covington from Philip Lee LLP

Rainbow: a developer-centric carbon removal registry

"Why carbon markets need field engineers, not just scientists" on Rainbow

"What scientists actually do in carbon removal" on rosskenyon.com

Resources

Residual Carbon

Peep Show

More from the show

Ad-free episodes and other benefits come with a paid subscription.

Carbon Removal Newsroom, the news show that ran alongside this one, is over. Its episodes are still up, on the feed Climate Workers Anonymous now uses.

Carbon Removal Memes is still goofing around.

The books that come up on this show are collected on my Bookshop shelf.

🎧 Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube

Paid subscribers get this episode ad-free. The ads in the free feed are inserted by Spotify when you press play. They are not in the file I make.


Share


Full Transcript

Ross Kenyon: Thanks so much for tuning in to Reversing Climate Change. I'm the host, Ross Kenyon. I have two sponsors right now, Rainbow and Philip Lee LLP. If you give me a couple minutes, I'll tell you about why they are very relevant to your interests. So listen up. If you follow me on Substack or LinkedIn, you've probably seen me write for Rainbow recently. They have a very idiosyncratic approach to how science is commercialized and how engineering works within carbon removal. And I really like working with them. I've learned a lot from the people there. They're very smart, thoughtful people. And they're aiming to be the most developer-centric registry out there. What's cool about Rainbow is how seriously they take field engineering experience. They aren't there just to write a bunch of detached rules about how things should work in the abstract and then let project developers figure it out.

Ross Kenyon: No, they are very serious about field engineering, about how operations actually work in the real world, and they take a rigorous yet philosophical approach. I'll link to those articles in the show notes in the sponsors section. You should check them out because that will give you a very good idea of why I think Rainbow is a very cool company and one that you should consider doing business with. If you are a project developer and you're thinking about which registry to use for your next project, you should absolutely take a meeting with Rainbow and see if there's a fit there. One thing to keep in mind that is often very important to the project developers that I've interviewed as a result of my work with Rainbow doing customer discovery work, just trying to wrap my head around the opportunities that they're seeing, is how fast their certification process is.

Ross Kenyon: They typically quote around three months to issue carbon credits, which is very short. It goes by lickety-split for registries. So if you're a project developer, you're looking for a registry to use to certify and issue your carbon credits automatically. Take a look at Rainbow. Link's in the show notes. Thanks so much for listening.

Ross Kenyon: I'd also love to tell you about Philip Lee LLP. I really like doing shows about the law. I think the law is such a fascinating part of our shared social life. It structures so much of it. It's badly understood by most people. And just structuring deals within carbon removal is hard. I'm talking grown-up deals here. Like when you're trying to put together an enormous package, complicated structurings, a lot of money changing hands. The stakes are high. You really do need a good lawyer. I'm sorry to tell you that if you are a startup out there in carbon removal, you're going to probably pay a fair amount of money to lawyers. There's just no way around it. Your choice is basically, do you get a bad lawyer or a good lawyer? One really cool thing I can say on Philip Lee LLP's behalf: Ryan Covington and I did a very fun show about how basically no one except for an elite few really know what bankability and project finance even mean.

Ross Kenyon: And he lays it out very clearly. If you'd like to go listen to that show, it's awesome. And it's linked in the show notes. And also we ended up talking about Ernest Hemingway. So it keeps with the tradition of Reversing Climate Change. One also really cool thing is that they just won Environmental Finance's VCM law firm of the year. They've won it three years in a row, 2023, 2024, and 2025. It's the only award for legal teams operating in the VCM, and they have offices in the US, Europe, and the UK. You should check out Philip Lee LLP. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for listening to this, and thank you to our sponsors. You really make this so that it's something that in a busy life with lots of competing priorities, I'm able to keep coming back and making more Reversing Climate Change.

Ross Kenyon: Thanks so much for what you do. And now, here is the show.

Ross Kenyon: Hey, thanks so much for listening to Reversing Climate Change. This is Ross Kenyon. I'm the host of the show and a longtime carbon removal entrepreneur. A short and sweet intro today, but first, a quick plug. If you could please open up your podcast app while it's still open. You haven't started doing something else yet, I hope. And you still have time to give the show five stars on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. If you are on Apple Podcasts, you can write a quick review, which is great. You can follow the show on Substack. And if you're so inclined, for $5 a month, you can become a paid subscriber, for which all of the ads I do not read myself are removed in Spotify. You get bonus content and you have my sincere thanks for helping keep the show going. Today I have with me Ted Christie Miller. Ted is the co-founder of Residual. Before that, he was at B0 Carbon working on ratings for carbon removal. Residual is a project developer. And in fact, they are the carbon partner as a project developer, which is an important distinction within the space. Ted and I explore this topic as well as what Residual is doing and what makes them unique in great detail. I don't feel the need to belabor it much here. Ted, when you tell me that a siren might go by, I think what you're trying to tell me is that you're a very cool urbanite who lives in New York City. I think you're trying to brag about living in the Big Apple, and I just live in provincial little Seattle. Are you trying to pull rank on me?

Ted Christie Miller: I wasn't pulling rank, I promise, but I live on 6th Avenue, which is not the most chilled place, I'd say. So it might happen. Apologies, listeners, in advance if a fire engine interrupts us.

Ross Kenyon: I just heard a very angry car horn. The software might edit that out in the future, but is that your life? How can you possibly do quality project development with people honking their horns like that all day long?

Ted Christie Miller: Well, I'm in the office most days, but I got back at 2am from a site visit last night, so I had a slightly slow morning.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, are you able to say where you were?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, we're going to announce the project quite soon, but we were in Eastern Colombia on a new reforestation project, which we're really excited about, taking an investor around. So yeah, we'll be talking more soon, but it was a great visit.

Ross Kenyon: Oh, cool. Right by the border with Venezuela. Sounds like a safe place to take an investor, Ted. I hope you have good influence.

Ted Christie Miller: There are parts that are less safe, but thankfully, we're in the right spot.

Ross Kenyon: Residual, your company has been operational for a year. You survived a year, Ted.

Ted Christie Miller: I know.

Ross Kenyon: You've done things.

Ted Christie Miller: Just about. Yeah, it's kind of mad thinking it's only been a year. I mean, Laura and I had been obviously plotting for longer than a year, but we unveiled it to the world a year ago.

Ross Kenyon: So how long was the pre-launch period where it was in utero?

Ted Christie Miller: I think it was about five months. Not that long.

Ross Kenyon: Not that long.

Ted Christie Miller: Not that long, yeah. But no, it was good. I mean, it was exciting to start telling the world about it. And I think it can't be underestimated how much value comes in actually just launching because things come from the launch, even if nothing's perfect, yeah.

Ross Kenyon: Oh, yeah. Five months is nothing, though, for the pre-public stealth moments. One of the jokes I had when I was in L.A. previously screenwriting was there's always one friend that you know who's been working on their screenplay for, like, seven years. You're like, will you just finish it and then move on to the next thing? Like, stop talking about it privately. Go do something with it or not. Five months is, you'd be like, oh, okay, I finished the script. It's time to tell the world about it. Let's go. Like, that's a good sign. Not everyone makes it that far at all.

Ted Christie Miller: Well, I'm a deeply impatient person. So I think five months seemed like an eternity to me, but yeah, no, maybe it is. It's not too bad.

Ross Kenyon: Deeply impatient. How does that impact your work at Residual?

Ted Christie Miller: I think being impatient is very useful in the early stages of the business because I do things very fast and we move at a very fast rate. I sort of wonder maybe when you've got a much, much larger business, how useful the impatience is at that point. But I think it's a great kind of fuel for getting things done.

Ross Kenyon: Is it just, you're the workhorse that's driving everyone crazy, calling your prospects 14 times a week, trying to close all the time?

Ted Christie Miller: It's not too bad for prospects, to be fair. But I actually asked Mark, our head of science, I was like, do you think I'm impatient this last week? And he was like, do you know what? I think you talk about it more than I feel it. So I don't know what that says.

Ross Kenyon: Oh, that's nice. So maybe you're a little bit in your head with it, which I have to ask now, do you ever address him and go "Mark"? Do you ever do the Johnson "Mark" to him? This is going to be a niche reference, which I wonder how many listeners will get. I don't think I'm going to have to link to the clip of just the Mark supercut from Johnson from Peep Show. But you're the only person who likes Peep Show more than me, I think.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah. Our Mark, the Mark from Residual, actually got an English girlfriend the last few months and has watched all of Peep Show in the space of about a month, all nine seasons. So he's up to scratch. So he can start quoting, which is good.

Ross Kenyon: If you want to get a job and socially engineer your way into a job at Residual, it turns out you just need to make Peep Show references within Ted's earshot. And then he'll be like, you're in, you bastard. Ted, it's been a year. What have you learned? What a weird year, by the way, it's gotta be like the strangest year to start a company in carbon removal. Like, where are we in the sine wave of the business cycle around carbon removal? What'd you learn? What beat you up? Tell me some things.

Ted Christie Miller: I mean, so much. You could break it up into so many aspects here. On the early stages of fundraising for a business, I think we've learned that it's no use doing it as a sort of part-time gig. You have to devote a good chunk of time to fundraising. And I think you need to think very carefully about who you want in your camp. And I think for us as a business, we made the decision to pursue really strategically useful angels and family offices. And that's actually not a very easy route to go down. It's quite hard to find those different groups and those people. And it requires, I think, a bit of impatience and a bit of hustle and using your friends and contacts and advisors as much as you can because they can be super helpful. So I think spending a bit more time reflecting on what type of capital you want to raise is always useful. I think a lot of people can create a startup and initially they are blown into the venture capital world and they are doing 10 meetings a day trying to meet all the VCs. And I actually think a bit of time thinking about what kind of capital you want is often good.

Ross Kenyon: Maybe for listeners who don't know, what is a family office and how does one approach them? Because they also have a reputation of being notoriously hard to reach. You know, "our people will call your people" kind of relationships. And they're hard to break into and show enough credibility where they necessarily even want to take a first meeting.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, so I think in simple terms, a family office is essentially a fund for private wealth that is often from a family, and often people call it a family office when it's actually just an independent vehicle that is not necessarily for a family. In terms of how to tackle that group, the difference, I think, between them and VCs is often they will be a bit more patient capital. So they'll be able to think more longer term. They also have strategic interests in certain areas. They might have certain focus areas they're interested in. And so if you can build those relationships, it can be really interesting. But for us, it's not very useful for anyone watching to get advice from this, but it was quite random, really. So one of our family offices, Chancellor Hill out of Singapore, they were an investor in one of our project partners.

Ted Christie Miller: So we met them through that. Another was introduced to me by an advisor that we had that I knew who was an investor in B0 where I used to work. He introduced us to the Hacking family office that runs a commodities business out of, well, out of London, but through Africa, really. Arminio Fraga is one of our angels. He's the former president of the Central Bank of Brazil. Laura, she's Brazilian and has deep networks there and got that introduction to him through that. Rupert Soames, who's a very well-known businessman in the UK, is also one of our angels. He's the chairman of the Confederation of British Industry. Similarly, using the networks and building out through that has been the way we do it. And so it's not a very structured process. It's often quite leaning on people for introductions, spending time building those relationships and trying to think about who is strategically useful for what you want to do.

Ted Christie Miller: So for us, having a commodities house in Africa that is invested in us is extremely useful when we want to do business development for African projects, for instance. Our investor in Singapore has great networks across APAC, which we're lacking a bit, both on the buy side and the project-level investment side. So another great, strategically useful investor for us. I think it depends on what you're wanting from the people investing in you.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, I think a lot of people don't spend that much time thinking about that because they're so grateful to have money coming in. It's just like, oh, you want to do this? Oh, that's wonderful. But as a project developer, I know it's pretty difficult to even raise VC money. If you had wanted it, could you have raised a venture round or was that just inaccessible to you, even best case scenario at this time in history?

Ted Christie Miller: I think at the stage we raised, it was basically Laura and I, sort of two people with a slide deck and vibes. And so I think there needed to be quite a lot of personal belief in what our vision was for the people investing in us. And I think we spoke to a number of different VC funds at the time, and I think there was a combination of the type of capital it was, it's quite expensive and they have very specific returns that they want. And also the market sentiment, you know, I think we weren't going to be a fit for most of the VCs, so it wasn't the right route. And I think we were simultaneously going down the strategy that we've been discussing and that seemed more fruitful and had the right kind of investors in our camp.

Ross Kenyon: Good. What kind of projects are you developing? I noticed that Residual has been not super open about what you got cooking over there, but are you even able to say what product types and where?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, for sure. So our initial thesis was really around biomass-based carbon removals. And so the majority of our pipeline is biochar and BECCS. And so they are split across a few different geographies. The Americas broadly is where we're focused. So Laura's Brazilian, as I mentioned, big focus in Brazil. We also have a project in Colombia, we have a project in the US. And then we actually have two projects in Australia as well. I'm half Australian, which has something to do with it. We also have an Australian family office behind us, I think, which helps. We're not constrained by region. It's far more the specifics of the project. What we need to be able to figure out is, does this project have the ingredients of a top, top quality project? If so, we can create the recipe to get them there. And that is not dictated by jurisdiction. It is dictated by the project partner and the fundamentals of the project itself.

Ross Kenyon: I'm so interested in this point specifically because some of the most successful project developers I've spoken with recently have been people who have emphasized repeatability and doing the same thing and making it scalable. So Graphyte doing biochar with these units that you just build in parallel essentially, or Healthier Earth focused on just doing biochar in this one way. You have multiple geographies. I'm talking here about political geographies, multiple jurisdictions that you have to keep track of policy-wise and changes in government that could affect you, but also BECCS and biochar, do those things naturally go together? This is a contrarian take. Why is it a good contrarian take?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, so I think the difference between us and them is we're not owner operators of our projects. So we are the carbon partner for operations. We don't own and operate. So for the names you mentioned, I'm completely with you. For them, it makes 100% sense to be very specific in what you do. For us, it's about taking the learnings from the ratings world and from the insurance world and from the brokering and registry world that our team all have and really injecting that into the project design of projects. And there are some fundamental truths around carbon credit quality that are transferable across different project types. And so there is a need to do that across different areas. And I think if you're looking at us as a business evolving, there's also a benefit in broadening out your coverage over different geographies and different credit types. Because as you know, as well as I, there are many different regulatory regimes which are bubbling away and forming in different ways. There are many different project types that are going to be eligible for these in different places. And so for the future sustainability of our projects and our pipeline, that ability to be eligible for multiple different potential regulated markets, multiple different price points and different credit types actually really plays in our favor when we take those projects to market.

Ross Kenyon: Fascinating. So what is the difference here with being a quote unquote carbon partner? I don't really hear people use that term very often. Maybe define it and explain what's the difference between that and project development as most people understand it.

Ted Christie Miller: If you think about a real estate project that's being developed, we are essentially the architect and the realtor for the project. We're not the owner operator. And so the difference is for us, we typically work with big industrials, big corporates. A lot of the fundamentals of what could be a great project are there. What they don't know is how to design a project which optimizes not just for registry clearing, but can get you a top rating, a low insurance premium, and can really create a project which is targeted towards those top buyers. And so that's where we will step in and we partner with them and we have a very vested interest in the project's success because 95% of our revenue comes from the project going to market and we are the partner for them. So think of us like the carbon side in a box and we are really in the trenches with our project partners. We will have some seeming deliverables when we go into a partnership, but in practice, they go so over and above what that entails, because at the end of the day, we want to do our best for these projects and make sure that they have the best chance of success. And so we will go over and above to achieve that for anything we work on.

Ross Kenyon: Okay. This type of project development seems venture backable though, because it sounds capital light. You're not financing this off of your balance sheet. And it seems like you're able to scale this expertise. You're almost like the financial legal business layer that's helping people with a load of bagasse sitting around. How do you turn that into something valuable for them and for you? That's a different kind of service. It's not even project development. Call it the carbon partner. But that seems like something that could raise venture funding. The way that I compare this is that project development is infinitesimals in calculus or something where it's not venture backable. But if you stack a ton of them up together, sometimes it becomes venture-backable if you're able to get enough of these small things together. Does it actually play out like that? Could you not have just raised venture funding in this way? This is wishful thinking. Also, it's four different questions on top of itself, so sorry.

Ted Christie Miller: Good luck. I think it could be venture-backable. It's more just, I think, the way that normally venture thinks about things is through the lens of software. And so when you take on, let's say you raise a lot of money from a venture capital firm, they may steer you into a route that is trying to make a SaaS product that does X, Y, and Z, and they change your revenue model. We have a very standard carbon asset development model. It's not that new for our market. There's others that have done it in former iterations of the carbon market. And I think that it can be more challenging for them to get their heads around. But I agree with you. I think the beauty of the model of doing a company like this is actually these are projects that last 20, 30 years in some cases. And so there are quite long term sustainable revenue streams that can come from this if you bet on the carbon market.

Ted Christie Miller: And so I think it definitely could be. I think you know as well as I do, venture has grown kind of weary of the carbon market in recent years. So I think to be confirmed how much venture capital there is around for this. And I think we've had such a good experience with the family offices that we've brought in and we're exploring a number of different project level financing mechanisms to help fund the business. I think there's other routes as well. I think that's what I want to also tell people, that there are other worlds. I think venture definitely has a place. It should probably be 20% rather than 80% of the funding of these businesses. But yeah, I think for us at the moment, the route we're going down is working.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, I'm not necessarily saying you should have gone that route, so much as saying that your model actually sounds more like SaaS than maybe you want to admit. Am I able to say how many projects you have under contract? Am I able to say that or not?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, we've got seven.

Ross Kenyon: Okay. So right now you have seven projects under contract and that's after a year. And I imagine that that number could probably go up quite a lot and the parabola could get steeper for how many projects that you have under contract. And I imagine you're probably also going to bring in more software to help manage some of these relationships and track these things. That starts looking more like SaaS than it does like project development or some of the other things that handicap the venture relationships within carbon removal. The macro stuff still might not make sense. Also, if you don't need to take venture dollars, then you really shouldn't. Lucky you that you don't even have to get into that process in the first place.

Ted Christie Miller: I think the SaaS point is more about your revenue model. It's literally software as a service. Our revenue model is baked into credit sales. So I think that's just the fundamental difference. On tech, the software side is central to what we do. So Laura, my business partner, has solo-deved the entire Residual platform, which is where we're going to start being more public about, but it's actually where all of our projects will live for buyers and investors. And it will also have a lot of the tools that we use as a business to create one place where we are bringing our data, bringing our projects and taking them out to the world. But it's not something we talk too much about publicly at the moment. I think it will be more and more so, but it will no doubt help us do our jobs better and more efficiently in time.

Ross Kenyon: You don't want to be down on the ground making biochar yourself. You want to just be doing sales. That's kind of where you want to be.

Ted Christie Miller: We're designing the projects.

Ross Kenyon: But you're also the realtor though. Is that you? Do you like doing that part of the thing?

Ted Christie Miller: So for us, I call us the architect and the realtor because we are the shop front, right? We are definitely going to use intermediaries. We have partnerships we're building with all of the major intermediaries. We're not pure play brokers. We'll never go into a deal where we're not designing the project as well. So for us, that's central. I think it's best to be the shop front. If we're working with a big agricultural firm in Brazil, let's say, they don't know the right intermediaries to go for. They don't know the top buyers that we're writing in the RFPs for. They don't know how to frame things in the right way. We do because a lot of them are our former clients. And so it just makes so much sense to also be that shop front.

Ross Kenyon: It's funny that you think about the architecting of these projects. There are people who are off stream and grain and people who are just trying to be like, what does your path to credits look like and what are your various revenue opportunities here? And also we have all these connections that we can make sure that you have the right intermediary relationships potentially and set these things up for you to make sure that this is not just something that you have to figure out yourself, but it has more of a turnkey basis. You are like that.

Ted Christie Miller: The difference is that we're the project designers, we're on the ground, we're like the carbon team in the actual project. So we are there making the decisions, doing technology selection, doing all the feasibility, doing all the project design work, taking it through registries, taking it through ratings. It's a lot more of a partnership than a service. And so that's how it's different.

Ross Kenyon: And then it sounds like your revenue model is based primarily on credits being issued, being sold. I mean, that's probably being sold. Is that how you're doing things?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, sold.

Ross Kenyon: Did you have any big pivots this year that you're like, that's not going to work? What do we do now?

Ted Christie Miller: Big pivots? I think there are project types that we are expanding out into that, I wouldn't say a pivot, but more of a broadening, I'd say, of what we're looking at. So I'd say that that's one. One thing that is new, I mentioned that reforestation project we're doing, there will be others as well in the months to come. So I think that's the main one, thinking a bit more about where we can have our impact across different areas. I think the central thing for us is we want to work on projects which have, as I said, that recipe of what high quality can be, the ingredients of what high quality can be, so we can get them there, and they need to be deliverable. That's the central thing for us. So we want to look at a project and know we can make this one of the top quality credits in the market that's going to attract the top buyers, but also it's going to actually deliver before my grandchildren are here. And so that's the key point.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, this is one thing that I've long admired about Residual, but also every serious project developer. I might include you in that category, even though I know it's a little bit of a technical distinction here, because I think a lot of people decide which type of carbon removal they want to do based upon something like this. I live in Oregon. I like biochar. Therefore, I'm going to do biochar in Oregon. You're like, okay, that's very convenient. This will require a lot of uprooting, but is that really the best place to do it? I think if you come at it from the way that you're thinking about it, you're able to just engineer projects where you're like, cool, this is going to be well received by the only buyers who are buying, is going to have a low insurance rate, like the premiums are going to be low, and we're going to be able to not have to carry this on our balance sheet or just have this in consignment for a long period of time. Like we're going to be able to offload this easily. And I wish more people came about it in that kind of way, because that's how most businesses do it. Like if you build it, they will come, not good go-to-market. But what you're doing seems like the other end of the telescope. Am I right about that?

Ted Christie Miller: 100%. So I think that's what we also discussed when Laura and I first had a breakfast that turned into a lunch that then turned into a business a few years ago. And so even on that day, I think one of the first things we talked about is how the carbon market does not think about product market fit. They develop a product without worrying about where it's going to fit into the market. I think no other market operates like that. And so what we're really bringing is PMF to the carbon market, designing projects which are optimized for sales and optimized for capitalizing that financing. And that's really how we're going to unlock really high quality projects at scale and have very meaningful removals and reductions in the years to come.

Ross Kenyon: Tell me about how you unlock the financing portion of this.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah. So when you're looking at, let's take a biochar project, for instance, to get to a level where you're going to get project level financing, either equity or debt or prepay or whatever it might be, there's a lot of early stage feasibility work, financial modeling, carbon modeling, tech selection, education, really, to get to that phase. And that is for our projects where we will come in and do some of that critical work that can stand up in front of big investors. And so that's one of the central pieces of what we work on. Alongside that, we also know the big investors in this space, a lot of them were previous clients of ours. And so we can bring them in to look at projects we're working on. And as I mentioned, we were on a site visit with an investor just this last week, chatting to others for different projects as well. And so that's a critical problem in the market, getting to that stage where you can raise project level financing. And that's really what we can help unlock.

Ross Kenyon: Hmm. My understanding of what blocks a lot of project finance is that even with an offtake, they're just not bankable because there's so much in the way of buyer protections that just make it so no one's going to finance a deal like that. Are you able to take on some of that risk or somehow make it so that contracts that would otherwise not be bankable somehow become bankable? Is there some sort of financial innovation that's happening at the Residual level?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, I mean, debt can be difficult on some of those offtakes, but there's plenty of offtakes that have raised debt off the back of it. I think it's how you structure those deals. So we have one of the top law firms in the country that does a lot of these structurings. There's our law firm. And so as we go and work on those offtake deals, they're going to be watertight. So you can then raise debt off the back of them if that's what you wish to do. But there's also other sources of capital. There are a lot of funds that will do big prepays, like commodities houses or more like trading entities. So bringing them in to look at these projects, and they can take on more risk because they're getting higher returns. There's also other sources of equity you can look at. So it's thinking beyond the standard debt model on an offtake, thinking more creatively about how you can fund these projects.

Ross Kenyon: Yes, I can imagine that someone listening probably would rewind the podcast at this point and be like, what are these other sources? How do I get into their pipeline? How do these other sources of project finance work that is not just raising debt off of an offtake?

Ted Christie Miller: Well, if you look at, let's take someone like a big commodities house, right? They will fund a project.

Ross Kenyon: Like Glencore is who you have in mind when you're saying that?

Ted Christie Miller: Glencore, Trafigura, Mercuria, those types of people, they will often do large prepays. They'll pay for the first tranche, and they will take a credit share out of the back end and they become sort of project partners. So that's one example of doing project level financing. Another is someone like Terra Natural Capital. They are quite creative about how they think about things. Once you've got an offtake in particular, they then think about how to structure a sort of blended model that is going to be successful for them and for the project partner. And then you've also got the more traditional, the banks. You can even look at outcome bonds, if you can get the World Bank involved. There are many different innovations that are happening in the market today. It is quite, I don't know, disordered, I suppose. That's not a word. It's not that structured. It's not very easy. You can't be like, oh, I'm just going to go and knock on all these doors and my project's going to be financed. It does require a bit of building out the network, figuring out who's looking at what, and trying to be a bit creative to get some of these projects funded.

Ross Kenyon: Most of the structures that you name are things like fixed income instruments that relate to green bonds and stuff like that. I associate that very strongly with carbon markets, but not in carbon removal. I just hear about it way, way less than I should. Are these deals taking place in the background and people are just NDA'd and aren't talking about it? Or are they still in the works, but maybe not mainstream yet? What's actually the status of many of these deals?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, I think it's the latter. A lot of them are in the works and not mainstream, but I don't know if I can name any of the banks, but I know three banks that are working on outcome bonds to fund a number of different project types. And so the people are looking at it for sure, but it is still early days and they're trying to understand what risks they can take on.

Ross Kenyon: So many questions about that. That's really interesting. Is that something that you think will make a splash in 2026? Is it farther out than that? When do you expect some of these new instrument types to be accessible to people in our space?

Ted Christie Miller: I think there'll be some announcements this year, but you've even seen some innovations. If you look at the Barclays Undo deal, Standard Chartered Undo deals, they have quite innovative structures that have been put together. I know Curate were helping to do that. So I think we've already seen some precedent. I think there'll be more of those across different project types. And yeah, I think in the ramp up to 2030, you'll hear that more and more.

Ross Kenyon: That sounds very optimistic, Ted, given that you found it in such a crazy year and even the last month, well, I guess two months now, we're talking at the end of February, weird start to the year. You don't feel like that's impacted your assessment of the direction of carbon removal and carbon markets.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, do you know what? I think I'm kind of bullish because the way I see it, the market is correcting rather than collapsing. If you look at particularly the analysis done by the ratings agencies, this isn't just B0, but also Calyx and Sylvera. What you can see is demand is flocking towards top quality credits. And so while the market looks like it's stagnating, underneath the hood, that's the collapse of energy offsets mostly. And it's the massive increase in CDR and really high quality avoidance. And so I think that's a natural maturation of the market. And I'm sort of hopeful about that. I think that's where we need to go if we're going to be able to scale it further.

Ross Kenyon: Yeah, well, it sounds like you are seeing good analysis and green shoots in places where you feel like you are exactly where you should be. Your business is well positioned to grow into 2026 and beyond. And if you were offering advice to companies, a lot of project developers and tech developers both listen to this show, what should they be looking out for and how can they learn from Residual's experience?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah. I think for developers, thinking as much as possible about risk at the very, very early days of a project is going to be really important. Too many projects used to come to me for carbon ratings, and they had not really de-risked their project to those standards. And it meant that they didn't have good outcomes and a lot of them don't exist today. And so I think really thinking about carbon risk, delivery risk, financing risk, all of these things at the early stages before you take a project to market is going to be really important. I also think having a finger on the pulse of those regulated markets is going to be key. You know, as things evolve, whether it's CORSIA or Article 6, being close to that and seeing the jurisdictions, the project types that are coming into the fold is going to be ever more important.

Ross Kenyon: Gearing up for the compliance market. I mean, people are doing that. Pretty much everyone who can get a Japanese company on their cap table seemingly has done so. I like gearing up for how do we integrate with Japan. People are watching how the EU ETS integration is going to play out and how they're going to be able to do that. It's a long time to get from here to there, though. Any thoughts on staying alive until then and being able to grow and show sufficient traction to have uptake during that time when it arrives?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, I think being laser focused on delivery, like the only way we get paid collectively is by these credits coming to market and finding a buyer. So just laser focused on high quality delivery for developers, I'd say.

Ross Kenyon: What does that mean? Is that about speed? Is it something else?

Ted Christie Miller: I think it's about speed. Yeah, it's about having the right expertise in your team as well, having the right advisors as well. I think it's about thinking when you're marketing your project, okay, how can I get the best price? How can I get the right buyers? I used to see day in, day out the power that a carbon rating, for instance, could have in unlocking those big buyers. You know, when I was in that role, I signed on Microsoft as a client and B0 still does the diligence for Microsoft. And I really see the value of those third party opinions. So for developers of all stripes, I do think that is still a very valuable marketing tool that helps you differentiate in the market, because that differentiation is going to be really key.

Ross Kenyon: I like the point that we were talking about earlier, being able to focus on, okay, how do we choose a project type? We know we want to do something in carbon removal. How do we do something that's going to get the highest possible rating here? I wish people would do more of that. I think a lot of it is maybe the culture where a lot of the tech transfer office, tech development work comes from scientists and engineers working at universities and they have a thing that they've been working on and then they try to commercialize it and spin it out. That kind of way of going into carbon removal doesn't lend itself to, okay, this is the entire space. Okay, there's tonnes of biomass over here. What's the highest value use of it? Is this a team to execute it? Can we do this? Will someone buy it at the end? Go. What's stopping us from just having an industry full of people hardcore focused on it from that angle?

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, I think it's a complex question and a hard one to figure out, and that's why we've got a business, at the end of the day.

Ross Kenyon: If everyone else is doing it, what would you be doing, Ted? You'd have to find something else to do. What's your second choice?

Ted Christie Miller: What was my second choice? I don't know, maybe something in food.

Ross Kenyon: Food? What? Because your sister's a bean entrepreneur, right? The queen.

Ted Christie Miller: Maybe I couldn't go into food because it's too close to that, you know.

Ross Kenyon: I saw her hanging with Yadamato Lenghi talking beans, not lying. I'm like, dang, Tess, like a superstar family here.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, yeah. She puts me to shame. She's the real, she's the queen.

Ross Kenyon: Okay, so your answer's not serious about tech development, though. It's like maybe a distorting way of going into carbon removal.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, and I think for us, we are seasoned carbon experts, and so it's bringing that into the development side, which I don't think there's enough of, really, these days, especially in the project types we're looking at. So, yeah, I suppose it's a similar ethos, for sure.

Ross Kenyon: Thanks for being here, Ted. Glad we finally got to do this. It only took us probably a full year since we've been talking about doing this, it seems like.

Ted Christie Miller: Yeah, thanks very much, Ross, and keep up the good work.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?